Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Talk Instruments (https://www.musicbanter.com/talk-instruments/)
-   -   How hard is it to learn to play the guitar? (https://www.musicbanter.com/talk-instruments/65019-how-hard-learn-play-guitar.html)

Viazon 09-20-2012 04:46 PM

How hard is it to learn to play the guitar?
 
Learning to play guitar is something I have always wanted to do. But I know what I am like. I have no discipline and I give up way to easily. But it has always been something I want to do.

How easy is it to teach yourself to play guitar? Are there any people here who were self taught?

prmtherocker 09-20-2012 10:39 PM

I am self taught guitarist but believe me learning to play guitar is very hard than other instruments like piano, drums, etc. But if you dedication and interest you can surely be a pro. Persistence is the key. Never give up at first because "Everything is hard before its easy."

There are lot of ebooks, videos and learning stuffs all over the internet. I mostly learned myself using Guitar Pro.

Neapolitan 09-20-2012 11:31 PM

It all depends where you want to go with it. If you just want to strum a few chords to a song and you own a decent instrument to play on it can be fairly easy. On the other hand if you want to get more involved and learn lead guitar for Rock, Metal or Country it can be somewhat difficult.

phoenix17 09-22-2012 02:52 AM

It's easy to learn. Just takes a lot of time to train your mind and hands. There's a lot of online resources available now to self-teaching guitar.

mr dave 09-22-2012 07:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Viazon (Post 1233055)
I have no discipline and I give up way to easily.

You need to address this first because if you're going to try teaching yourself any instrument you will only get what you put into it. If you can't be bothered to pick it up and practice you're never going to develop into anything worthwhile.

Learning the most basic functions and theory of the instrument isn't that hard, but unless you practice those elements it's never going to matter. I used to buy every copy of any guitar magazine that had tablature in it back in the 90s. Whether I knew the song or not it didn't matter, I'd sit there and play through the tab just to learn new licks or to see how different parts were put together.

Getting a teacher also won't change the fact that the ability to play the instrument is still entirely your responsibility and directly related to how much you choose to play it.

Plankton 09-22-2012 07:48 AM

^wut he said^

Was gonna pull that little gem out of that post too.

blastingas10 09-22-2012 10:22 AM

It's not easy at all. It's all about patience and discipline. It's really satisfying to look back and see how far you've come and it makes it all worth it. From my experience, guitar is harder than the only other instrument I have experience with which is piano. When you have a ****ty guitar with really high action, changing chords can be a big task. I found it to be a lot easier on piano, but I know they both have their own aspects that make them difficult.

Howard the Duck 09-23-2012 03:12 AM

i'm half-self-taught and half received lessons

strumming a few basic chords is easy

and that's all you need in punk, really

ferdie_poly 09-23-2012 05:22 AM

aside from discipline, I think inspiration plays a major role in learning how to play guitar

The 5th Horseman 09-25-2012 04:35 PM

Learning to play guitar is hard typically. Ive been playing for 8 years, piano for 10. Ive been giving private music lessons for near 6 years now and have had all types of students.

When learning to play guitar, at first, your fingers will hurt due to not being calloused. Once youget past that, depending on what you want to learn, it can be difficult to build dexterity, speed and playing cleanly. You can just jump into playing guitar and be steve vai in a month or 2. Once you get past the intermediate stuff, comes learning how to play outside of the scale boxes, along with playing melodic lines in tandem with chords (think hendrix, john mayer, etc).

All of that being said, if youve got the will and drive and inspiration, playing guitar can be very rewarding and very fun.

As a closing statement, if you are really interested in playing or learning an instrument, I very strongly suggest learning piano first. This is because Piano is a relatively easy instrument to learn due to the fact that you can actually see all of the pitches laid out sequentially as opposed to the guitar which has overlapping tones depending on what string youre on and where you are on the fretboard. A lot of the time, playing piano will make a lot more sense to someone who doesnt have any musical training.

Hope this has helped.

Scorpiousfrank 09-25-2012 08:36 PM

I'm self taught. My parents were against it (still are), but then when I showed then I could play a few chords, they quickly left me to my own devices. Learning on your own can be tough.

What you need is a lot of imagination. Without this, you won't be getting anywhere. Quick chord changes call for imagining the next chord you want you play in your mind while you're still playing the current one.

Self taught also means that you tend to rely on power chords more often than other chords. You may find the others too hard and you may not have any motivation. The best cure for this will be to figure out the chords to some song and then check them out with Ultimate Guitar Tabs. Don't go for Guitar Pro. A few of the tabbed ones will be very tough for a beginner.

Another thing to remember is to start easy. Start with C, G, A, D chords. Learn to switch between them quickly.

The other thing you need to keep in mind is that you need to practice. Without that, you'll be getting nowhere. Another thing is that when you're not close to a guitar, imagine playing one, picture the fingering of the chords in your mind and then strum an imaginary guitar.

Each free moment you get could be utilised to practice switching chords. Switching chords should become flesh memory. You shouldn't even think twice about looking down at the fret board to see your finger positions; you should just be able to get it right on the first try.

And last of all, good luck! You'll need it.

Sent from my GT-S5360 using Tapatalk 2

ThisIsMyLove 09-26-2012 06:50 AM

If you learn how to read tabs, which should take about 10 minutes then pick an easy song to start with you're on your way. I chose Zombie by The Cranberries and was playing to a decent standard within a couple of months. 2 years on and I was lead in a reasonably successful band. Not one lesson.

Public 10-20-2012 06:35 AM

Depending on how you see playing on guitar.

I learnt it by myself through hitting the strings in various ways while listening to it on headphones. Then I found out how to tune it and later tried to play something simple, like grunge music or creating my own stuff (ballades mostly).
It's all about getting a nice grip on your fingers and be organized when hitting the strings.

Then I started recording my ideas and through this I quickly made my first tracks with guitars, which sounded pretty decent.

Isbjørn 10-20-2012 11:29 AM

It's not that hard, but you'll have to take the time. Take a guitar course, watch internet tutorials, and take online lessons. I did all of these, and now I'm a decent guitarist. Not on professional level though.

Howard the Duck 10-21-2012 05:21 AM

not hard at all, just takes effort

blastingas10 10-21-2012 10:06 AM

Not hard at all? I beg to differ. Sure, it's not rocket science or anything but it's not easy by any means. You're right when it say it takes effort, that's pretty much it. A lot of effort, time, desire and patience. Learning and playing are two different beasts. I can get on YouTube and learn how to play some more difficult songs, but once you want to start writing your own music, that's when you encounter that different beast. There's no much you can do.

Howard the Duck 10-22-2012 08:30 AM

try singing - much harder

i'm learning to sing at the moment

The Bullet 10-23-2012 06:59 PM

That really boils down to onw simple, basic question: how good do you really want to be?

Spoiler for Long rant that can be summerized in the two sentances below::
If you want to learn how to accompany your singing? Eh, should take two years max with occasional practice. I've seen it done in months. Still, you'll have to throw in that occasional practice.

If you want to really play guitar, it takes a lot longer and takes consistant, focused effort. Maybe it isn't hard as much as it just takes dedication, but if you really have no dedication, you'll throw away your guitar before you can even play like Taylor Swift. Just as a warning. I've seen people ask me to teach them and give up after they can't play a simple song in a week. A basic level does not take long to achieve AT ALL, but people seem to think it takes even less than it does. They think they'll get it one day as opposed to one year. Wrong.


Not to mention that there's some people who simply won't be able to do it just like some people can't whistle, even if they work at it hard and play other instruments well. I've seen that happen, too.

I've been playing for five years, I practice every day, and I usually warm-up my practice sessions by playing the first "Jump In The Fire" (Metallica) solo without making any mistakes (double speed on a very good day, but that's rare.) And, quite frankly, that's nowhere near as impressive as it sounds. I don't consider myself to be anywhere near as good as most people who take it as seriously as I do who I find myself jamming with. I constantly find myself realising I suck more than I thought I did the day before. I know, that relative to my lifetime, five years is a microscopic blip, but that's all I've played so far. I shoot for the skies because, although my life has plenty of time to change and my love for the guitar may change, I love playing and I would love to play for a living some day.

My point is, the better you want to be, the longer it takes. If you want to be at a professional level, that takes no less time than training to be a major league athlete, as I remember a group of three world-renounded jazz musicians, who I won't specify incase someone can track me down based off of their names, telling me and a crowd of about two-hundred other amateur musicians. they basically spent two hours saying "none of you guys play enough, and when you do, you play along to your iTunes instead of going out and forming bands." Unfortunately, that was pretty true of everyone, including me.


Take your pick. The more skill you want, the more time you'll have to put in.

GuitarHeroFan101 10-23-2012 11:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Howard the Duck (Post 1242508)
not hard at all, just takes effort

and patience. I actually learned pretty quickly. My friend showed me how to play guitar, and after a couple weeks, I was playing songs like "Sweet Home Alabama" and "Gimmie Three Steps". I can only play parts of songs, though.

Alie 10-26-2012 07:45 AM

It was not difficult for me, but I wasn't self taught, my boyfriend tought me... I think if you really want to you'll manage doing it!

GrapeSoda 11-19-2012 07:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Howard the Duck (Post 1242508)
not hard at all, just takes effort

Or the spirit of jad fair

*david fair whoops

Ohwarriorx1 11-19-2012 10:57 PM

Pretty Damn hard. For me anyways

ThePhanastasio 11-19-2012 11:30 PM

Just weighing in with my personal experience:

Guitar is difficult. When you first start, it's going to be extremely frustrating and you're probably going to be convinced you can never switch between chords or even learn chords that aren't G, C, D, A, Am, Dm, G7, because your hands won't want to move that way, and your fingertips will feel like they're being murdered. That lasts for weeks.

After that, you'll suddenly realize that you can play all manner of other chords with a little bit of practice, and your fingers don't hurt anymore. Suddenly, it seems like it just happens one day, you're able to switch between chords and that F chord is cupcake city.

After that, you've got a nice foundation to continue, and you can pretty much look up tabs and kind of know what you're doing. And it's just up from there! You just have to understand that it's going to take a little while for it to feel natural, but from there, it's going to be fine. You're not going to be able to shred like Malmsteen off the bat - or maybe ever - but you will be able to strum an acoustic at a campfire LIKE A BOSS.

GrapeSoda 11-22-2012 04:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ThePhanastasio (Post 1252302)
Just weighing in with my personal experience:

Guitar is difficult. When you first start, it's going to be extremely frustrating and you're probably going to be convinced you can never switch between chords or even learn chords that aren't G, C, D, A, Am, Dm, G7, because your hands won't want to move that way, and your fingertips will feel like they're being murdered. That lasts for weeks.

After that, you'll suddenly realize that you can play all manner of other chords with a little bit of practice, and your fingers don't hurt anymore. Suddenly, it seems like it just happens one day, you're able to switch between chords and that F chord is cupcake city.

After that, you've got a nice foundation to continue, and you can pretty much look up tabs and kind of know what you're doing. And it's just up from there! You just have to understand that it's going to take a little while for it to feel natural, but from there, it's going to be fine. You're not going to be able to shred like Malmsteen off the bat - or maybe ever - but you will be able to strum an acoustic at a campfire LIKE A BOSS.

It took me me a couple months before I could learn guitar. I never did any kind of scales or learning of songs. I still don't really but I noticed some cool things on the way. Mainly that no matter your skill level if you can hear music while you play you're playing musically and that is something to get excited about at any point while your playing!

thefreethinker31 11-22-2012 06:47 PM

For me, you just got to get through this "phase" wherein your fingers are still adjusting, notes are still new, and strumming is still measured by ups and downs. When your fingers get to the point when they automatically position themselves with chords, and strumming becomes innate, then it gets easy from that point on. It usually takes 3 months to get over this phase with constant practice (consistently playing the guitar for 30 mins a day).

Isbjørn 11-23-2012 07:38 AM

Be careful and try not to injure your forearms - that tends to happen if you practice too much. If your arms start to hurt, STOP PLAYING IMMEDIATELY.

Burning Down 11-23-2012 07:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Briks (Post 1253235)
Be careful and try not to injure your forearms - that tends to happen if you practice too much. If your arms start to hurt, STOP PLAYING IMMEDIATELY.

This is why proper posture is so important. The biggest issue is players wrapping their thumb around the neck of the guitar. That puts a huge strain on all the tendons in your hand, wrist, and arm. So, proper posture is wrist out, fingers curved, and thumb placed directly on the back of the neck. Some guitars (Strats and some other models) have a darker line or strip of wood that runs along the back of the neck - this is the perfect place for the thumb to be while you're playing.

simoirs 11-23-2012 10:43 AM

My experience with guitar has never, ever getting back tog...been frustrating.
I had my moments: the F chord, trying to link properly the D one (because of the unusual position of fingers) and others for sure but I really loved the instrument and I couldn't wait to be able to make some great noise with it.

My advice is to learn powerchord, even without knowing the theory behind, so if you start getting nervous you can just stick to the same fingers position and play music anyway.
It could even make the F chord become easier, but in my case after weeks of practice I just woke up one day and I could do it. Still a mistery to me.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:16 PM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.