The English Football Thread

[Cuthbert]

Originally Posted by Trollheart

Giggs over Terry Henry is definitely a joke, and before Shearer, THE Premier League's all time top scorer? And where is Ginola, eh?

Decent case for Paul McGrath to be in there imo. Only other defender to win PFA POTY is John Terry.

Not sure who my top five would be but Ronaldo, Suarez and Henry would be the first three for me. Shearer might be in it just because he's the top scorer, and for three or four seasons he was arguably the world's best striker.

I'd have had VDS over Schmeichel also as I think he was the better goalkeeper. And let's be real, Speed is only in there, so high as well, because he died. If he is in there then why not Gareth Barry?

Wouldn't be laughable to put Harry Kane in either if you've got Bale in there. He's been better for Spurs than Bale ever was and for a longer period of time. Unless they're considering their careers outside of the PL (Bale at Real Madrid) in which case why is Ronaldo not #1?