Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Song Writing, Lyrics and Poetry (https://www.musicbanter.com/song-writing-lyrics-poetry/)
-   -   Hi, would you rate my lyrics please? (https://www.musicbanter.com/song-writing-lyrics-poetry/61845-hi-would-you-rate-my-lyrics-please.html)

jeffgreggs 04-08-2012 03:54 PM

Hi, would you rate my lyrics please?
 
Hi, I've written 3 songs, and was wondering if you'd let me know what you think! Be honest, thanks :)

1. I STILL LOVE YOU

You walked away, yesterday,
All alone, I am today
I let you in, I shared your soul
You broke my heart, you took your toll

PRE-CHORUS
You’re on my mind, all the time
I wish i could give you a sign...

CHORUS
That I still love you
I still love you
I should have told you every day,
I wish the pain would go away,
Cause I still love you...

I tried to call you on your phone,
I’m sick of being all alone,
I was complete, You were my life,
I wanted you to be my wife

PRE-CHORUS
CHORUS

It’s in the past, now you’ve moved on
There one day, next you’ve gone
You said some things, it meant nothing,
I’d just bought you a diamond ring,
taught a mockingbird to sing,
i took you under my wing

felt like a piece that didn’t fit,
you once told me that I had lit
up the candle of your heart
now i can’t escape the dark
you’re putting me through hell
all that’s left’s an empty shell

PRECHORUS
CHORUS x2
I still love you, I still love you,
Do you love me?, Do you love me?,
You don’t love me, You don’t love me,
You never loved me, You never loved me,
But I still love you, I still love you,
I still love you, I still love you,

2. FRIEND-ZONE

You asked me what was wrong
I’m gazing in your eyes
“I love you with my heart, my soul and mind”
Heart racing, butterflies

I’m falling deeper in love,
Deeper in love,
Deeper in love,
With you

I thought that you were made for me
I’d be with you until the end
With those few words you broke my heart
When you said “let’s just be friends”

I told you of my love for you
She takes my hands from her hips
You look down towards the floor
The smile faded from your lips

You’re speaking with a cold, blank stare
You walk away, and I’m alone
Your words stuck in my mind
Forever stuck in the friend-zone

I’m falling deeper in love,
Deeper in love,
Deeper in love,
With you

I thought that you were made for me
I’d be with you until the end
With those few words you broke my heart
When you said “let’s just be friends”

You were one of my best friends,
Our memories a distant thought,
I loved you with my heart, soul and mind,
The times we shared are all I’ve got,

You’re on my mind every day
And I still see you in my dreams
You may not be perfect, baby
But you’re perfect for me

I’m falling deeper in love,
Deeper in love,
Deeper in love,
With you
You’re on my mind every day
And I still see you in my dreams
You may not be perfect, baby
But you’re perfect for me

3. BALLAD OF THE BROKEN HEART
You were my soul
You were my life
You’re cutting me
Like a knife

I thought that I had seen the light
Holding on to you so tight
I wish that you’d come back to me
I was blind, but now I see

I wish that I had seen the signs
Before your hand slipped from mines
My heart is breaking everyday
Wishing my pain away

You said I meant
Nothing to you
But since you’ve gone
My heart’s in two

When you’re around, my nerves were shot
From the start your love I’ve sought
At the start I was so shy
Without your love I thought I’d die
When I asked you to be mine
I never thought I’d crossed the line

I thought that I had seen the light
Holding on to you so tight
I wish that you’d come back to me
I was blind, but now I see

I wish that I had seen the signs
Before your hand slipped from mines
My heart is breaking everyday
Wishing my pain away

I wish you would
Walk through my door
And things would be
As they were before

I thought that I had seen the light
Holding on to you so tight
I wish that you’d come back to me
I was blind, but now I see

I wish that I had seen the signs
Before your hand slipped from mines
My heart is breaking everyday
Wishing my pain away

Thanks!

housekeeping 04-08-2012 06:03 PM

They're pretty straight forward. Early Beatles-ish.

Dr_Rez 04-08-2012 06:18 PM

Im not trying to be mean or anything just to be honest. This is filled with so many used cliches. Seeing light and rhyming it with holding tight seems like a super easy way out of a real rhyme. The chorus especially needs some personalization.

I think you are off to a good start and you clearly know how to go about writing a song. BUT keep in mind how many love songs have been written in history. Do you want this to get lost in the masses of democracy?

blastingas10 04-09-2012 08:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dr. Rez (Post 1175638)
Im not trying to be mean or anything just to be honest. This is filled with so many used cliches. Seeing light and rhyming it with holding tight seems like a super easy way out of a real rhyme. The chorus especially needs some personalization.

I think you are off to a good start and you clearly know how to go about writing a song. BUT keep in mind how many love songs have been written in history. Do you want this to get lost in the masses of democracy?

Exactly. That type of writing has become so cliche. It's kind of hard to write a love song without it being a cliche and sounding really corny these days. Bob Dylan was great at writing love songs without sounding really cliche. Its something I try to do when writing, it's no easy task. The first thing that comes to mind for most people when they're writing a song is love. Love songs in general have almost become a cliche. I'm not a huge Maynard Keenan fan but i think he does a great job of writing lyrics that aren't cliche or typical.

Don't pay attention to how many times I use the word "cliche". :laughing:

But of course even if the lyrics aren't great, the music as a whole can still be good.

ThePhanastasio 04-09-2012 10:20 PM

When depending on a rhyme scheme, going for the easiest, most cliche line is not the way to go. Even if you were in a boy band, that doesn't really fly.

Write something that really means something real to you. Don't worry about your rhyme scheme; worry about the metre, if anything.

silverwick 04-10-2012 01:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jeffgreggs (Post 1175570)
Hi, I've written 3 songs, and was wondering if you'd let me know what you think! Be honest, thanks :) Thanks!

"5.125", Jeff, needs a bit of fine tuning.

blastingas10 04-10-2012 10:24 AM

It's hard to write things that are real to me. I tend to write with a little surrealism.

TheNiceGuy 04-11-2012 06:51 AM

I don't mind what you've done here; I can really relate to the second one in particular. However as has been said the consistent "love" cliches are a little monotonous. Try and vary your themes a little more to avoid this. But nonetheless the're all pretty solid.

Dr_Rez 04-15-2012 06:51 PM

yea I dont think he is every going to come back.

TheNiceGuy 04-20-2012 03:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dr. Rez (Post 1178417)
yea I dont think he is every going to come back.

Well he did say to be honest... :P

jeffgreggs 04-21-2012 03:39 AM

Sorry for the late reply folks! But thanks very much for the input, totally see where you're all coming from! Thanks, appreciate it! :D

mallycobain 05-01-2012 04:16 AM

I love how it's to the point, and doesn't use big words that no one can understand. Your lyrics are true, and relateable.

****Can someone help me????****
Just some ideas I wrote down while listening to Something In The Way - Nirvana (instrumental)
These are bits of my poetry, ideas of what I want the song to be about;
any lyric ideas? simple, straight to the point, not too wordy?

"I taste the silence as it infests my mind.
A touch of sanity and bitter hate,
Yet I need its warm embrace."

"It’s okay, don't pity me, please. I have no friends..but maybe it's better that way"

"My mind is an overwhelming mess of dark and twisted thoughts that have taken over and chased out the soul I once had. Maybe it's better for me to be alone with myself..I can't handle people. I can't handle the boundless pain inside me, let alone the pain of everyday life. I'm too bitter and hostile for people. I hate people because people hate me. I'll never live to be what I've worked for and I'll never live up to anyone’s expectations. Happiness is a forgiven emotion to me. If I have none within me, so how in hell can I share it with people? So I choose to be alone, because it's what's best. I've learned this the hard way over the past years. Over these years I have found my friend, they're in my head. "

irisblind 05-06-2012 06:42 PM

Jeff buckley is a good example of how to write love songs that aren't too cliche.

Automatic Writing 05-14-2012 01:53 AM

I think your lyrics are very relate-able. Your sense of expression is very keen, I think there was a comment about avoiding cliches but if that's something that comes naturally to you go for it.

blastingas10 05-20-2012 02:58 AM

I'm just gonna post a verse I've written.

Through eyes of ocean
Our senses lost in devotion
Treachery has changed my plans
So many thoughts left unspoken.

Any opinions? Criticism? Is it too cliche?

Rangeroad15 05-31-2012 08:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by blastingas10 (Post 1190800)
I'm just gonna post a verse I've written.

Through eyes of ocean
Our senses lost in devotion
Treachery has changed my plans
So many thoughts left unspoken.

Any opinions? Criticism? Is it too cliche?


woah man i like that verse quite a bit and i cant even put together music in my head for it cause i think it coudl go with so many genres. Nice

blastingas10 06-01-2012 12:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rangeroad15 (Post 1194817)
woah man i like that verse quite a bit and i cant even put together music in my head for it cause i think it coudl go with so many genres. Nice

Hava thanks man. I've scrapped it. Just another thing I wrote that I didn't like

semtex 06-02-2012 01:25 AM

Honestly not really my style...I'm not much for rhyming. Here and there it's fine and if it just happens, but otherwise it comes to seem somewhat corny and also like a structural restriction in expression. I don't really like the style...A little cliche like someone said, although the part about the mockingbird did stand out to me. It's a bit too concrete for my taste and it doesn't feel so raw and real as I like

Henry.Fatih 06-11-2012 03:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jeffgreggs (Post 1175570)
Hi, I've written 3 songs, and was wondering if you'd let me know what you think! Be honest, thanks :)

1. I STILL LOVE YOU

You walked away, yesterday,
All alone, I am today
I let you in, I shared your soul
You broke my heart, you took your toll

PRE-CHORUS
You’re on my mind, all the time
I wish i could give you a sign...

CHORUS
That I still love you
I still love you
I should have told you every day,
I wish the pain would go away,
Cause I still love you...

I tried to call you on your phone,
I’m sick of being all alone,
I was complete, You were my life,
I wanted you to be my wife

PRE-CHORUS
CHORUS

It’s in the past, now you’ve moved on
There one day, next you’ve gone
You said some things, it meant nothing,
I’d just bought you a diamond ring,
taught a mockingbird to sing,
i took you under my wing

felt like a piece that didn’t fit,
you once told me that I had lit
up the candle of your heart
now i can’t escape the dark
you’re putting me through hell
all that’s left’s an empty shell

PRECHORUS
CHORUS x2
I still love you, I still love you,
Do you love me?, Do you love me?,
You don’t love me, You don’t love me,
You never loved me, You never loved me,
But I still love you, I still love you,
I still love you, I still love you,

2. FRIEND-ZONE

You asked me what was wrong
I’m gazing in your eyes
“I love you with my heart, my soul and mind”
Heart racing, butterflies

I’m falling deeper in love,
Deeper in love,
Deeper in love,
With you

I thought that you were made for me
I’d be with you until the end
With those few words you broke my heart
When you said “let’s just be friends”

I told you of my love for you
She takes my hands from her hips
You look down towards the floor
The smile faded from your lips

You’re speaking with a cold, blank stare
You walk away, and I’m alone
Your words stuck in my mind
Forever stuck in the friend-zone

I’m falling deeper in love,
Deeper in love,
Deeper in love,
With you

I thought that you were made for me
I’d be with you until the end
With those few words you broke my heart
When you said “let’s just be friends”

You were one of my best friends,
Our memories a distant thought,
I loved you with my heart, soul and mind,
The times we shared are all I’ve got,

You’re on my mind every day
And I still see you in my dreams
You may not be perfect, baby
But you’re perfect for me

I’m falling deeper in love,
Deeper in love,
Deeper in love,
With you
You’re on my mind every day
And I still see you in my dreams
You may not be perfect, baby
But you’re perfect for me

3. BALLAD OF THE BROKEN HEART
You were my soul
You were my life
You’re cutting me
Like a knife

I thought that I had seen the light
Holding on to you so tight
I wish that you’d come back to me
I was blind, but now I see

I wish that I had seen the signs
Before your hand slipped from mines
My heart is breaking everyday
Wishing my pain away

You said I meant
Nothing to you
But since you’ve gone
My heart’s in two

When you’re around, my nerves were shot
From the start your love I’ve sought
At the start I was so shy
Without your love I thought I’d die
When I asked you to be mine
I never thought I’d crossed the line

I thought that I had seen the light
Holding on to you so tight
I wish that you’d come back to me
I was blind, but now I see

I wish that I had seen the signs
Before your hand slipped from mines
My heart is breaking everyday
Wishing my pain away

I wish you would
Walk through my door
And things would be
As they were before

I thought that I had seen the light
Holding on to you so tight
I wish that you’d come back to me
I was blind, but now I see

I wish that I had seen the signs
Before your hand slipped from mines
My heart is breaking everyday
Wishing my pain away

Thanks!

I don't know how old you are but I'm impressed! This is both poetical and lyrical as well as musical. There is nothing I would change about it at all.

What I want to hear is the musical version. You are a poet for sure. But poets and musicians are different animals. I'm a poet and I'm impressed.

The musical portion have you developed it? Do you have an idea for it? If you do definitely post a small demo of it on Sound Cloud or something like that so that we can all hear what some of this sounds like.

Dragonite222 06-11-2012 04:53 PM

They were good, but i found them too simple almost.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:07 PM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.