- - The Official Led Zeppelin Thread
(https://www.musicbanter.com/rock-n-roll-classic-rock-60s-rock/9252-official-led-zeppelin-thread.html)
Chula Vista
11-19-2014 05:04 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by OccultHawk
(Post 1510216)
It's actually weird to me that I could love a band so much but remain so relatively ambivalent about what grew out of them especially when compared to Black Sabbath.
Zep's influence was a lot more wide ranging than Sabbath. I think you'd be really surprised at how many artists across a very wide range of genres would name them as an influence. Here's another interesting read on the subject.
Again that article confirms my suspicions that the bands most heavily influenced by Zeppelin aren't so good. Dokken, Steve Vai, Cinderella, and Whitesnake? That's some pretty serious slim pickins.
Chula Vista
11-19-2014 08:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by OccultHawk
(Post 1510224)
Again that article confirms my suspicions that the bands most heavily influenced by Zeppelin aren't so good. Dokken, Steve Vai, Cinderella, and Whitesnake? That's some pretty serious slim pickins.
Those are some some of the ****ty hair metal guys that blatantly ripped some riffs.
Both Ozzy and Tony have said that Zep I and Zep II were huge influences on the direction they decided to go with Sabbath.
My phone doesn't like that link if you just want to tell me the 15 bands.
Ninetales
11-19-2014 08:58 PM
I think the initial point wasn't that Led Zeppelin aren't influential, but that there are other artists that are equally/more influential.
Chula Vista
11-20-2014 09:01 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ninetales
(Post 1510312)
I think the initial point wasn't that Led Zeppelin aren't influential, but that there are other artists that are equally/more influential.
The Beatles, The Stones, and Bob Dylan. Joni Mitchell too.
Pretty everyone that came after them took a huge amount of influence from one or more of them.
“I think at that point we were aspiring to be a Led Zeppelin kind of a band where you could pick up your acoustic instruments or you could go out and rock or you could play a country song." - Pearl Jam's Jeff Ament
Ninetales
11-20-2014 09:30 AM
Did Led Zeppelin influence the state of ambient music? minimalism? jazz? electronic music? noise? modern classical? drone?
Even metal or other subgenres may have been indirectly influenced by Zep through the power of degrees, but like I wouldn't say they were hugely influential in the development of black metal or industrial or new wave, etc(unless you want to use the well Led Zeppelin->A->B->C->D->E->black metal which just turns into a who's older contest).
Led Zeppelin are extremely influential in rock music, but they didn't recreate music or anything and there are tons of other music avenues, styles, genres and movements that they did not touch or help develop.
Chula Vista
11-20-2014 09:58 AM
I'm strictly talking about rock and it's immediate off-shoots.
A couple of examples.
Communication Breakdown > The Ramones
Four Sticks > Jane's Addiction
Ninetales
11-20-2014 01:14 PM
gotcha. we're on the same page then
Unknown Soldier
11-21-2014 09:30 AM
Black Sabbath mostly influential to extreme metal genres, whereas Led Zeppelin the whole heavier end of the rock spectrum in general.
The Beatles, The Stones, and Bob Dylan. Joni Mitchell too.
Pretty everyone that came after them took a huge amount of influence from one or more of them.
“I think at that point we were aspiring to be a Led Zeppelin kind of a band where you could pick up your acoustic instruments or you could go out and rock or you could play a country song." - Pearl Jam's Jeff Ament
Grrr... Everyone loves to praise Bob Dylan, and yet they never say a word about Joan Baez... Even Judas Priest loved her enough to cover "Diamonds and Rust". Although Judas Priest did get their name from a Bob Dylan song... Ah, I just can't escape him!
Well, since this thread has been brought back to life, I guess I have no choice but to pick on Led Zeppelin some more. :ar_15s:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chula Vista
(Post 1510194)
(good article that kinda sums it up)
Legacy, Influence, and Cultural Significance
Led Zeppelin was inducted into the Rock ‘n Roll Hall of Fame in 1995 and has won countless awards including a Grammy Lifetime Achievement Award in 1995.
Lifetime Achievement Awards are basically the consolation prizes of music. And, as Frownland once pointed out, Grammys are mostly about popularity and give no true indication of a musician's talent.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chula Vista
(Post 1510194)
Every single member of the band is considered one of if not the greatest in the field and it is debatable that Led Zeppelin is one of the greatest bands ever put together. They have sold over 200 million albums worldwide and are in an elite category with the Beatles and Garth Brooks as statistically the greatest artists ever.
Sure, Page, Plant and the boys have got chops, but I find the whole "Who's the best?" debate to be pretty pointless and petty. Especially since they had very little imagination, and routinely stole riffs, lyrics, and even whole songs. After just five minutes of research, you'll quickly learn that Led Zeppelin aren't quite the masterminds that you might believe them to be.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chula Vista
(Post 1510194)
Led Zeppelin defined rock music and the rock lifestyle and they are not only adored by fans but also respected by famous musicians.
Bull****. Just complete and utter bull****. I could post literally hundreds of pre-Zep bands that smoke, drank, had sex, took drugs, and spit in the faces of anyone who questioned them. Saying that Led Zeppelin, or any one of their ancestors or peers, "defined rock music and the rock lifestyle" is just pretentious beyond belief. It's raising up one band, while covering your ears and shouting "Na na na!" to every other band that contributed to the scene.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chula Vista
(Post 1510194)
There have been numerous tribute albums by bands such as Stone Temple Pilots, Tina Turner, Duran Duran, and even the London Philharmonic Orchestra to name a few. The band is the epitomy of branding and they changed the way music was created for the radio and even for how managers operated.
The only thing they changed about music on the radio was making it an annoying and obsolete form of sharing music, as everyone got tired of Zep fanboys playing "Stairway to Heaven" (of which the famous intro riff was stolen from "Taurus" by the band Spirit) over and over. Okay, joking aside, what did Led Zeppelin do with their songs that other bands hadn't done before, in terms of radio-play? You'll have to elaborate, because it seems like a very vague and unsubstantiated statement that exists solely to stroke the band's ego.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chula Vista
(Post 1510194)
Led Zeppelin has left an overwhelming legacy and even Jimmy Page is proud of the fact that their music inspired some of today’s greatest musicians to pursue their dreams. Aerosmith, Guns ‘n Roses, and Van Halen borrowed the sound from the song “Whole Lotta Love” for their basic feel.
"Whole Lotta Love"? You mean the song that they stole from Muddy Waters, which eventually caused them to be sued into oblivion until they settled with him?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chula Vista
(Post 1510194)
Led Zeppelin also had a major impact on fashion and the definition of “Cool”. The band oozed sexuality and macho-ism and everyone wanted to give off that vibe. Musicians such as jack White copy their style and even to this day Led Zeppelin t-shirts are worn by celebrities. They even started the big hair craze of the 1980′s.
The band "oozed sexuality and macho-ism" because that was the trademark attitude of the Blues, of which they were a revival band. Before they were even born, the groundwork for their sound was laid down and mastered. Saying that Led Zeppelin created this sound and attitude is like saying that Elvis created Rock and Gospel; it's mistaking appropriation with innovation. Before Led Zeppelin had even released their debut LP, Blues Revival music like this was happening:
Google greatest US presidents of all time and both Ronald Reagan and GWB come up in the top five results.
Go Reagan?
Chula Vista
02-07-2015 09:13 PM
I'm really comfy in my Zep fan worship. Been that way since 1970. Nothing is gonna take it away.
Linda and I saw this in a packed movie theater with a bunch of Zep fans. Lots of fathers and sons for sure.
So many goose bump moments.
Paul Smeenus
02-07-2015 09:16 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Frownland
(Post 1548782)
Google greatest US presidents of all time and both Ronald Reagan and GWB come up in the top five results.
Go Reagan?
I'm a big Ike fan
Unknown Soldier
02-08-2015 03:50 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Oriphiel
(Post 1548497)
Bull****. Just complete and utter bull****. I could post literally hundreds of pre-Zep bands that smoke, drank, had sex, took drugs, and spit in the faces of anyone who questioned them. Saying that Led Zeppelin, or any one of their ancestors or peers, "defined rock music and the rock lifestyle" is just pretentious beyond belief. It's raising up one band, while covering your ears and shouting "Na na na!" to every other band that contributed to the scene.
Whilst I agree with a lot of the points you've raised about Led Zep, you need to remember that Chula was around in the 1970s when Led Zep were doing all of the above, so he would've lived and breathed with the band as it were and views the band with a certain amount of nostalgia, and they were the highest profile band to do all the aspects that you're picking him up on.
I've really been warming up to Zeppelin this year. I've always liked them to some degree, but they never really sunk into my taste until lately, primarily due to hearing Physical Graffiti front to back for the first time.
Plankton
03-26-2015 09:49 AM
I wore em out in my late teens, but I can still stomach some of it these days. Houses Of The Holy is still my favorite full album from them.