Don

LOL. I don't know what a ****ing ocatave is??? Me and DontRunMeOver were discussing Neapolitan chords and I probaly don't know what an octave is??? I've been composing music for many years, graduated a musical course, been in many bands, am a reviewer and I don't know what an octave is????

rofl, the funniest thing about it is that not long ago you mistook TIME SIGNATURES for the KEY a song's in!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! And let me get this straight, you're saying I don't know what an octave is????

roflol.

Yeah nice link there, be good if it would work but it doesn't matter. I already know the record for greatest range (8 octaves) and rock singers don't even come close to any list. I'm talking about rock you moron.

Ladies and gentleman...read both sides of the arugment if you will, and please tell boo boo to quit arguing with a superior man in all fields. He's aware he's lost, but he can never swallow his pride, so maybe someone can help him?

sleepy jack

I'm not gonna step into this arguement cause its 3:14am and i'm tired and don't feel like arguing this subject, but word of advice Don. Quit acting like such a condescending eltist music snob. All it really does is piss everyone off, you were starting to grow on me till I read through this thread and you start acting like this. Seriously, everyones equal. You're no better then him. Quit being so arrogant.

__________________

boo boo

YOU CONFUSED KEYS AND TIME SIGS ON YOUR DREAM THEATER REVIEW YOU ****ING MORON, MISFITS PROVED IT, YOU KNOW NOTHING YOU ****ING IMBECILE.

ALL THE SINGERS I LISTED WERE ROCK, THAT LIST WAS A ****ING ROCK LIST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

DIE GODDAMMIT, DIE MOTHER****ER, DIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

__________________
It's only knock n' knowall, but I like it

http://www.last.fm/user/kingboobs

Don

Wow, what a relevant and accurate statement there.

Nice exception there, too bad it means nothing.

So there goes your bias point then, nice going.

Silly boy. "best" ones? That's what the whole poll was about, picking random ones for people to decide who the best ones were there. If I just listed all the guitarists I thought were the best, then I wouldn't have made a poll to begin with.

Isn't "random" in your vocabulary?

Saying Batio isn't a technical God is almost more lolly than saying there are 20 keyboardists better than Rudess. And apparently you know more about technical ability than me...

How can I plan it out when I'm given a time limit? It's extremely hard to do, and once again, that wasn't the point of the poll. I've already explained what the point of it, I know it's hard for you to understand it, it's okay my little handicapped boy.

And if it was such a waste of bandwidth then how come it got so many replies? If I had of done what you intended, most people would be lost, the average person would rather see someone like Cobain than Lane, for example.

boo boo

Theres more to being a guitar god than TS, and Batio isnt THAT skilled either.

Yeah he plays very damn fast, and theres more to instrumental ability than speed, Batio lacks versatility, and he cant play rhtyhm worth a sh*t.

People like Ry Cooder, Shawn Lane and Allan Holdsworth school him, you not including them in the poll was a insult.

Also replies dosent make it any less spam, there was a thread on DDD called "can you play guitar with your penis?"...It made it to over 20 pages.

__________________
It's only knock n' knowall, but I like it

http://www.last.fm/user/kingboobs

Don

There is a very short distance between the capslock key and the 'A' key.

Now you're digging deep hoping that someone reading you immature capitals will actually believe you. Fact: I never once confused the key's a song's in with the time signature, that's actually an impossible thing to do for a musician.

I wasn't taking about the singers you listed, I was taking about the singers with the greatest range.

Merkaba

I personally say boo boo has you beat.

For all your superior wisdom and what not you fail to provide a good argument. Trying to take the piss as if you know everything is pretty tiresome, especially when you do it without relating to the argument at hand.

Such as boo boos octave figures. You tried to laugh off his lack of knowledge instead of actually talking about the figures at hand.

And you talk about swallowing pride, you need some of your own perscription.

__________________
She thinks I'm a reclusive genius, she's going to be very disappointed when she finds out i'm a reclusive wanker

boo boo

2.75 isnt that ****ing great.

FACT!

Captain Beeheart has at least a 4 octave range i believe, and hes a horrible singer.

Also tone has crap to do with skill, its a natural thing, tone is something you are born with, it dosent make you very talented.

__________________
It's only knock n' knowall, but I like it

http://www.last.fm/user/kingboobs

Don

Crow, just because you like boo boo opinions better than mine shouldn't necessarily mean you're an utter fool. You must be aware that boo boo is actually the one saying he's better than me. I never once professed I was better than anyone, you're just putting words in my mouth. All I've done is tell you my professions...boo boo has said things such as he's opinions are better than mine, and he knows more about prog and more about technical ability than me and that's he's better than LaBrie, etc, etc ,etc.

Please grow up, Crow, or grow a brain.

Don

His figures were both wrong and embarrassing. But nice joke.

I know you're joking because boo boo said "LaBrie doesn't even come CLOSE to those singers in range." Then later on he said LaBrie's octave range is 2.75....and even though it's wrong I could have sworn that that was CLOSE to 3.