Battle of the Bands Rock Edition Season 2! Discussion Thread

Comus · 09-10-2010, 11:34 PM

Discuss your nominations/supports and who you think will win.

Unknown Soldier · 09-11-2010, 06:33 PM

Initial problem I had here, was literally choosing just 10 bands from a very big GENRE FIELD. I tried to pick a variety of stuff from metal, prog and classic rock and I could easily come on here tomorrow and just name another 10 groups, that I think are as good as these bands.

Maybe the whole thing should be broken down into smaller categories like (Hard Rock, Classic Rock, Heavy Metal, Punk, Indie, Alternative, folk etc) with the winners of each category going forward. Admittedly, we could have differences of opinions about which bands belong in each category, but sorting that out could be part of the fun, and with someone on here to have a final say on where the said group could be categorized.

Alfred · 09-12-2010, 12:02 PM

I forgot to nominate System Of A Down, whoops. I imagine editing my post would make things a wee bit sticky.

Necromancer · 09-12-2010, 12:46 PM

I nominate the bands 'Free' and 'Bad Company' in the Classic Rock catagory.
The reason for nominating these two bands is mainly because of Paul Rodgers, there just isnt very much discussion anymore concerning Free or Bad Company, back in the 70s Bad Company was one of the more popular bands, atleast they were here in the Northeastern, US.
Paul Rodgers is so different in vocal style than Freddie Mercury ever was, but I like him as the frontman for Queen, turned out as a nice homage to Mercury's career.

Unknown Soldier · 09-12-2010, 01:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by VocalsBass

I nominate the bands 'Free' and 'Bad Company' in the Classic Rock catagory.
The reason for nominating these two bands is mainly because of Paul Rodgers, there just isnt very much discussion anymore concerning Free or Bad Company, back in the 70s Bad Company was one of the more popular bands, atleast they were here in the Northeastern, US.
Paul Rodgers is so different in vocal style than Freddie Mercury ever was, but I like him as the frontman for Queen, turned out as a nice homage to Mercury's career.

The categories were just my idea and so don`t exist

But certainly agree about Paul Rodgers, and as far as I`m concerned should be mentioned in the same breath as Robert Plant and Ian Gillan from that era. For the record I think Free are superior to Bad Company.

Necromancer · 09-12-2010, 02:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Unknown Soldier

For the record I think Free are superior to Bad Company.

In what way do you mean Free is superior? As in talent, record sales, popularity?
I didnt think that Free was together long enough to have as much material as Bad Company had let alone, as good as Bad Company's music.
The only thing that stands out about the band Free, (to me anyway after '70) besides two or three popular songs is, the bass player was very good.
Bad Company has some really good albums, let alone good singles that are actual rock classics.

Unknown Soldier · 09-12-2010, 03:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by VocalsBass

In what way do you mean Free is superior? As in talent, record sales, popularity?
I didnt think that Free was together long enough to have as much material as Bad Company had let alone, as good as Bad Company's music.
The only thing that stands out about the band Free, (to me anyway after '70) besides two or three popular songs is, the bass player was very good.
Bad Company has some really good albums, let alone good singles that are actual rock classics.

Free were together for 5 years and put out 6 studio albums and one live, I think thats a good output!!! The albums "Tons of Sobs" "Fire and Water" and "Heartbreaker" are their three standout albums. The material was superior to that of Bad Company, as was the melodic hard rock sound they put out and of course they had Paul Kossof on guitar, one of the greatest guitarists to have ever come out of Great Britain. The bassist of the group was Andy Fraser and as you probably know he went with Rodgers to Bad Company.

Bad Company on the other hand, were a supergroup that were very much a blander version of Free and apart from the debut which is a good album, the rest of their output is largely run of the mill rock that sold by the bucketload, and the band were seriously treading water by the end of the 1970's.

I was a big fan though of Mick Ralphs, and I love the song he wrote when he was in Mott The Hoople "Ready For Love" which actually features on the Bad Company debut.

Necromancer · 09-12-2010, 03:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Unknown Soldier

Free were together for 5 years and put out 6 studio albums and one live, I think thats a good output!!! The albums "Tons of Sobs" "Fire and Water" and "Heartbreaker" are their three standout albums. The material was superior to that of Bad Company, as was the melodic hard rock sound they put out and of course they had Paul Kossof on guitar, one of the greatest guitarists to have ever come out of Great Britain. The bassist of the group was Andy Fraser and as you probably know he went with Rodgers to Bad Company.

Bad Company on the other hand, were a supergroup that were very much a blander version of Free and apart from the debut which is a good album, the rest of their output is largely run of the mill rock that sold by the bucketload, and the band were seriously treading water by the end of the 1970's.

I was a big fan though of Mick Ralphs, and I love the song he wrote when he was in Mott The Hoople "Ready For Love" which actually features on the Bad Company debut.

If you insist Free is better than Bad Company, thats your opinion, their album Holy Water with lead vocalist Brian Howe, and album Company Of Strangers with lead vocalist Robert Hart were both good albums in my opinion, let alone the classic albums featuring Paul Rodgers.
I dont subscribe to your theory

Unknown Soldier · 09-12-2010, 03:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by VocalsBass

If you insist Free is better than Bad Company, thats your opinion, their album Holy Water with lead vocalist Brian Howe, and album Company Of Strangers with lead vocalist Robert Hart were both good albums in my opinion, let alone the classic albums featuring Paul Rodgers.
I dont subscribe to your theory

Well the albums with Brian Howe I don`t think are very good at all. I can`t comment on the stuff with Robert Hart but this must be their 90`s material.

Out of interest you would nominate both Bad Company and Free as your classic rock choices, if you had to choose another two who would they be?

Necromancer · 09-12-2010, 03:52 PM

Since Bad Company is more of a classic blues/rock style, I would match them with bands like Aerosmith, AC/DC, etc. if that is the question?
Thats OK! liking Free better than Bad Company Soldier, I respect your opinion regardless its even that important either way.

09-12-2010, 12:02 PM	#3 (permalink)
Alfred one big soul Join Date: Feb 2008 Location: Canada Posts: 5,096	I forgot to nominate System Of A Down, whoops. I imagine editing my post would make things a wee bit sticky. __________________ LAST.FM / VINYL COLLECTION / RYM

09-12-2010, 12:46 PM	#4 (permalink)
Necromancer Divination Join Date: Oct 2007 Posts: 2,655	Free & Bad Company I nominate the bands 'Free' and 'Bad Company' in the Classic Rock catagory. The reason for nominating these two bands is mainly because of Paul Rodgers, there just isnt very much discussion anymore concerning Free or Bad Company, back in the 70s Bad Company was one of the more popular bands, atleast they were here in the Northeastern, US. Paul Rodgers is so different in vocal style than Freddie Mercury ever was, but I like him as the frontman for Queen, turned out as a nice homage to Mercury's career.

09-11-2010, 06:33 PM	#2 (permalink)
Unknown Soldier Horribly Creative Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: London, The Big Smoke Posts: 8,265	Initial problem I had here, was literally choosing just 10 bands from a very big GENRE FIELD. I tried to pick a variety of stuff from metal, prog and classic rock and I could easily come on here tomorrow and just name another 10 groups, that I think are as good as these bands. Maybe the whole thing should be broken down into smaller categories like (Hard Rock, Classic Rock, Heavy Metal, Punk, Indie, Alternative, folk etc) with the winners of each category going forward. Admittedly, we could have differences of opinions about which bands belong in each category, but sorting that out could be part of the fun, and with someone on here to have a final say on where the said group could be categorized.

09-12-2010, 03:52 PM	#10 (permalink)
Necromancer Divination Join Date: Oct 2007 Posts: 2,655	Since Bad Company is more of a classic blues/rock style, I would match them with bands like Aerosmith, AC/DC, etc. if that is the question? Thats OK! liking Free better than Bad Company Soldier, I respect your opinion regardless its even that important either way.