The Official Tool Thread

[Urban Hat€monger ?]

That wasn't a personal attack on you, I'm just going by what other bands you talk about on the forum.

Other than Tool all I've seen you post about is Slipknot & Limp Bizkit, bands who not only fall under that catagory but who are practically the poster childern for it.

So the fact that there is a huge crossover of popularity with that audience would suggest that there's no real intellectual criteria that allows one to enjoy Tool anymore than most bands.

I know you're too blind to see this but I await you to start talking about bands who actually play complex music whether than be musically complex or literary complex rather than bands who are aimed at 13 year old social outcasts that you currently enjoy

[Unknown Soldier]

Don't condemn him for liking only those bands, he also likes Korn too.

[Necromancer]

From a positive standpoint, Tool may be one of the more popular hard rock bands of the day. Their music contains elements of progressive rock, metal, and a brooding artistic feel that has given Tool a strong fan base. Boasting Danny Carey as one of the best drummers of the modern day, and the enigmatic Maynard James Keenan as a front man. I'm personally not surprised the band has such a following.

Negative: I just personally can't get into them because no matter how much exertion the band and its producers put into the sound of each song, the riffs themselves seem to be based on a big block of air. In other words, if you sit down to play a Tool song on your acoustic guitar, you'll more than likely find yourself (A) playing a mid-80s Megadeth-style bass line or (B) alternating between two or three tedious barre chords that are right next to each other. The band is too slow to kick ass and too melodically limited for my taste. In other words, Tools music is artistically not my cup of tea. But that in no way means that they are not a good band regardless of all the negative reviews. (Better than Korn anyway) Personal preference is all that matters.

[MyName]

That wasn't a personal attack on you, I'm just going by what other bands you talk about on the forum.

You're redirecting the discussion to my personal traits and preferences instead of arguing my argument

Other than Tool all I've seen you post about is Slipknot & Limp Bizkit, bands who not only fall under that catagory but who are practically the poster childern for it.

I still kinda like LB, Fred's voice is really good in slow/soft songs and instrumental parts are usually very captivating and catchy. I don't really care that much for Slipknot tho.

So the fact that there is a huge crossover of popularity with that audience would suggest that there's no real intellectual criteria that allows one to enjoy Tool anymore than most bands.

Oh yeah, I(one person) listen to Limp Bizkit and Tool. Such a HUGE crossover. Ask Forward To Death how much he loves Limp Bizkit

I know you're too blind to see this but I await you to start talking about bands who actually play complex music whether than be musically complex or literary complex rather than bands who are aimed at 13 year old social outcasts that you currently enjoy

Urban I, unlike you, listen to music I LIKE. I don't listen to some jerk-off boring complex music or hipster bands barely anybody cares about just so I can act superior to others.

Overall I like the 90s/early 2000s culture the most so most music I listen comes from that era, that means mainly grunge, alternative and nu metal.

That is not to say that I didn't TRY listening to many classic rock/metal bands like The Beatles, Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin, Aerosmith, Black Sabbath, Metallica, Iron Maiden, Judas Priest etc and I also tried countless other rock/metal bands, ranging from Aerosmith to Dream Theater to Nightwish.

[Isbjørn]

When did you stop loving Slipknot? You did, after all, post this:

Originally Posted by MyName

What, bitch? Me and SlipKnot too br00000000tal for you? HA?

Originally Posted by MyName

Dude I totally agree SlipKnot are the most br00tal band ever, totally.

...though I totally hope you were joking.

[Rjinn]

Are we talking about Tool? Or are we talking about MyName's taste in music?

Seriously who gives a **** about who they are marketed at?

[Forward To Death]

I don't think anyone cares, it was just a topic for about a page, and this is a discussion board afterall. Calm your tits.

[Rjinn]

Originally Posted by Forward To Death

I don't think anyone cares, it was just a topic for about a page, and this is a discussion board afterall. Calm your tits.

Just a question, don't need to read too much into it. :P

[hip hop bunny hop]

Originally Posted by Rjinn

Seriously who gives a **** about who they are marketed at?

I think the social component of music is a valid topic of discussion.

[Unknown Soldier]

Originally Posted by Rjinn

Are we talking about Tool? Or are we talking about MyName's taste in music?

Seriously who gives a **** about who they are marketed at?

To be fair most bands have usually been marketed at a target audience and usually the band's have been under pressure from the record company to do so.

It's just sad though, that so many recent metal bands have been targeted at kids and we've ended up with angsty kids sucking up to ****ty metal bands. Tool though are going to be far harder to market though, than say either a band like Slipknot or Korn.