AHHH dont u love mass confusion hehe :crazy:

This is really hard cuz i love both bands but im going to have to go with Tool on this one. Tool has been more consistent to me with making great songs, but thats my opinion. But ofcourse both bands r sooo freakin good

i agree...both r excellent

to say honestly i had never heard of tool until my half sister played it in her car on the way to my dad;s i was like :yeah: this is effin awesome!!!!
It was stinkfist, i <3 it!!!!!!! and iz my favourite still!...Aenima was my favourite c.d. :hphones: :band: ...NIN That guy is amazing aLso... :thumb:

Toooooooooooooooooooooooooo-all!!!!

Oh man no comparison TOOL by far<-very talented-anyone like A Perfect Circle's stuff to?

neither.

Both groups havent put out decent material for about nine years. But, Pretty Hate Machine and Opiate are must haves.

Never really been a fan of either band , they both strike me as being rather pretentious & humourless.

NIN, hands down. Tool is a great band, no question, but the emotions so clearly expressed by Mr. Reznor win me over.