Top 10 Rock Bands Ever? (singer, single, genre, albums, fan)

crash_override · 04-30-2009, 09:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lucifer_sam

in case you want to rip me a new one:

Faith No More
Pink Floyd
Queens of the Stone Age
The Church
Can
Stereolab
Minutemen
The Pretty Things
David Bowie
Primal Scream

probably not actually it but definitely indicative of what i listen to.

oh come on man. i can at least understand why you'd like those other artists but Interpol hasn't lived up to the hype at all. those one-off albums that come out every few years aren't really indicative of talent, just critics misappropriating whose ass to shove their faces in.

Ditto on stereolab...

lucifer_sam · 04-30-2009, 09:53 AM

go check out Mars Audiac Quintet, Emperor Tomato Ketchup, Transient Random-Noise Bursts with Announcements, or any of their several billion collabs out there. then get back to me.

crash_override · 04-30-2009, 11:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lucifer_sam

go check out Mars Audiac Quintet, Emperor Tomato Ketchup, Transient Random-Noise Bursts with Announcements, or any of their several billion collabs out there. then get back to me.

I'll give stereolab another listen, just for you. But I can't guaruntee anything. But top 10 seriously?

The Cat · 04-30-2009, 02:15 PM

In no particular order

Iron Maiden
Dire Straits
Metallica
Colour Haze
The Doors
Red Hot Chili Peppers
Pink Floyd
Rage Against The Machine
Muse
The Who

Mmmmm i'm sure i'll hang my mind!

**Janszoon** · 04-30-2009, 02:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mirrorball95

Rock can means so different things as there are so many different sub genres of rock.
I do believe the Beatles had a very distinctive sound though and
I guess it would be most suitable to class them as rock but I still wouldnt name them alongside the likes of Black Sabbath & Rush (who to me are nothing like them and miles better IMO).

I would say that the Beatles are much closer to the sound of original rock n roll than Black Sabbath or Rush so by that measure they're actually more rock than them. Personally I don't really like the Beatles, but we're talking about genres here not the quality of the band's output.

blackcabmal · 04-30-2009, 04:29 PM

Hello everyone 1st post
1-ELP
2-Budgie
3-Curved Air
4-Little feat
5-Mostly Autumn
6-Pink Floyd
7-Soft Cell
8-Simon and Garfunkel
9-Rush
10-The Cure

Mirrorball95 · 04-30-2009, 06:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by crash_override

Is this some sort of cruel joke?

No man, it is totally true. I may have heard something on PlanetRock before but I dont have any of their albums and cant name their songs im afraid. Ive heard there Prog Rock.
I first heard of them on these music forums & got mixed up at first with an avant garde band called 'King Missile' who are extremely weird and most people wouldnt like them although people like Zappa so I guess it's possible.
Anyway anybody got any first album recommendations for King Crimson.
I get the impression there one of the 'unsung' or lower profile Prog Rock bands such as 'Devo' or 'Camel' whom somebody introduced me to not that long ago and they are not bad bands.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Janszoon

I would say that the Beatles are much closer to the sound of original rock n roll than Black Sabbath or Rush so by that measure they're actually more rock than them. Personally I don't really like the Beatles, but we're talking about genres here not the quality of the band's output.

Yeah this is pretty much what i was trying to say. It just isnt Rock as I would class it. I get what youre saying with them being around before Rush & Sabbath etc but I still wouldnt use the phrase 'more rock' than Sabbath or Rush. Also I think that people have different perceptions of genres obviously the core of the genre is still relevant but Ive had people say to me 'whats that headbanging your listening to?' & Ive been listening to Neil Young lol & I wouldnt class that as being 'heavy' as such.
I wouldnt even class Sabbath as being that heavy either tbh as I listen/have listened to much heavier stuff than that.
But fair enough man, youre entitled your own opinions as I am with mines

**Janszoon** · 04-30-2009, 07:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mirrorball95

Yeah this is pretty much what i was trying to say. It just isnt Rock as I would class it. I get what youre saying with them being around before Rush & Sabbath etc but I still wouldnt use the phrase 'more rock' than Sabbath or Rush.

Actually I don't think you do get what I'm saying. Them being around before those two bands is not what I'm talking about. I'm saying that the Beatles' music has more in common stylistically with early rock n roll (i.e. Chuck Berry, Little Richard, etc.) than a band like Rush does. And since the term "rock n roll" was invented to describe the music made by people like Chuck Berry and Little Richard it can be argued that the closer you come to that particular sound the more rock you are.

Incidentally, I'm not saying that Rush and Black Sabbath aren't rock. They are. I'm just saying that they're further removed from what the term "rock" was originally coined to describe.

dac · 04-30-2009, 10:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lucifer_sam

oh come on man. i can at least understand why you'd like those other artists but Interpol hasn't lived up to the hype at all. those one-off albums that come out every few years aren't really indicative of talent, just critics misappropriating whose ass to shove their faces in.

in case you want to rip me a new one:

Faith No More
Pink Floyd
Queens of the Stone Age
The Church
Can
Stereolab
Minutemen
The Pretty Things
David Bowie
Primal Scream

Oh come on man, SF Sorrow is great, but outside of that it gets pretty meh.

Interpol probably made it in because I'm rediscovering them (if you could call it that) lately. The list was surprisingly tough make though, as most of my listens over the past 6-12 months have been from trip hop and post rock. I will say The Church and Can have been slowly creeping up though.

Mirrorball95 · 05-01-2009, 08:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Janszoon

Actually I don't think you do get what I'm saying. Them being around before those two bands is not what I'm talking about. I'm saying that the Beatles' music has more in common stylistically with early rock n roll (i.e. Chuck Berry, Little Richard, etc.) than a band like Rush does. And since the term "rock n roll" was invented to describe the music made by people like Chuck Berry and Little Richard it can be argued that the closer you come to that particular sound the more rock you are.

Incidentally, I'm not saying that Rush and Black Sabbath aren't rock. They are. I'm just saying that they're further removed from what the term "rock" was originally coined to describe.

Maybe I didnt go into enough detail but obviously I know that Beatles style of rock is more closer to original rock & roll compared to the likes of Black Sabbath or Rush.
I thought it would have been too obvious to actually have to say it.
After all you do have to listen to music to judge it anyway.
My perception of 'Rock' (probably due to personal preference) is more accustomed to bands like Rush or Black Sabbath other than original 'Rock & Roll' as you had mentioned.
This would be why I described The Beatles as not being a 'rock' band in my eyes, which I still kind of agree to(to a certain extent).
Perhaps it would be more suitable to place them as an 'original' rock band but then they had their own sound and all that so its hard to place them.
Certain bands (of whom a lot I do not like) have their own distinctive 'mark' or 'sound' on music (if you know what i mean..) such as U2 for instance, their high pitched air guitar sound has been mimicked/copyed by 90% of the new 'Indie Rock' bands; Snow Patrol, Kings of Leon (recent sell out period) & Coldplay to name a few.

04-30-2009, 09:53 AM	#692 (permalink)
lucifer_sam Unrepentant Ass-Mod Join Date: Jun 2008 Location: Pennsylvania Posts: 3,921	go check out Mars Audiac Quintet, Emperor Tomato Ketchup, Transient Random-Noise Bursts with Announcements, or any of their several billion collabs out there. then get back to me. __________________ first.am

04-30-2009, 02:15 PM	#694 (permalink)
The Cat ..Just Not Your Kind Join Date: Jan 2009 Location: Germany Posts: 188	In no particular order Iron Maiden Dire Straits Metallica Colour Haze The Doors Red Hot Chili Peppers Pink Floyd Rage Against The Machine Muse The Who Mmmmm i'm sure i'll hang my mind! __________________ Just Because Your paraniod......Doesn't Mean They Are Not After You!

04-30-2009, 04:29 PM	#696 (permalink)
blackcabmal Groupie Join Date: Apr 2009 Location: Bromley Kent Posts: 1	Hello everyone 1st post 1-ELP 2-Budgie 3-Curved Air 4-Little feat 5-Mostly Autumn 6-Pink Floyd 7-Soft Cell 8-Simon and Garfunkel 9-Rush 10-The Cure