The only AFI cd I have is their most recent one. It probably isn't a very good first impression of them because I've sampled some of their older stuff, and I thought it was a lot better.

afi is really good. i like them alot. i agree with the old stuff being better.

well this is gonna make me really sound like a "groupie" but i only have their sing the sorrow album and i absolutely love it. i really have no interest in buying their other albums since 1)i just download the songs now instead of paying for the cd (yes im a pirate) and 2)i dont know any of the songs on their old cds. so based on their sts cd, i love them. i think theyre awesome. call me a poser if you wish, i dont care.

Woo! I love A.F.I. That is all I have to say.

I've haven't got any of their old stuff. I've got black sails in the sunset, sing the sorrow and the art of drowning. I think AFI rock though, and when I get round to it I'm gonna get their back catalogue.

Not knowing everything a band has done doesnt make you a poser. Sing The Sorrow was one of their weakest albums (in my opinion), so you should definatley check out some of their other stuff, I reckon you'd like...

sing the sorrow was poo in my opinion. i love some of their older stuff though.

well usually when i would tell people that i liked a certain band and i either only liked a few songs or just had one particular album that they didnt like, they would say i wasnt a true fan. so i just watch what i saw now. which older afi album in particular do you recommend?

Black Sails In The Sunset
The Art Of Drowning
Shut Your Mouth And Open Your Eyes is also great.. Tis very different, especially to Sing The Sorrow

And there's the All Hallows E.P aswel, which is good...

mmkay. any particular songs off those albums that you like better than the other ones? i dont wanna be wasting my time downloading and come to find out that i dont like the song.