Music Banter - The Official Gentle Giant thread

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)

- Prog & Psychedelic Rock (https://www.musicbanter.com/prog-psychedelic-rock/)

- - The Official Gentle Giant thread (https://www.musicbanter.com/prog-psychedelic-rock/40731-official-gentle-giant-thread.html)

The most cringeworty reviews are the "this album is bad because it's not prog" and "this is poppy therefore bad" variety. Of which there is a lot of.

There's some good reviews. But it seems that for whatever reason, the ones who give the worst reviews are the main contributors to the site. :laughing:

Oh yes, I cringe when a band has a change in sound, but still makes a brilliant album, and are labelled as "not prog" and as such given a low score. Seems the main scoring on progarchives is about how prog stuff is.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Comus (Post 665175)

Case in point the idiots who rant about how "pop" Discipline is.

Quote:

Originally Posted by boo boo (Post 665170)

There's some good reviews. But it seems that for whatever reason, the ones who give the worst reviews are the main contributors to the site. :laughing:

Caught :eek:

best to worst (fave song)

Octopus (The Advent of Panurge or A Cry For Everyone or Knots, however that one bit in Raconteur, Troubadour is gorgeous)
The Power And The Glory (Proclamation or The Face)
In A Glass House (The Runaway or Experience)
Acquiring The Taste (Moon is Down)
Gentle Giant (Funny Ways)
Three Friends (Prologue)
Free Hand (Just The Same)

In A Glass House and The Power And The Glory are really close in my rankings. also worth noting I have listened to my top 3 albums a bunch more than the others.

The 10 track comp for the initiate was pieced together by me, Anteater, Comus and Boo Boo. That means there was some compromise and so I'm not 100% pleased with it (I'm sure the others feel the same). For that reason, I pieced together a new for the 10 track mixtape thread and I figure I should advertise it here as well. :)

Quote:

Originally Posted by tore (Post 972113)

Here's a 10 track compilation for newcomers to Gentle Giant :) It is slightly different from the one in the Official Gentle Giant thread as that was made through some kind of democratic election process between me, Anteater, Comus and Boo Boo. Since I didn't have to compromise this time, I prefer this one!

If you don't know Gentle Giant, they are an english prog band from the 70s that never quite reached the mainstream, but their style has immense influence on other proggers. They were multi-instrumental, did some crazy a-capellas and were generally highly creative with their music. Generally speaking, they have 7 albums which are all considered gems of the genre which is pretty impressive.

Check'em out!

10 Tracks For the Gentle Giant Novice

http://img692.imageshack.us/img692/1...hresgeiger.jpg

FunnyWays
Nothing At All
Wreck
Black Cat
The Advent Of Panurge
Knots
Prologue
Proclamation
Just the Same
On Reflection

In the songs comment tag you'll find information on which album that song was originally released on.

The only song I'm familar with is Just the same which Stuart Maconie played on a radio show about 10 yrs. ago. I didn't like the vocals but it was an intersting song with a sublime little break down in the middle.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyingpig437 (Post 972122)

The album that song is from, Free Hand from 1975, is currently my favourite Gentle Giant album .. It is brilliant and I'd say definetly worth getting! If you like Just The Same, you'll probably like the other songs too :)

In the comp from my previous post, the song On Reflection is also from Free Hand.

I really like that tracklist. Props!

Fave album is Octopus.

Fave song is The Advent of Panurge.