lucifer_sam

you still left the gigantic stain that is ELP on that list?

and what about Roxy Music? Ferry may not be as good a songwriter as Eno but they're certainly influential enough.

__________________
first.am

boo boo

Uriah Heep are my guilty pleasure band.

Though I'm not really guilty about it.

He was the wizard of a thoooousand kings, and I chanced to meet him one night waaaandering. He told me tales, and he drank my wine. Me and my magic man kinda feeeelin' fine.

Well I love ELP and while most of you hate them. They are still one of the most influencial and defining bands of the genre. So they get their credit.

Roxy Music. I don't know. I certainly consider early Eno prog. But Roxy Music I'm not sure about, they are such a unique band, but they are often more associated with glam rock and proto punk than prog. Eno is respected in prog circles, at least he is now. He has a good deal of influence on krautrock too.

But Roxy Music were greatly despised by prog fans back in the day, because they felt they were trying to take the sound and make it more "rock n roll", the idea of which prog fans obviously hated, and while their influence outside of prog is great, their influence within prog itself is miminal.

Their status as a prog band is highly debatable and I feel if I included them, there would be no reason not to include Radiohead or Queen either.

__________________
It's only knock n' knowall, but I like it

http://www.last.fm/user/kingboobs

FaSho

It's awesome seeing The Moody Blues so high.

__________________

spark10036

If we are talking artist as one person, then right now is Steven Wilson, but then again I'm such a fan-boy....

__________________

FireInCairo

I wanted to see
1. King crimson
2.Can
3. kraftwerk

...but that will never happen.

__________________
O G MUDBONE: Only You can prevent forest fires.

SATCHMO

I smell a Top 100 Prog band thread brewin'. Get at it Boo.

dac

You know they were stretching for acts when Trans Siberian Orchestra makes it. Kraftwerk and Can seem like their places should have been switched. GY!BE? Are they actually prog? The Mars Volta deserve to be ahead of shit like Fates Warning. Nice to see some love for Comus though. Genesis should be down about 20 spots imo. I could go on but meh...

__________________

TheBig3

Thats the first time I've seen that site (DDD) and i don't know how the hell anyone operates on it.

__________________
I've moved to a new address

boo boo

Math rock and post rock are considered off shoots of prog to a degree. The kind of things math rock bands do isn't too different from what King Crimson was doing in the early 70s.

I think Godspeed could be considered prog. Of course post rock is such a unique category that can't just easly be pigeonholed into another genre, but it's basic premise isn't all that different from prog, in that it's anti-rock music, Godspeed do undeniably have a lot of prog elements. Complex, multi-layered and really long compositions, as well as classical and jazz influences.

As for Genesis, sorry dude but they're definetely top 5 worthy, they were one of the most original bands for their time, they're one of the most acclaimed prog bands and they're easly the most influencial prog band after KC and Yes.

__________________
It's only knock n' knowall, but I like it

http://www.last.fm/user/kingboobs

dac

Yeah that's why I made sure to add the "imo." Genesis is just one of those bands I'll never 'get.'

Also I just noticed Portishead on the list. Trip-hop =/= prog rock.

__________________