At the moment I'd say S.F. Sorrow. Just because the other two I've heard hundreds of times, and I've only heard S.F. Sorrow a few dozen times so far. It's still fresh and amazing to me, so it wins by default.

Because there is only one Syd Pink Floyd album Piper gets the nod.

I never thought SF Sorrow was any good at all but I haven't given it a chance in 20 years.

Absolutely agreed. I hadnt heard it until recently due to another thread on here, and 60's psychedelica and garage stuff is something i've only really been adding to my collection over the last year bar a few "classics".

I would have always said Sgt Peppers, hands down. Now, I'd have to say SF Sorrow.

Yay!
at least a few cats are with me

Piper for sure. I still hear something new everytime. Listen to the album on decent headphones. It takes on a whole new dimension, the production is excellent.

Every song is incredibly interesting, even the the two crappy ones. I think I am the only person who loves Pow R. Toc H...shame.

S.F. Sorrow absolutely ****s over the other two records; Phil May's contribution to the musical world is limited but this kills.

Favorite Tracks: Bracelets of Fingers, Death, Old Man Going, Loneliest Person

4 for SF Sorrow, keep em coming....

The only song from Piper I downright hate is Bike. I really loved Pow.R Toc H personally, and consider it one of the album's highlights.

I never really liked Flaming or Stethoscope but they have a very nice atmosphere as does the whole album.