Most Talented Member of Pink Floyd (lyrics, instrumental, single, beatles)

SATCHMO · 03-23-2008, 12:38 AM

Hmmm ...Talented? Thats' a tough question to answer. I'd say that if you look at Floyd's Discography as a whole You'll see more of Gilmore's influence than any other band members. Roger Waters Is a decent bass player, an OK singer, and a good songwriter, but I think he's eclipsed by Gilmore in all three of those areas (so what if Waters pretty much wrote The Wall. Its a psychotherapy session put to music, and one of the most overrated pieces of music in rock n' roll history). I'm sure Barrett was very talented, but its hard to know whether you're crediting his genius or his neurosis when talking about him, and although his influence got the ball rolling, the band quickly evolved into an entirely different musical entity. I think Gilmour gets it for me.

03-23-2008, 12:38 AM	#11 (permalink)
SATCHMO Al Dente Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: Texas Posts: 4,847	Hmmm ...Talented? Thats' a tough question to answer. I'd say that if you look at Floyd's Discography as a whole You'll see more of Gilmore's influence than any other band members. Roger Waters Is a decent bass player, an OK singer, and a good songwriter, but I think he's eclipsed by Gilmore in all three of those areas (so what if Waters pretty much wrote The Wall. Its a psychotherapy session put to music, and one of the most overrated pieces of music in rock n' roll history). I'm sure Barrett was very talented, but its hard to know whether you're crediting his genius or his neurosis when talking about him, and although his influence got the ball rolling, the band quickly evolved into an entirely different musical entity. I think Gilmour gets it for me.