Tool is better but I really dig APC..I saw them open for NIN the day Mer de Noms was released...I haven't heard (seen?) Amotive yet..

I've never cared for them. I'm glad that they are over with.

You saw them? eMOTIVe is good. `What's so funny 'bout Peace Love and Understanding` and `What's going on` are good tracks in my opinion. Check 'em, they're pretty soft - and along the lines of 3 Libras.

Isn't the whole album like full of covers?

What's Going On - Marvin Ga ye.

Imagine - John Lennon.

Seriously, are there any original A.P.C. songs on that album, cuz I'm interested in knowing if there actually is?

I only heard them today, but I really liked it. Im getting an album soon

theyre not over after maynard tours with tool, which will be a while theyre in japan either soon or now, he'll go back into the studio with billy

emotive sucks ass and most of it is covers.
passive is original but it's from maynard's other side project tapeworm with trent reznor.
tool is way better

The first album had some good songs, and the second one had a couple okay songs, the third album sucked royally. To think anyone could turn When the Levee breaks into that, eww.

I like APC i think there really good. I like Tool much more tho.. there more rock and there lyrics are much more darker and deeper.. APC with the covers they've done i only like John Lennons the most i think.. i think they did a amazing job with Imagine..

Yeah I have to admit Imagine was good when I think about it...

i like apc's remixes theyre pretty awesome

Blue's remix was good. Boy oh boy you guys ... well, I adore APC. Obviously Tool is better, but still. I wasn't aware most of the songs on eMOTIVe were covers to be honest, I knew Imagine was and I knew a few of the others, but certainly not What's going on. Sheesh that's a shock.

didnt you notice there wasnt that much time between 13th step and emotive
like months

In a recent interview with Tool in some French magazine, Maynard said that APC is done with.

APC got off to a good start with their first two albums. They were delicate I'd say. A little more artistically soft, with some headthumpers every now and again. I did love all of their music off those two albums, especially The Package.

But eMotive just sucked arse. A political-Mr.-Nogoodmusic. They definitely shouldn't have released that one.

for serious?
bummer.
i hope that means more tool music.

I would assume so, yeah. Maynard's done with APC, and Adam said that for the next Tool album, he'd like to have Maynard there for the entire writing/recording process, so I'm expecting a new Tool album within the next 2-3 years, definitely.

yeah i love APC, i think there lyrics are more meaningful than Tool's but i still love tool!! yeah i know all the songs on emotive's album are cover songs except 2 of them but i still love that album. But i like the 1 and 2 albums much more.

I wasn't aware of their existence until a year ago, more or less. Blue has to the one of the best songs on Thirteenth Step, along with The Package and Weak and Powerless. As for Mer De Noms, I'm hooked on Magdalena.

Magdalena is an awesome song, probably one of my favourites off that album.

Thinking Of You is another one I love.

When I went to see them in concert, Josh Freese was drumming away to that song and his drumstick broke, he threw it away and flicked up another one within like .1 of a second. It was pretty awesome how he did that. It's as if nothing had happened.

I like Tool..my fav. band..I totally dig APC...I have seen both live..excellent shows...I think that when it comes to "modern" rock it doesnt get much better.

Love both bands.

Six months ago I did not like Tool at all. Let me take that back, I liked the song "Sober" and that was about it. I was into emo and punk and Tool was way too serious for my tastes at the time. And then I started hanging out with an entirely different group of people and they all happened to be huge Tool fans. I held out as long as I could but was done in by a combination of "Ticks and Leeches" and mushrooms. Since then, I have become a huge Tool fan.

As for A Perfect Circle, I'm still not really into them that much. They're good and all, but I like Tool so much more it isn't even funny. I think part of the reason is that, unlike a lot of Tool fans, I don't worship at the alter of Maynard James Keenan, I worship at the alter of Adam Jones. I respect Maynard and everything, but I honestly think that Adam brings the band together. And henceforth, I'm not much of an APC fan.

Except for the Emotive album. That album rocks my ass off.

Emotive sucks it harder than a whore.

Tool is ****ing great. APC is great too, though I can see how they might be a little harder to get into at first...I love them, but not as much as Tool

I like Tool but I can't seem to get into APC past a handful of songs on their first album.

Aye, that it does. I don't even acknowledge it as part of their discography.

I like APC but I never seem to listen to their two albums anymore, however I still rate The Package as one of the coolest songs I've ever heard.

I couldnt chooes between the two i like them both equal.

APC is Maynard woman half and Tool is his penis

where the hell have you been?

i never really could get into apc. a liked a few of their songs but i just cant sit down and listen to an entire album like i can with tool.

Tool can bore me a little, i could listen to APC all day if i wanted to....

i hate them both equally

And all of them do different feelings...

what??

Each album gives a different feeling if you sit through an entire one.

My fav..has to be Lateralus...especially when feeling suicidal..

A Perfect Circle
 

Mine is Imagine..the original one is good as well though.