Does it work in a similar way with granting wishes?

If so, how many times will I need to ask the mirror to make you disappear?

It doesn't look like Lloyd Price.

Nah, it's from the Pat Boone show

The Pat Boone Show was in the swingin' 60s.
This is definitely 50s era - more than likely mid 50s Sullivan Show period.

I'm also leaning a bit toward Lonnie Sattin as a possibility.
I don't know how old he would be during this time, but it could be him.
I'd have to look again at some pix online to get a more recent look.
He was the cousin of the great Dakota Staton.
I'm still not ruling out Lloyd Price because, yes, he does look like a guy in his 20s -
this was the way classy guys in their 20s dressed in those days.

Update: yes, I'm seeing that Lonnie would've been 30 years old
during this performance. Going back to see if I can hear his voice
over the caterwauling Robinson.

What are you? Some kinda superstitious peasant?

Thanks but it isn't Lonnie Sattin or Lloyd Price.

They just don't look like the guy Robinson is with.

Go check the Documentary, they literally say it's the Pat Boone show dud

No it doesn't. It just has Woody Allen saying that he was a writer for the Pat Boone Show and
that Sugar Ray was scheduled to be on (which, by the way, he didn't, in the end, actually do).
They then cut to Sugar Ray and Lloyd on the Sullivan show (which was B&W in the 50s -
the Pat Boone Show was in color in the late 60s).

Why wouldn't they say he didn't do it

Look. How about you just do the research yourself - or better yet,
drop this off at an R&B/soul/jazz forum and see if they say the
same things that I'm getting from at least 3 heavy duty jazz (player)
and R&B dudes on this side. I'm not really interested in this anymore.

I'll check with Lloyd himself and see what he says, but that's it on my side.