Spider-Man: Who Played Him Best?
 

https://i1.wp.com/www.geekcrusade.co...01-collage.jpg

https://i0.wp.com/www.geekcrusade.co...09-posters.jpg

Who is your favorite Spider-Man?

I see where you're coming from. I was a teen when the Toby Maguire films came out. I think that 'The Amazing Spider-Man' films best portrayed the back-story of how Peter Parker became Spider-Man. Garfield seems more legit, emotionally, as far as the actor being connected to the character. Holland is great, nothing against him. He is the youngest LOOKING, so he will probably be the choice for most kids from here on out.

Andrew.

Toby is a bitch.

Andrew was easily the best Spider-Man even if the way Peter was written was lame. The man can quip. I'd be interested to see what would have happened if the first three movies hadn't existed and they'd written Peter more traditionally rather than making him all delinquent to change things up. I imagine Garfield would have been better able to cover the full spectrum of Parker's character, such as his angry moodiness that at least bordered on autism from the early days of the comic.

True story:

When my kid was living up in Hollywood, and working in the salon basement of this place, right across the street from the famous "Riot House".

https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com...21a5640f33.jpg

Met her for lunch one day and Toby and Tom Selleck were having lunch at the next table.

ye

i dont really care about andrew garfield's performance cuz those movies sucked wang

You forgot this one

No contest.
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-sZKZZZocHW...514-411164.jpg
Emo Toby wins every time.

Seriously though, both Andrew and Tom were good, but if I'd have to choose one, I'd go with Tom.
Mostly because he had a hot aunt may :P

that even felt weird in the comic book honestly, iron man just kinda showed up at spidey’s

left me thinking wait what

i still dont think theyve really done spiderman enough justice in a film yet though, toby’s just been the best we’ve had.

The Daily Bugle played him pretty good. They got a photojournalist with consistent shots that are hard to get and they're getting him to do it for pennies on the dollar.

And this gif is my jam.

https://media.giphy.com/media/jQmVFy...ized-large.gif

REALLY? You guys think this tool was the better Spiderman?

https://media.giphy.com/media/5q6cIlsVy8FBC/giphy.gif

https://media.giphy.com/media/gkXJ9WxXkWBxu/giphy.gif


https://media.giphy.com/media/rsmNKnPszXwPe/giphy.gif

I am judging all you Tobey Maguire fans.

Honestly I don't think we've ever had a good Peter Parker. Tobey was surface level with no substance, Garfield was written as someone not Peter Parker, and the new guys is... well he's fine I guess.

Well when you take only gifs from Spider-man 3, then yeah it looks bad. But when you take gifs like these

https://media1.tenor.com/images/831a...itemid=4893338

https://media1.tenor.com/images/67e6...itemid=5621388

https://media1.tenor.com/images/98bc...itemid=5621389

Now we're really talking the best Spiderman.

:laughing:

I see your point.

I was a huge Spiderman fan when I was a kid, had like 40kg of spiderman comics. I was super excited for the movie. And then they cast Tobey "charisma of a colonoscopy and a face I'd never get tired of punching" Maguire as Peter which was bad enough.. but then they cast Kirsten Dunst as Mary Jane. . Kirsten "pie face" Dunst as the hottest comicbook babe.
That's a crime I have still to forgive them, the bastards.

Nah. That honor is basically a three-way-tie between Wonder Woman, She-Hulk, and Supergirl.

dude

mary jane > wonder woman > she hulk

every ****in day

I like the female Wonder Twin, Jayna.

Church

Mary Jane still has her hymen.

every time OH says church to one of my posts its like a mini internet bj

i like it

She very much does not unless she sat on a toilet and got pregnant.

She stuck with virginity saving blowjobs until marriage.

Church and Chugalug.

Tobey Maguire is not endearing.

I only saw one and he was Spidey. Those other guys look lame but I haven’t seen their movies. I don’t know if I should vote or not.

Neither are teenage boys.

And it was on this day that everyone found out that Batlord is a sub.

I was younger than ten but the first movie I saw in the theater was Billy Jack. ****ing loved the **** out of it.

You have to be a real man to take it like a woman.

I very much doubt that comic book Mary Jane put her virginity on a pedestal.

It was a secret?

Unless they do it just to prove that they're a real man.

There was room for doubt.

the first sam raimi spiderman is my earliest theatre remember

pretty sure i saw movies before that but i cant remember them

Proof’s in the pudding.

I can see the argument for each. I think all three of them bring something unique to the table for the role.