Wall E hands down.

Wall E 1
Up 0
Toy Story 3 0

Toy Story 3 and it's no contest...

Up>>>Toy Story 3>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Wa ll E(didn't like it at all at all)

toy story 3 for me. the first half of wall e was great but the rest sucked. toy story was consistently entertaining.

Wall E: 1
Up: 1
Toy Story 3: 2

It would be easier if people counted their own votes.
Anyway, haven't watched any of them, and don't plan to. This kind of animation annoys the hell out of me. Maybe if I stumbled on them on some of the cable channels... some day.

Toy Story 3 for me. I grew up with those movies and number 3 still managed to tug that special spot in your heart! I thought it was a really sweet movie.

Wall E: 1
Up: 1
Toy Story 3: 3

I'm not a Nicholson fan, but it wouldn't surprise me if he played slightly nutty/psycopathic tendency-ish characters before that as well.

wat?

I vote Wall-E, my favourite animated film - though Toy Story 3 isn't too far behind.

Wall E - 2
Up - 1
Toy Story 3 - 3

Up - seeing the shot of the house going up with the balloons in theatres was one of my favorite theatre experiences of all time. That shot alone got me completely teared up. I'm also a fan of animated films with more "human" villains, a la "The Hunchback of Notre Dame", so I really loved this movie.

Wall E - 2
Up - 2
Toy Story 3 - 3

Toy Story 3 easily. Up and Wall E are probably my two least favorite Pixar movies.

Wall E: 2
Up: 2
Toy Story 3: 4