Red Dead Redemption

I've always wanted to try that game.

How does it fair?

Mehh..It's pretty good. My dad bought it, and never touched it, so I thought I'd try it. I'm never bored playing it (which is a plus) because there's a lot of things to do, and killing. :D Hitman is more of my cup of tea, but it's still a pretty good game.

I don't really like the Bioshock games, despite the fact they are so heavily lauded. MW3 I've yet to play but have it. I've almost finished Gears of War 3 and as a huge fan of the first two I have to say this is not as good. Everything that is in the first two games is there and as always the game engine and graphics are great, but it lacks in storyline and that is the problem, at times it feels like one game too many in the series.

Fantastic game and I'd go as far as to say one of the best games ever made.

what about Battlefield 3 vs Red Dead Redemption?

I'm getting Battlefield 3 after I finish MW3 but there is no point comparing it to Red Dead Redemption, two totally different types of games.

On the PC currently playing Rome Total War and the Broken Sword games, both great stuff.

do you prefer competitive crack-reward type killing or narrative focused killing?

I am currently attempting to do a playthrough of every Grand Theft Auto game. Also, I play Guitar Hero and/or Rock Band every day.

Juiced 2: Hot Import Nights.

I don't know why the hell I'm playing this, but I am so...