Your Day

Synthgirl · 10-12-2023, 03:22 PM

I didn’t say trans people were “uniquely vulnerable”. I also did not mention murder specifically. I’m not going to debate you anymore, it’s more than clear that I cannot provide answers to the question of what should be done in every situation involving trans people, and frankly after how rude your behavior toward myself and others on SCD has been, I don’t feel like I am obligated to humor you.

Synthgirl · 10-12-2023, 03:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Key

I'd say it's a strength. It just shows you have passion and compassion

Thank you, this really means a lot.

jadis · 10-12-2023, 04:22 PM

Well you do talk a lot about "not feeling safe." And as it happens I do believe that MTFs are vulnerable... to whatever it's called when others don't return to you or project back onto you your preferred self image. I should really brush up on my psychoanalysis cause they've got all the cool words for this stuff.

But it can be called the basic ambivalence of human condition. What makes life so interesting is that you don't know and can't control what others make of you. It's a back and forth between you and The Other where little is guaranteed.

"You will use my preferred pronouns and affirm my view of myself or I'll get you ****ing fired" is when you're afraid of life's inherent uncertainty and need to coerce others into compliance. A power thing. Power often comes in gentle guises: "you should show more consideration," "be kind," "if only you do this little thing there will be increase in the general happiness" etc

Tristan_Geoff · 10-12-2023, 07:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jadis

The Montreal gayborhood is bigger than San Fran's, just saying

lmao at the attempt at one-upping, just because you live in a city with a large queer population doesn't mean u know anything about what you're talking about

Tristan_Geoff · 10-12-2023, 07:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jadis

Well you do talk a lot about "not feeling safe." And as it happens I do believe that MTFs are vulnerable... to whatever it's called when others don't return to you or project back onto you your preferred self image. I should really brush up on my psychoanalysis cause they've got all the cool words for this stuff.

But it can be called the basic ambivalence of human condition. What makes life so interesting is that you don't know and can't control what others make of you. It's a back and forth between you and The Other where little is guaranteed.

"You will use my preferred pronouns and affirm my view of myself or I'll get you ****ing fired" is when you're afraid of life's inherent uncertainty and need to coerce others into compliance. A power thing. Power often comes in gentle guises: "you should show more consideration," "be kind," "if only you do this little thing there will be increase in the general happiness" etc

this isn't a debate fam, life is not up for debate and how people are. People's lives are at stake and your ignorance and others is why trans people are killed and targeted by politicians in the first place.

basically you've been brainwashed into a Ben Shapiro state

Synthgirl · 10-12-2023, 08:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jadis

Well you do talk a lot about "not feeling safe." And as it happens I do believe that MTFs are vulnerable... to whatever it's called when others don't return to you or project back onto you your preferred self image. I should really brush up on my psychoanalysis cause they've got all the cool words for this stuff.

But it can be called the basic ambivalence of human condition. What makes life so interesting is that you don't know and can't control what others make of you. It's a back and forth between you and The Other where little is guaranteed.

"You will use my preferred pronouns and affirm my view of myself or I'll get you ****ing fired" is when you're afraid of life's inherent uncertainty and need to coerce others into compliance. A power thing. Power often comes in gentle guises: "you should show more consideration," "be kind," "if only you do this little thing there will be increase in the general happiness" etc

No, I don't feel safe because the GOP, the religious right, and even my own damned clinic are constantly talking about (and in some states, passing) terrifying laws and healthcare bans that will prevent me from continuing to live my currently very happy life as a transgender woman. It's not about "others not accepting my self image" or whatever and you know it.

I just want the conservatives to stop attacking my people. The only people "coercing others into compliance" are the people telling me I'm not allowed to exist as myself and enacting legal force to that end. In a perfect world I wouldn't care if you called me a man or used the wrong pronouns, I used to be pretty chill about that stuff because I could brush it off as just some *******s. Now those *******s are my country's government.

And yes, your precious TERFs are in fact contributing to this. I don't care how supposedly non-bigoted JK Rowling is, if you praise and validate and platform people like Kellie Jay Keen and Matt Walsh, you are hurting trans people. End of story.

jadis · 10-12-2023, 11:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tristan_Geoff

lmao at the attempt at one-upping, just because you live in a city with a large queer population doesn't mean u know anything about what you're talking about

No that was a joke. I do know more about gay sex than yourself though, by virtue of having had more of it than you by the sound of it.

Tristan_Geoff · 10-12-2023, 11:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jadis

No that was a joke. I do know more about gay sex than yourself though, by virtue of having had more of it than you by the sound of it.

lmao wtf does it supposed mean

jadis · 10-13-2023, 12:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Synthgirl

No, I don't feel safe because the GOP, the religious right, and even my own damned clinic are constantly talking about (and in some states, passing) terrifying laws and healthcare bans that will prevent me from continuing to live my currently very happy life as a transgender woman. It's not about "others not accepting my self image" or whatever and you know it.

I just want the conservatives to stop attacking my people. The only people "coercing others into compliance" are the people telling me I'm not allowed to exist as myself and enacting legal force to that end. In a perfect world I wouldn't care if you called me a man or used the wrong pronouns, I used to be pretty chill about that stuff because I could brush it off as just some *******s. Now those *******s are my country's government.

And yes, your precious TERFs are in fact contributing to this. I don't care how supposedly non-bigoted JK Rowling is, if you praise and validate and platform people like Kellie Jay Keen and Matt Walsh, you are hurting trans people. End of story.

Some of the anti-trans measures by Republicans are discriminatory and inexcusable like the ban on military service under Trump. Also the protections against discrimination in hiring are, from what I understand, not what they should be and certainly not what they are in the UK and Canada.

But mainstream and institutional trans activism focuses not on reasonable goals that pose an affront to no one but the most hardened social conservatives. Instead their activism is geared toward 1) the erosion of biological sex as a legal category (the consequences for women are well known) and 2) the erosion of barriers against life-changing and irreversible medical interventions for minors.

Both of these are deeply controversial, to put it as politely as I can. They trigger a backlash that is not limited to social conservatives. They are deeply unpopular once you lay them out clearly and strip away the window dressing of histrionic propaganda about "trans genocide" and the truly despicable manipulation of parents by false claims about teenage suicidality.

I think that you should have access to whatever hormones you want. But if a universal ban is the best way of ensuring that no blockers or testosterone would be prescribed to teenage girls then I support the ban. The maximalist and reality-denying political goals of the extremely well-funded and organized trans lobby is part of the story of how we got to this juncture.

This is because the real goal for the likes of Jennifer Pritzker is not to strive toward a practical accommodation that would help trans people avoid discrimination. It is to make the world accept his self-image as a woman.

jadis · 10-13-2023, 12:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tristan_Geoff

lmao wtf does it supposed mean

That I remember your post about your sex life on the other forum

10-12-2023, 03:22 PM	#77321 (permalink)
Synthgirl Music Addict Join Date: Jan 2023 Location: Cheeseland USA Posts: 159	I didn’t say trans people were “uniquely vulnerable”. I also did not mention murder specifically. I’m not going to debate you anymore, it’s more than clear that I cannot provide answers to the question of what should be done in every situation involving trans people, and frankly after how rude your behavior toward myself and others on SCD has been, I don’t feel like I am obligated to humor you.

10-12-2023, 04:22 PM	#77323 (permalink)
jadis Music Addict Join Date: Jun 2021 Location: dont ask Posts: 1,405	Well you do talk a lot about "not feeling safe." And as it happens I do believe that MTFs are vulnerable... to whatever it's called when others don't return to you or project back onto you your preferred self image. I should really brush up on my psychoanalysis cause they've got all the cool words for this stuff. But it can be called the basic ambivalence of human condition. What makes life so interesting is that you don't know and can't control what others make of you. It's a back and forth between you and The Other where little is guaranteed. "You will use my preferred pronouns and affirm my view of myself or I'll get you ****ing fired" is when you're afraid of life's inherent uncertainty and need to coerce others into compliance. A power thing. Power often comes in gentle guises: "you should show more consideration," "be kind," "if only you do this little thing there will be increase in the general happiness" etc