Swag.

Basically coolest member. Swag is a word that has basically become meaningless now though. And my "swag" to Phantom means I support it.

What's his definition?

swag: apperance, style, or the way he or she presents themselves.

So basically coolest member.

In partnership with recognizing the journals, Journal Entry of the Year.

Worst debater - The member who's presence in a discussion is usually the most disruptive - I think there's a case for erasertime306 winning this. He is to date the only user I've put on ignore.
Best avatar - The best member avatar of 2011. = Urb, of course
Moderator of the Year - The member of the mod team who has helped to moderate the site the most in 2011 and who's work and efforts are the most appreciated. - Sorry to be a bit of a creep, but Pedestrian is a fantastic mod. "Crosswalking" is also my very favourite music journal.
Best new 2011 member - The best new addition to the site in 2011. - Easily RMR. His reviews have been consistently excellent.

Right on. That's pretty much what I was going for, though, in my humble opinion I think the category should just be Swag and not Most Swag.

Surely everyone is slightly swag in their own way, though?

I'd vote steveeden888 as most enigmatic.

So enigmatic I can't understand even one of his posts. I wish I could but everything just goes right over my head. Also he makes funny spaces between all of his lines.

Also I would vote eraser.time206 for biggest troll in denial
Always causing a storm with his stories that don't seem to quite make sense and defends very loosely arguments. Not to say I'm some kind of saint but reading his stuff has been a little weird.

And Ill duce is my favorite new member.
Hes extremely active around here and I think he has some quality postings and is funny as hell.

Haha... I think that is pretty much true! eraser definitely ought to win some kind of award, since a lot of his postings have been offensive and occasionally misogynist...

I'd disagree with Steveen888 though. He has been quite obnoxious in some threads and was very rude to tore, although he subsequently apologised.

And yes, Il Duce is an absolute legend.

Don't you think you're jumping the gun here lads? Nominations haven't started yet ;)