Musicbanter I call upon thee! *List Idea*

Schizotypic · 07-17-2009, 10:15 PM

This may seem insane, but I have a sort of to-get list I've been keeping for some time (about eight months)... and I thought I'd try and make it a community project rather then just being my personal north star.

The name of the game is suggestion, the list will move with the tastes of the community. All one has to do to get a band off or onto the list is say so in a post and get it two votes for their post. If you agree just say "second" or "Third" in a quote. Once it hits third I guess you can "fourth" it, but it won't matter because it'll be up onto or off of the list anyway, and will kind of be spam. Edit: For every two times a band is opposed it takes another vote to have it make the list. As an example, if Brokencyde had three votes but was opposed twice, it needs a fourth vote to count. If it was opposed four times it needs five votes to count. Sorry for making this even more complicated, but the opinions of those who disagree with a band being added need to have their thoughts counted as much as those who want to see it on there. It is, afterall, the "community" list. No need to try and keep track of things, just post your opinion and I'll keep an eye on everything.

I put this in The Lounge in the high chance that the idea doesn't catch on, and also to give more of a sense of freedom in posting. If all goes well I will be checking the page every day to make adjustments accordingly. Actual changes to the list will be moved from the "waiting" section to the actual list at least once a week. I think the list has the potential to be a great and powerful source of quick and easy new band finding and I hope Musicbanter benefits from it as much as I have, I'm looking forward to the sway of the community!

Community List:
!!!
13Th Floor Elevators
1990's
? And The Mysterians
ACDC
AIR
A Perfect Circle
Acid Bath
Addicts (The)
Agitation Free
Akphaezya
Alanis Morissette
Album Leaf (The)
Alien Sex Fiend
Alternative TV
Andrew Bird
Anglagard
Ani Difranco
Animal Collective (The)
Animals (The)
Antibalas
Apex Twins
Arcade Fire (The)
Architechture In Helsinki
Archive
Aretha Franklin
Arrested Development
Arvo Part
Ash
At The Drive In
At The Gates
Atmosphere
Autolux
Bacamarte
Bad Brains
Bad Religion
Band Of Horses
Barry Adamson
Bathory
Bauhaus
Beatles (The)
Beck
Bell And Sebastian
Ben Harer
Big Bad Voodoo Daddy
Bikini Kill
Billy Brag
Birds And Buildings
Bjork
Black Heart Procession (The)
Black Sabbath
Black Taj
Blackfoot
Blood Brothers (The)
Boards Of Canada
Bob Dylan
Boredoms
Boris
Brainiac
Brian Eno
Bud Powell
Budgie
Built To Spill
Bumblefoot
Burning Witch
Byrds (The)
CAN
Capability Brown
Captain Beefheart
Caravan
Carina Round
Cars (The)
Charles Mingus
Charlie Hunter Quartet
Church (The)
Citay
Clap Your Hands Say Yeah
Clash (The)
Cold War Kids (The)
Comus
Cor Scorpii
Cream
Crime And The City Solution
Cult (The)
Cure (The)
Cursive
DJ Shadow
Dalek
David Bowi
David Garza
Dead Boy And The Elephant Men
Dead Can Dance
Dead Kennedys
Death Cab For Cutie
Deer Hunter
Deftones
Depeche Mode
Desert Sessions (The)
Dire Staits
Disco Inferno
Dogmatics (The)
Doors (The)
Drudkh
Dusty Springfield
Echo And The Bunnyman
Eiliff
Electric Prunes (The)
Elliot Smith
Eloy
Elvis Costello And The Attractions
Enon
Etron Fou Leloublan
Faint (The)
Faith No More
Fall (The)
Far
Faust
Flaming Lips (The)
Flaming Tsunamis
Flipper
Flogging Molly
Floyd Council
Frank Zappa
Fugazi
Funkadelic
Future Of The Left
G.G Allin
Gal Costa
Genesis
Gentle Giants
Gentle Waves (The)
George Rob
Get Up Kids (The)
Gilberto Girl
Girl Talk
Glassjaw
Godspeed You! Black Emperor
Gorillaz Biscuits
Gram Rabbit
Gregorian Chant
Gun Club (The)
Guster
Hatfield And The North
Haunted (The)
Hawkwind
Head Wound City
Heartbreakers (The)
Henry Rollins
Hepcat
Hold Steady (The)
Holy Molar
Hot Water Music
Human Beinz (The)
Human Drama
ISIS
Iggy And The Stooges
Il Balletto Di Bronzo
Incubus
Isobel Campell And Mark Lanigan
Jaguar Love
Jam (The)
James Brown
Janis Joplin
Jawbox
Jawbreaker
Jedi Mind Tricks
Jeff Buckley
Jesus And Mary Chain
Jesus Lizard (The)
Jet To Brazil
Jethro Tull
Jimi Hendrix
Joanna Newsom
John Cale
John Coltrane
John Lennon
John Martyn
John Perish
Johnny Winters
Joy Division
K'naan
Kaleidoscope (The)
Kansas
Kate Bush
Keyo Dot
Khanate
Killers (The)
Kills (The)
King Crimson
King For A Day
Kings Of Leon
Kinks (The)
Kraftwerk
L7
Leaf Hound
Led Zeppelin
Left Banke (The)
Leonard Cohen
Les Claypool
Les Savy Fav
Liars
Lifehouse
Locust (The)
Long Beach Dub Allstars
Loop
Lords Of Acid
Lou Reed
Love
Lyres (The)
Mad Capsule Markets (The)
Made In Mexico
Magma
Mahavishnu Orchestra
Main
Man Man
Mark Wirtz
Mars Volta (The)
Marvin ***e And Tammy Terrel
Massive Attack
Mastodon
Maudlin Of The Well
Mclusky
Me Without You
Medeski, Martain And Wood
Melt Banana
Melvins (The)
Meshuggah
Mice Parade
Mick Harvey
Midnight Oil
Mike Ness
Miles Davis
Ministry
Minor Threat
Minos The Bear
Minutemen
Misfits
Mission Of Burma
Moby
Modest Mouse
Moldy Peaches
Monks (The)
Montanas (The)
Moonsorrow
Morphine
Morrisey
Mountain Ash Band
Mr.Bungle
Muddy Waters
Murder City Devils
Muse
My Bloody Valentine
Myrkgrav
Mysteria
Neighborhoods (The)
Neon Blonde
Neutral Milk Hotel
New Order
New Sun
Nick Cave
Nick Drake
Nine Inch Nails
Nirvana
Noise Ratdet
One Day As A Lion
Operation Ivy
Opeth
Ornette Coleman
Os Mutantes
Otis Redding
PJ Harvey
Panda Bear
Panzerpappa
Patti Smith
Pavement
Peggy Lee
Pelican
Phoenix
Pil
Pink Anderson
Pink Floyd
Pixies (The)
Placebo
Poison Idea
Poison The Well
Police (The)
Porcupine Tree
Portshed
Postal Service (The)
Pretty Girls Make Graves
Pretty Things (The)
Primus
Prince
Proyecto 'A'
Psychic Tv
Public Enemy
Pulp
Pylon
Q65
Queen
Queens Of The Stone Age
Quest For Fire
Quicksand
Radiohead
Rage Against The Machine
Raincoats (The)
Rancid
Ratatat
Red Hot Chili Peppers
Refused
Renaissance
Richard Hell
Rising Sons (The)
Rival Schools
Rokes (The)
Rolling Stones
Room
Roots (The)
Rush
Salma Mammas Manna
Saul Williams
Scars On Broadway
Scott Walker
Serge Gainsbourg
Serj Tankian
Shins (The)
Shout Out Out Out
Sigur Ros
Simple Minds
Slayer
Slint
Small Faces (The)
Smalls (The)
Smashing Pumpkins
Smiths (The)
Social Distortion
Solillaquists Of Sound
Sonic Youth (The)
Sonics (The)
Sopwith Camel (The)
Sparta
Spoon
Squirrel Nut Zippers
Steel pulse
Stone Temple Pilots
Stranglers (The)
Streets (The)
Sugar Cubes
Suicide
Sun Ra
Sunny Day Real Estate
Supergrass
Syd Barett
System Of A Down
T.v On The Radio
TSundowners (The)
Talking Heads (The)
Tarantula Hawk
Tears For Fears
Television
Temptations (The)
Texas Is The Reason
The (The)
The Bruthers (The)
Thelonious Monk
These Arms Are Snakes
They Might Be Giants
Third World
Thomson Twins
Thrice
Thursday
Tim Buckley
Ting Tings
Today Is The Day
Tokyo Police Club
Tom Petty
Tom Waits
Tomorrow
Tool
Tortoise
Travis
Tribe Called Quest
Turquoise
Twinemen
Ugly's (The)
Ultra Vivid Scene
Ulver
Valient Thorr
Vampire Weekend
Van Halen
Van Morrison
Velvet Underground (The)
Vendetta Red
Violent Femmes
Virgin Of The Birds
Walkmen (The)
Wall Of Voodoo
Warsawpack
We Versus The Shark
White Stripes (The)
Who (The)
Wilco
Windir
Wire
Wishbone
Wolfmother
Wu-tang Clan
Wyclef
X
XTC
Yeah Yeah Yeahs
Yes
Yndi Halda
Youth (The)

Waiting:
To Be Added:

To Be Taken Off:

Current Number: 414

Schizotypic · 07-17-2009, 10:15 PM

Added:
Pil (week one)
Genesis (week one)
Yndi Halda (week one)
Kraftwerk (week one)
Porcupine Tree (week one)
Aphex Twin (week one)

Taken off:
U2 (week one)
Bright Eyes (week one)
MGMT (week one)
The Libertines (week one)
Jimmy Eat World (week one)

In week one the number or bands went from 413 to 414.

Freebase Dali · 07-17-2009, 10:21 PM

Take out: Moby
Add in: Hybrid
Put a rush order on: Squirrel Nut Zippers

P.S... this is an excellent idea.

~~someonecompletelyrandom~~ · 07-17-2009, 10:23 PM

Completely Ignore: Freebase Dali

I like Moby.

boo boo · 07-17-2009, 10:24 PM

Take out: Bright Eyes
Add in: Genesis

Miltamec Soundsquinaez · 07-17-2009, 10:25 PM

All of them are good.......

and buy every CD, too.

Freebase Dali · 07-17-2009, 10:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Conan

Completely Ignore: Freebase Dali
I like Moby.

Not in favor.

~~someonecompletelyrandom~~ · 07-17-2009, 10:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by boo boo

Take out: Bright Eyes
Add in: Genesis

Seconded

Take Out: U2
Add in: PiL

boo boo · 07-17-2009, 10:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Miltamec Soundsquinaez

All of them are good.......

and buy every CD, too.

Wow, now that's what I call open minded and undiscriminating.

Granted I like most of the bands out of these that I have heard.

Antonio · 07-17-2009, 10:30 PM

no thanks

Take out: Mice Parade
Add in: Clutch

07-17-2009, 10:15 PM	#1 (permalink)
Schizotypic Souls of Sound Sailors Join Date: Feb 2009 Location: Mojave Posts: 759	Musicbanter I call upon thee! List Idea This may seem insane, but I have a sort of to-get list I've been keeping for some time (about eight months)... and I thought I'd try and make it a community project rather then just being my personal north star. The name of the game is suggestion, the list will move with the tastes of the community. All one has to do to get a band off or onto the list is say so in a post and get it two votes for their post. If you agree just say "second" or "Third" in a quote. Once it hits third I guess you can "fourth" it, but it won't matter because it'll be up onto or off of the list anyway, and will kind of be spam. Edit: For every two times a band is opposed it takes another vote to have it make the list. As an example, if Brokencyde had three votes but was opposed twice, it needs a fourth vote to count. If it was opposed four times it needs five votes to count. Sorry for making this even more complicated, but the opinions of those who disagree with a band being added need to have their thoughts counted as much as those who want to see it on there. It is, afterall, the "community" list. No need to try and keep track of things, just post your opinion and I'll keep an eye on everything. I put this in The Lounge in the high chance that the idea doesn't catch on, and also to give more of a sense of freedom in posting. If all goes well I will be checking the page every day to make adjustments accordingly. Actual changes to the list will be moved from the "waiting" section to the actual list at least once a week. I think the list has the potential to be a great and powerful source of quick and easy new band finding and I hope Musicbanter benefits from it as much as I have, I'm looking forward to the sway of the community! Community List: !!! 13Th Floor Elevators 1990's ? And The Mysterians ACDC AIR A Perfect Circle Acid Bath Addicts (The) Agitation Free Akphaezya Alanis Morissette Album Leaf (The) Alien Sex Fiend Alternative TV Andrew Bird Anglagard Ani Difranco Animal Collective (The) Animals (The) Antibalas Apex Twins Arcade Fire (The) Architechture In Helsinki Archive Aretha Franklin Arrested Development Arvo Part Ash At The Drive In At The Gates Atmosphere Autolux Bacamarte Bad Brains Bad Religion Band Of Horses Barry Adamson Bathory Bauhaus Beatles (The) Beck Bell And Sebastian Ben Harer Big Bad Voodoo Daddy Bikini Kill Billy Brag Birds And Buildings Bjork Black Heart Procession (The) Black Sabbath Black Taj Blackfoot Blood Brothers (The) Boards Of Canada Bob Dylan Boredoms Boris Brainiac Brian Eno Bud Powell Budgie Built To Spill Bumblefoot Burning Witch Byrds (The) CAN Capability Brown Captain Beefheart Caravan Carina Round Cars (The) Charles Mingus Charlie Hunter Quartet Church (The) Citay Clap Your Hands Say Yeah Clash (The) Cold War Kids (The) Comus Cor Scorpii Cream Crime And The City Solution Cult (The) Cure (The) Cursive DJ Shadow Dalek David Bowi David Garza Dead Boy And The Elephant Men Dead Can Dance Dead Kennedys Death Cab For Cutie Deer Hunter Deftones Depeche Mode Desert Sessions (The) Dire Staits Disco Inferno Dogmatics (The) Doors (The) Drudkh Dusty Springfield Echo And The Bunnyman Eiliff Electric Prunes (The) Elliot Smith Eloy Elvis Costello And The Attractions Enon Etron Fou Leloublan Faint (The) Faith No More Fall (The) Far Faust Flaming Lips (The) Flaming Tsunamis Flipper Flogging Molly Floyd Council Frank Zappa Fugazi Funkadelic Future Of The Left G.G Allin Gal Costa Genesis Gentle Giants Gentle Waves (The) George Rob Get Up Kids (The) Gilberto Girl Girl Talk Glassjaw Godspeed You! Black Emperor Gorillaz Biscuits Gram Rabbit Gregorian Chant Gun Club (The) Guster Hatfield And The North Haunted (The) Hawkwind Head Wound City Heartbreakers (The) Henry Rollins Hepcat Hold Steady (The) Holy Molar Hot Water Music Human Beinz (The) Human Drama ISIS Iggy And The Stooges Il Balletto Di Bronzo Incubus Isobel Campell And Mark Lanigan Jaguar Love Jam (The) James Brown Janis Joplin Jawbox Jawbreaker Jedi Mind Tricks Jeff Buckley Jesus And Mary Chain Jesus Lizard (The) Jet To Brazil Jethro Tull Jimi Hendrix Joanna Newsom John Cale John Coltrane John Lennon John Martyn John Perish Johnny Winters Joy Division K'naan Kaleidoscope (The) Kansas Kate Bush Keyo Dot Khanate Killers (The) Kills (The) King Crimson King For A Day Kings Of Leon Kinks (The) Kraftwerk L7 Leaf Hound Led Zeppelin Left Banke (The) Leonard Cohen Les Claypool Les Savy Fav Liars Lifehouse Locust (The) Long Beach Dub Allstars Loop Lords Of Acid Lou Reed Love Lyres (The) Mad Capsule Markets (The) Made In Mexico Magma Mahavishnu Orchestra Main Man Man Mark Wirtz Mars Volta (The) Marvin *e And Tammy Terrel Massive Attack Mastodon Maudlin Of The Well Mclusky Me Without You Medeski, Martain And Wood Melt Banana Melvins (The) Meshuggah Mice Parade Mick Harvey Midnight Oil Mike Ness Miles Davis Ministry Minor Threat Minos The Bear Minutemen Misfits Mission Of Burma Moby Modest Mouse Moldy Peaches Monks (The) Montanas (The) Moonsorrow Morphine Morrisey Mountain Ash Band Mr.Bungle Muddy Waters Murder City Devils Muse My Bloody Valentine Myrkgrav Mysteria Neighborhoods (The) Neon Blonde Neutral Milk Hotel New Order New Sun Nick Cave Nick Drake Nine Inch Nails Nirvana Noise Ratdet One Day As A Lion Operation Ivy Opeth Ornette Coleman Os Mutantes Otis Redding PJ Harvey Panda Bear Panzerpappa Patti Smith Pavement Peggy Lee Pelican Phoenix Pil Pink Anderson Pink Floyd Pixies (The) Placebo Poison Idea Poison The Well Police (The) Porcupine Tree Portshed Postal Service (The) Pretty Girls Make Graves Pretty Things (The) Primus Prince Proyecto 'A' Psychic Tv Public Enemy Pulp Pylon Q65 Queen Queens Of The Stone Age Quest For Fire Quicksand Radiohead Rage Against The Machine Raincoats (The) Rancid Ratatat Red Hot Chili Peppers Refused Renaissance Richard Hell Rising Sons (The) Rival Schools Rokes (The) Rolling Stones Room Roots (The) Rush Salma Mammas Manna Saul Williams Scars On Broadway Scott Walker Serge Gainsbourg Serj Tankian Shins (The) Shout Out Out Out Sigur Ros Simple Minds Slayer Slint Small Faces (The) Smalls (The) Smashing Pumpkins Smiths (The) Social Distortion Solillaquists Of Sound Sonic Youth (The) Sonics (The) Sopwith Camel (The) Sparta Spoon Squirrel Nut Zippers Steel pulse Stone Temple Pilots Stranglers (The) Streets (The) Sugar Cubes Suicide Sun Ra Sunny Day Real Estate Supergrass Syd Barett System Of A Down T.v On The Radio TSundowners (The) Talking Heads (The) Tarantula Hawk Tears For Fears Television Temptations (The) Texas Is The Reason The (The) The Bruthers (The) Thelonious Monk These Arms Are Snakes They Might Be Giants Third World Thomson Twins Thrice Thursday Tim Buckley Ting Tings Today Is The Day Tokyo Police Club Tom Petty Tom Waits Tomorrow Tool Tortoise Travis Tribe Called Quest Turquoise Twinemen Ugly's (The) Ultra Vivid Scene Ulver Valient Thorr Vampire Weekend Van Halen Van Morrison Velvet Underground (The) Vendetta Red Violent Femmes Virgin Of The Birds Walkmen (The) Wall Of Voodoo Warsawpack We Versus The Shark White Stripes (The) Who (The) Wilco Windir Wire Wishbone Wolfmother Wu-tang Clan Wyclef X XTC Yeah Yeah Yeahs Yes Yndi Halda Youth (The) Waiting: To Be Added: To Be Taken Off:** Current Number: 414 Last edited by Schizotypic; 07-22-2009 at 12:53 PM.

07-17-2009, 10:15 PM	#2 (permalink)
Schizotypic Souls of Sound Sailors Join Date: Feb 2009 Location: Mojave Posts: 759	Added: Pil (week one) Genesis (week one) Yndi Halda (week one) Kraftwerk (week one) Porcupine Tree (week one) Aphex Twin (week one) Taken off: U2 (week one) Bright Eyes (week one) MGMT (week one) The Libertines (week one) Jimmy Eat World (week one) In week one the number or bands went from 413 to 414. Last edited by Schizotypic; 07-22-2009 at 12:52 PM.

07-17-2009, 10:21 PM	#3 (permalink)
Freebase Dali Partying on the inside Join Date: Mar 2009 Posts: 5,584	Take out: Moby Add in: Hybrid Put a rush order on: Squirrel Nut Zippers P.S... this is an excellent idea. __________________

07-17-2009, 10:25 PM	#6 (permalink)
Miltamec Soundsquinaez Aural melody discerner Join Date: Jan 2008 Location: in a truck down by the interstate Posts: 347	All of them are good....... and buy every CD, too. __________________ Hello, my name is Luka. I live on the 2nd floor.

07-17-2009, 10:23 PM	#4 (permalink)
~~someonecompletelyrandom~~ Account Disabled Join Date: Nov 2008 Posts: 4,538	Completely Ignore: Freebase Dali I like Moby.