Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   The Lounge (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/)
-   -   English grammar (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/22957-english-grammar.html)

adidasss 05-22-2007 05:08 PM

English grammar
 
This topic trouble me so. First off, I don't understand how anyone can go through schooling and not know how to spell properly. How does that happen? Are you people not required to write in school? Are all your classes oral? Do you not read books? I'm speaking from a viewpoint of a foreigner who took English twice a week (yes, that means I was required to speak or read in English only an hour and a half a week) and yet it appears that my grammar is better than 70% of the native English speakers...are you people not embarrassed of this fact? Admittedly, my grammar and spelling are far from perfect, but if I can manage to construct a coherent sentence in a foreign language, how is it that so many native English speakers fail to do the same? Really...I'm curious to know. What are your excuses? How do the rest of you, the (seeming) minority that has a handle on their own language, explain this phenomenon?

PopIsDead 05-22-2007 05:18 PM

I explain this phenomenon by saying that a lot of people (especially Americans) are lazy idiots who feel it's better to save time in writing whatever they're writing than to make their sentence coherent. Sorry if that was incoherent.

sleepy jack 05-22-2007 05:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PopIsDead (Post 368563)
I explain this phenomenon by saying that a lot of people (especially Americans) are lazy idiots who feel it's better to save time in writing whatever they're writing than to make their sentence coherent. Sorry if that was incoherent.

Quoted for tr00f.

Curiosity marijan, are you basing this off from encounters with teenage americans on forums? Because thats a terrible thing to base it off. Since the majority of teens on the internet think its okay to type like they're writing a text message.

PopIsDead 05-22-2007 05:26 PM

Teenage Americans make me want to laugh and then choke myself with a cereal bar.

adidasss 05-22-2007 05:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Crowquill (Post 368568)
Quoted for tr00f.

Curiosity marijan, are you basing this off from encounters with teenage americans on forums? Because thats a terrible thing to base it off. Since the majority of teens on the internet think its okay to type like they're writing a text message.

So you're saying that in real life they're quite capable of spelling normally?

Sparky 05-22-2007 05:33 PM

d00d it s nat mi foult i dun carr, i liek 2 busy txtn to do the sentuncos.

****, i put a comma in there >.<

you'd be surprised at how bad some kids are at genral reading and writing comprehension at my school, but mainly it's because it doesn't have an immediate benefit and its rather time consuming at first, making kids not want to push themselves to get better at it.

i blame microsoft word >:[

sleepy jack 05-22-2007 05:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss (Post 368574)
So you're saying that in real life they're quite capable of spelling normally?

I find most of them are quite capable, they're just lazy.

adidasss 05-22-2007 05:43 PM

I don't accept that as a valid excuse. No one is that lazy.

sleepy jack 05-22-2007 05:52 PM

You'd be amazed, i've called people out on it hear and they all tell me this isn't school.

right-track 05-22-2007 05:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Crowquill (Post 368588)
You'd be amazed, i've called people out on it hear and they all tell me this isn't school.

*here

5/10 see me!

I blame the educational system.

In my day the curriculum was much more demanding than it is nowadays.

anticipation 05-22-2007 06:12 PM

It's not that most people do not know how to speak and write correctly, but rather most people choosing to spell incorrectly and speak like their 4 years old.



its just that ebonic lexicon eloquence, baby.

TheBig3 05-22-2007 06:13 PM

this thread offends me

cardboard adolescent 05-22-2007 06:14 PM

Your neglect of punctuation and capitalization offends me.

TheBig3 05-22-2007 06:22 PM

I don't know, to answer the OP, I'm often just slapping up posts in between whatever else I'm doing. I'm sure you feel as if I'm making up some **** but I'm not so incredibly focused on what people think of my sloppy posts here, especially since the time I do put in some effort I still get "I'm not sure I get you."

Other times I'm usually so pissed off at some stupid prevailing opinion that I'm writing a mile (lets say 1200 meters) a minute and don't even stop to think about grammar, I just want to slash at an argument.

cardboard adolescent 05-22-2007 06:24 PM

...

I'm not sure I get you.

LazyFingers 05-22-2007 06:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss (Post 368557)
What are your excuses?

Mon jus ralax it nun ov ur busnis how i spel on de internt. I cun spel in real livfe so y shud i spel curectly here, hu? Godz im glad i gut dat of mi chest.

CAPTAIN CAVEMAN 05-22-2007 07:55 PM

^**** you.

Yeah, it's laziness.

Frances 05-22-2007 09:04 PM

Texting is no excuse either! Spell properly! A lot of people dismiss apparently uneducated posts, BECAUSE OF THE WAY THEY'RE WRITTEN!!! I know I do sometimes. It's hard to convince yourself you're talking to an intelligent person when they spell worse than your 6 year old nephew who still wets the bed.

TheBig3 05-22-2007 09:59 PM

Thats really your loss then, isn't it. Awfully mad for someone who seems to be dismissive of the whole thing. Almost as if you're mad you can't read through. If you don't like poor spelling, perhaps you should leave the internet.

Those perturbed by poor spelling might find yourselves in a bit of hypocrisy down the road. I'd be less virtuous on my stand against it. Those slighted by this post may see fit to redeem themselves by exposing a more harsh reality. Half of you that do spell correctly have very little if anything interesting to say. You chant simple maxims and common mantras that are as conformed as your spelling.

I use to be of the mind that I would give you some sympathies in your complaint, because occasionally its valid, but I find that you're closed minded in most of your views and your failure to compromise is just as ignorant, if not more so that poor grammar.

Spelling can be fixed (just like erroneous opinions might I add), poor intellect and intellectual bankruptcy cannot. You all have your flaws. Taking a righteous stand against someone else's flaw might be bad for business in your internet popularity game. And my use of righteous isn't haphazard, people who continue to have this stance will be referred to, at least by me, as oojayhadists.

I know I crack myself up, but seriously, not since Napoleon have the political insults been that well crafted. I mean come on, thats right up there with "idealouges."

Frances 05-22-2007 10:13 PM

o u r so riet. i men, if ppl cnt un-D-stan u dats dare folt. spelingz ova ratted enywayz. i don git ppl hoo bich abot it, cnt thay raed?

TheBig3 05-22-2007 10:33 PM

Oh no, hyperbole to prove me wrong! whatever will i do? I mean honestly, you're looking like Crowquill in the "Why rap" thread.

If someone writes like that, its a lot different than someone who just can't spell words. English isn't exactly phonetic, and our use of 5+ languages makes it more than a little understandable that people might not spell ridiculous, tsunami, proboscis, or kindergarten correctly every time. We've all used l33t speak, so we're all guilty of the crime you're condemning. The easy and populist argument.

Frances 05-22-2007 10:42 PM

Settle down man. if you'd just climb down from that high-chair you'd realize we are not talking about bigger individual words.

sleepy jack 05-22-2007 10:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBig3KilledMyRainDog (Post 368815)
Oh no, hyperbole to prove me wrong! whatever will i do? I mean honestly, you're looking like Crowquill in the "Why rap" thread.

ur jst h8n cuz of mi ubr 1337 $|<1||z.

TheBig3 05-22-2007 11:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Frances (Post 368817)
Settle down man. if you'd just climb down from that high-chair you'd realize we are not talking about bigger individual words.

First of all. Settle down is a sure shot sign of a weak argument. People say "settle down" when they are losing an argument. tell me, did I use too many capital letters? Maybe too many exclamation points? Perhaps it was my irate font color?

If you read my argument you'd know that my point in using those words was that none of them are English in origin. Therefore, they way they are pronounced are different and it prevents English from having a phonetically standard way of spelling words. Letters in French don't make the same sounds as German, or Japanese.

Spelling in English isn't something everyone one is going to do perfectly.

Blain 05-22-2007 11:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss (Post 368557)
This topic trouble me so. First off, I don't understand how anyone can go through schooling and not know how to spell properly. How does that happen? Are you people not required to write in school? Are all your classes oral? Do you not read books? I'm speaking from a viewpoint of a foreigner who took English twice a week (yes, that means I was required to speak or read in English only an hour and a half a week) and yet it appears that my grammar is better than 70% of the native English speakers...are you people not embarrassed of this fact? Admittedly, my grammar and spelling are far from perfect, but if I can manage to construct a coherent sentence in a foreign language, how is it that so many native English speakers fail to do the same? Really...I'm curious to know. What are your excuses? How do the rest of you, the (seeming) minority that has a handle on their own language, explain this phenomenon?


EDIT: From reading the thread, I understand your point. Well, People just treat this no differently to msn... There really should be no problem with this.

Merkaba 05-23-2007 12:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBig3KilledMyRainDog (Post 368830)
First of all. Settle down is a sure shot sign of a weak argument. People say "settle down" when they are losing an argument. tell me, did I use too many capital letters? Maybe too many exclamation points? Perhaps it was my irate font color?

Lol, you rock.

Adidasss; It's just not as embarrassing to the Western world anymore, to spell like complete morons. In 1990 if you spelt like crap, people would call you on it and you'd probably call yourself dumb. In 2007, you're rarely called on it, and if you are, you're excuse is that it's cool, you're modern, and everyone's doing it.

Most people still like to spell properly so as not to come across as complete tossers but the variance is pretty huge compared to 20 years ago, or even 10.

Frances 05-23-2007 12:42 AM

[QUOTE=TheBig3KilledMyRainDog;368830]First of all. Settle down is a sure shot sign of a weak argument. People say "settle down" when they are losing an argument.QUOTE]

Really? I didn't know those words were only used together in losing arguments. People also say "settle down" when someone is getting worked up.

adidasss 05-23-2007 03:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBig3KilledMyRainDog (Post 368608)
I don't know, to answer the OP, I'm often just slapping up posts in between whatever else I'm doing. I'm sure you feel as if I'm making up some **** but I'm not so incredibly focused on what people think of my sloppy posts here, especially since the time I do put in some effort I still get "I'm not sure I get you."

Other times I'm usually so pissed off at some stupid prevailing opinion that I'm writing a mile (lets say 1200 meters) a minute and don't even stop to think about grammar, I just want to slash at an argument.

Believe it or not, I didn't have you in mind when I made this tread. More like people like 6655321. I'm sure that if you took the time to actually read your posts before posting them you could spell as well as the next person.:D

Quote:

Originally Posted by Frances (Post 368780)
It's hard to convince yourself you're talking to an intelligent person when they spell worse than your 6 year old nephew who still wets the bed.

Exactly! Although, I'm not so sure that the people who do that actually care if their opinions loose validity simply because they're spelled badly. We're basically talking about complete morons here, which is still rather puzzling because one would think that such people had difficulty finishing their schooling.

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBig3KilledMyRainDog (Post 368799)
Half of you that do spell correctly have very little if anything interesting to say. You chant simple maxims and common mantras that are as conformed as your spelling.

I use to be of the mind that I would give you some sympathies in your complaint, because occasionally its valid, but I find that you're closed minded in most of your views and your failure to compromise is just as ignorant, if not more so that poor grammar.

Spelling can be fixed (just like erroneous opinions might I add), poor intellect and intellectual bankruptcy cannot. You all have your flaws. Taking a righteous stand against someone else's flaw might be bad for business in your internet popularity game. And my use of righteous isn't haphazard, people who continue to have this stance will be referred to, at least by me, as oojayhadists.

I know I crack myself up, but seriously, not since Napoleon have the political insults been that well crafted. I mean come on, thats right up there with "idealouges."

You're fooling yourself if you think that appearance is irrelevant as opposed to content. Many will disregard the latter if it isn't packaged in standardized English.

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBig3KilledMyRainDog (Post 368815)
Oh no, hyperbole to prove me wrong! whatever will i do? I mean honestly, you're looking like Crowquill in the "Why rap" thread.

If someone writes like that, its a lot different than someone who just can't spell words. English isn't exactly phonetic, and our use of 5+ languages makes it more than a little understandable that people might not spell ridiculous, tsunami, proboscis, or kindergarten correctly every time. We've all used l33t speak, so we're all guilty of the crime you're condemning. The easy and populist argument.

I'm not saying everyone should have a vocabulary that equals that of Joyce, but when someone can't write basic thoughts in their own language I start to wonder how that can happen.

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBig3KilledMyRainDog (Post 368830)
If you read my argument you'd know that my point in using those words was that none of them are English in origin. Therefore, they way they are pronounced are different and it prevents English from having a phonetically standard way of spelling words. Letters in French don't make the same sounds as German, or Japanese.

Spelling in English isn't something everyone one is going to do perfectly.

Weak argument. It's your own language, it's not only your duty to know it, it's a necessity (or at least it should be, but seeing as how most of the people that can't spell worth a damn have gone through a certain period of schooling, it may not actually be necessary to know how to write in English to survive).

swim 05-23-2007 05:43 AM

It's not like we chose the language so contrary to itself. We were merely born.

MURDER JUNKIE 05-23-2007 12:02 PM

Us Canucks are Natural Born Spellers, once it becomes an Olympic sport we will have at least a chance at a Gold Medal

right-track 05-23-2007 12:12 PM

In England there are 2 types of spellers.
Those that can and them wot carnt.

tdoc210 05-23-2007 01:35 PM

Hmmm, tis the internet, and i can see misspellings such as reversed letters do to a fast hand, or overlooking. I of course am guilty of that type of error, but basically, I know how to write correctly, being in college level English all your life teaches you such, but I,m not going to bother with such nonsense as fragments, run-ons, clauses, and participles, on a message board.

sleepy jack 05-23-2007 03:15 PM

Yeah but you could bother with coherency.

tdoc210 05-23-2007 03:48 PM

no, it is. It's the misplaced letters that throw you off most likely.

jackhammer 05-23-2007 03:50 PM

I cannot speak for our American cousins-but here in U.K we can be pretty lazy about spelling and punctuation.

There is also a huge amount of accents and colloquialisms here (slang basically-just showing off with a big word!), which has a bearing on our speech-people living no more than fifty miles apart can have different words for different things.

E.G-Chewing Gum is Chuddy where I come from.

When English is not your first language you are going to learn it correctly-whereas a lot of English kids know the lingo (slang!) and so; cannot be bothered.

Adidasss-I am very impressed with your English. An erstwhile work colleague of mine who has since become a good friend, is Slovakian and her English is excellent considering she has had such a short time to learn.

Blain 05-26-2007 05:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mamagarmr (Post 368941)
Hmmm, tis the internet, and i can see misspellings such as reversed letters do to a fast hand, or overlooking. I of course am guilty of that type of error, but basically, I know how to write correctly, being in college level English all your life teaches you such, but I,m not going to bother with such nonsense as fragments, run-ons, clauses, and participles, on a message board.

Half of those commas were un needed =\.

sleepy jack 05-26-2007 05:48 PM

Try nearly all of them.

Trauma 05-28-2007 09:38 PM

The percent of illiterate English speakers has been lowered to make it seem like they are more intelligent than people who speak other languages when in fact the standard for being considered illiterate has only been lowered.

adidasss 06-08-2008 02:15 AM

Hi, let's try to put aside the rather obnoxious opening post and use this thread to correct other people's mistakes. Maybe we'll all learn a thing or two.

For example:
Quote:

Originally Posted by phallpdx (Post 488285)
They are alright, but their are many more bands which sound similar, but are more artistically legit. They borrow Indie sounds/ideas and apply them to something more mainstream. Anyways, I listen to them... but their are much better bands in the same genre. A good stepping stone band.

This is something I see a lot so let's try and clear up a few things;

their - that which belongs to them. Examples: their accomplishments; their home town.

there - At or in that place. Examples: Sit over there. Wouldn't go there again...

they're - Contraction of "they are". Examples: They're so big. They're coming.

Also:

your - of, belonging to, or associated with you. Examples: Your book. Your bad taste in music.

you're - Contraction of "you are". Examples: You're a twat. You're not allowed to misspell this again.

K, thank you, that is all, you may go now...

right-track 06-08-2008 05:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss (Post 488286)
your - of, belonging to, or associated with you. Examples: Your book. Your bad taste in music.

you're - Contraction of "you are". Examples: You're a twat. You're not allowed to misspell this again.

K, thank you, that is all, you may go now...

Don't forget to chastise the Americans with their miss-use of the word then instead of than.

Despite a traditional Grammar School education, I've always had problems with your and you're.
In fact, it wasn't till a few months ago that the penny finally dropped. :o:


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:12 AM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.