It all depends on your mood..

if you are ready for some hardcore eatin' action grab the crunnnnnchy
but
if you are going for that soft smooth shaved vagina feel to your sandwich go for teh creeeeaaamy

who keeps bringing back all these old threads?!

idk...but msooth for me...like simon.

It's weird, they probably searched for peanut butter then voted without posting, scariness.

eeksh. a lot of old threads are coming back with people who i have no idea about....you know, who i haven't seen posting in a while.

if you are the trying kind,try SMOOTH peanut butter and jelly in pancakes.

Whichever is easier to lick off Lindsays naked body

smooth and crunchy combined

whats the point in that......... then you just have less crunchy pb

hmmm....EW.