The ultimate musical question
 

think about this:usehead:

if you where on a desert island, and the only things you could have where a cd player, 3 cds, and one other thing, what would the 3 cds and the other thing be?

PS: Other thing CANNOT be an mp3 player and 3 cds CANNOT BE BURNT!!

Also, this is my first post, so please comment on my n00bishness, i dont mind, and tell me if you like the thread:)

Matt:hphones:

1. The Fall of Troy- Self Titled
2. Converge- Jane Doe
3. Mineral- Power of Failing

the other thing would be a boat.

1. Circle Takes The Square "As Roots Undo"
2. She Died Real Pretty "Carpe Diem Is Dead"
3. Sunny Day Real Estate "Diary"

and an airplane.

Haha...sucks you don't have any gas. Should have thought about that one.

Yeah, and it sucks you don't have OARS...or a SAIL....

Burn. I bring

A Kyuss album
A Tool album
A Porcupine Tree album

And I'll have a cheerleading team.

I can row with my hands. Get some motion going and then just let the waves take me away while I sleep.

you dumb bitches, you're forgetting the batteries for the cd player....

Mines solar powered.

Bitch.

oh ok, if we're going by those standards, i'd bring the white stripes - elephant, the mars volta - frances the mute and the doors - l.a. woman....and the other thing would be a nuclear powered hovering 6 star hotel with lots of hot naked guys and a mall so i can buy the batteries and other cd's....

bitch.

That's more than one thing. You lose for cheating. You get nothing.

what are you talking about, the mall is IN the hotel! it's all in that one thing.....the nuclear powered 6 star hovering hotel/mall....what, now you're gonna tell me you've never heard of that and that it doesn't exist...

iron maiden - killers
the clash - combat rock
metallica - and justice for all

lubricant.

wow...iron maiden aye....that other thing should be a loaded pistol...

Oh moley, need some ice for that burn? and some LUBE FOR ADIDASSS'S GRANDMA?

stick to your own damn island, 'one mans poison another mans wine' and my island is going to have iron maiden bursting my ear drums.

plus i refuse to even debate with someone who puts the white stripes in his top 3 'survival on an island' album list, it nearly bloody killed me the day i bought it.

Well....For the CDs
1.Frances the mute - The Mars Volta
2.BE - Pain of Salvation
3.V:The New Mytholegy suite - Symphony X

For my other Object...Pedal Boat

Three copies of A Charlie Brown Christmas....just in case.


And a thesaraus.

Christina Aguilera - Dirty
Rihanna - A Girl Like Me
Kelly Clarkson - Breakaway

I would take nothing else.

falling forward- hand me down
tool- undertow
oasis- definitely maybe
and a puppy

iggy pop- lust for life
david bowie-ziggystardust
lou reed-tranformer

spikey cause i love her

The Doors - L.A. Woman
Pink Floyd - The Wall
The Beatles - Revolver

Well Fueled Space Ship filled with Candy and a map

Rage Against the Machine - Battle for Los Angeles
White Stripes - White Blood Cells
Death From Above 1979 - You're a Woman, I'm a Machine

and



a super pack of toliet paper

that's a DAMN good answer!

mmm tough one

afi-sing the sorrow
jacks mannequin-everything in transit
atreyu-the curse

& id bring chapstick :D

I almost picked that one. I've been listening to it alot lately.

I picked it because it is an album that I can listen to for hours with out being bored with it. It was them or Lightning Bolt

Yeah....I change mineral in my first one.

I need some at the drive in. This station is non-operational...yes, i'll take the best of cd. bitches.

Meshuggah - Catch 33
Soilwork - A Predator's Portrait
Mitch Hedberg - Strategic Grill Locations

...and a magic carpet.

The Essential Michael Schenker Group
Argus - Wishbone Ash
The Best of Black Sabbath

And.......

A packet of durries.

Hank Williams III - Straight To Hell
Snapcase - Progression Through Unlearning
Ramones - Ramones

and an unlimited supply of Pabst Blue Ribbon
YUMMY!!!!

That made me roflol.

Please don't tell me you've heard The Chainheart Machine and think A Predator's Portrait's better...

Plastic surgery disasters - Dead kennedys
Dookie - Green day
empire strikes first - Bad religion

and obvioulsy the pope cos we could play loads of games with his robe such as 'find the robe' or the critically aclaimed 'robe on the loose'

Jeff Buckley - Grace
The most comprehensive Marvin ***e 'best of' available
The most comprehensive Bob Marley 'best of' available

And I'd bring Aishwarya Rai because somebody would surely come to rescue her and if they didn't there'd be plenty of fun things we could do together to pass the time:love:

1. Between The Buried And Me - Alaska (it was hard choosing between this and the s/t :( )
2. In Flames - The Jester Race
3. At The Gates - Slaughter Of The Soul


and as for the other thing, probably Scarlet Johansson :D

1. Circle Takes the Square- As the Roots Undo
2. Fall of Troy- Fall of Troy
3. Saetia- A Retrospective

Honorable mention would have to be Either/Or Elliott Smith.

1. Motley Crue greatest hits
2. The Ministry Of Sound Greatest hits (got like 80 songs on that, thatll do me)
3. Stevie Wonder's greatest hits!

And Stu. so he'd have to suffer it with me

Ok, I would bring amorica by the Black Crowes and tOOL's Aenima

Can my other thing be Layne Staley?

Oh, wait, 3 CDS-ok, the other would be Nothing's shocking by Jane's Addiction

If you like corpses sure.