Trollheart

Yeah, pretty much the point I was trying to make. You can't in fairness generalise an entire ERA, never mind a genre, without something to back it up. I also am not trying to fight with you, but your vague reasons given above would certainly not convince me of your argument. Personally, I HATE Elvis (with a passion!), Buddy Holly, Bill Hailey, and especially Roy bloody Orbison, but I would never denigrate their music and say it was all the same and boring. I just don't like the music they play, but recognise that others do, and that they are not completely representative of their era.
I would never make a comment like "all 50s music is terrible" because I have not the ground to stand on; I dont listen to that sort of music, so really I'm in no position to challenge or put it down. Neither are you.

That's the way I see it, anyway. It seems, forgive me, almost terminally close-minded of you to discount over twenty years of music without even knowing much about it, or trying to understand it. How can for instance, screamo be the same as progressive rock, or dubstep be related in any way to ambient? If you don't know what I'm talking about, you should realise that you're therefore not really in a position to judge. I would urge you to listen to some post-90s music, then make your decision. And I dont mean the charts. There are plenty of people here who can point you in any direction you wish to explore.

__________________
Trollheart: Signature-free since April 2018

Trollheart

Oh, one other thing, which has not been addressed but formed part of your aversion to music after the 90s: downloading music. Well, sure, lots of people prefer CDs or even LPs, but don't forget that downloading music is a great way to "try before you buy", to see if you like the music you're planning to buy before you do. In a battered economy like ours, I couldn't possibly afford to buy all the albums I THINK I might like. I used to do that when I was younger, and working, but circumstances have changed dramatically for me now, and downloading music is the best option for me. I have a huge vinyl collection, but my turntable got busted and I've never really bothered to replace it.

Sure, today's music is almost instant and always accessible via ipods, YouTube, itunes and so on, but that's how the world is today, and in fairness, some artistes have gained fame through those media in a way they could never have done had they just been trying to sell CDs. So music downloads, while a pain to a purist like yourself, certainly fulfil a need and perform a valuable service in our world today.

Anyway, I guess they're not going anywhere, so may as well get used to them!

__________________
Trollheart: Signature-free since April 2018

jmurray01

Well I just want to say before I contact a member of admin about deleting my account, no hard feelings, I didn't mean to offend anybody.

"Out", as the Americans say.

__________________

gunnels

You didn't offend anybody as far as I can tell.

__________________
Let's Play TF2 Sometime.|Unrepresentative Last.fm.|Puns, Pokemon, and Miscellany

Janszoon

I don't think you've offended anyone here. Just some harmless banter.

__________________
A Night in the Life of the Invisible Man

Time & Place

25 Albums You Should Hear Before the Moon Crashes into the Earth and We All Die

last.fm

Paedantic Basterd

The only thing this community asks its users for is an open mind.

Key

Aww man don't leave. It was just a heated discussion if anything. You should stick around, you'd be able to give some good insight on bands that I don't normally dive into.

Mojo

Exactly. This is a music forum. Not a metal forum, not a jazz forum, not a 60s forum but a music forum. Naturally it is going to attract a certain type of person - people who love music and love to absorb and explore all it has to offer. Close-minded views and generalisations regarding the very thing that everyone here should feel passionate about are likely to be met by some strong opinions.

The majority of people here can debate and share differing opinions. Personally theres only so much that I myself can handle when it comes to opinions on certain bands, certain albums, certain tracks etc because frankly if I have fully formed my own opinion of something then chances are I wont give a crap what anyone elses opinion is. It's not rudeness, I just have nothing to gain from using this forum for that kind of thing.

Generalisations and a closed mind are, however, different. For example someone can tell me that they don't like Black Sabbath and, although I may be tempted to question their sense of hearing and mental health, that's fine. Opinions differ and everyones got one. Tell me that all heavy metal is crap, or all the singing is the same, or every band make emotionless, thousand note a second, wank-a-thon albums designed to cover up a lack of real talent or song writing abilities and I won't question your opinion, I'll ignore or disregard it. I'll ignore or disregard it because if you can make such a ridiculous generalisation then it's blatantly obvious that it is uninformed and you simply know nothing of what you talk about.

Basically, if you stick to what it is you know about and keep an open mind about what it is you don't know about then everyone here will be cool. If you don't then you might mistake the response you get for offence when really you are just interacting with mostly open-minded people with a passion and strong opinions.

__________________

Last.FM | Echoes and Dust

Urban Hat€monger ?

That works both ways though.
The amount of 'your taste isn't good enough listen to this' heroes we have here annoys me just as much.
Nothing wrong with waiting for that person to ask rather than forcing it on them.

__________________

Paedantic Basterd

I've always perceived it as people being excited to share something they love, rather than shape someone else to their tastes, but perhaps I see it differently being someone who loves to take recommendations.