Atreyu's EP's and first album were all awesome. The Curse gets 2 out of 13, for BM and 5V. the drummer should only be allowed to sing for ALG.

anyways, i prefer them over Thrice, for the old stuff.

The Crimson was better than 5 Vicodin.

Thrice's old stuff is crazy good and Frost you sir are a party pooper.

this whole forume thing is cool and everything but if this (which band is better)is all you talk about in here you need to consider new topics....just a suggestion.

if i am a party pooper, than this is the sadest party ever.

bleh

thrice hands down!! their they can actually play their instruments. and the guy who screams for Atreyu can not scream live

Atreyu can play their instruments, dumbass.

ATREYU hands down!

neither of the bands can play their insturments. deal with it.

^ i respect that you have different opinions on music, but why do you have to go around and bash bands other people like? i dont sit and comment on the stuff you listen to.