the saddest "emo" song i have ever listened to is unfinished by mineral. i guess its the softer side of emo, or according to random sites, its part of the post-emo indie category. but there are too many categories anyway.

sorry if it isnt the hardcore emo you guys love

elliott smith - waltz 2 xo

^not emo

"ten bucks says you got aids" by Class Action

tears are in your eyes by yo la tengo i dont care if you folks think yo la is emo its just a sad song

the juliana theory.- you always say goodnight, goodnight
alesana.- early mourning

and I don't remember any other sad song,
also Konstantine by Something Corporate it's really depressive

Now THAT is sad, because not one of those songs(or bands) is emo.

Oh you lot can shut up, this whole thread is filled with songs that are just relatively sad and not emo.

Just because everyone residing in the emo forum about a year ago wallowed around in ignorance doesn't mean that you guys have to now crush their opinions with some newly acquired 411.

If they were interested enough, I'm sure they'd take the time to look up what emo really is in the educational thread, not state an opinion for it to get bashed.

RING RING!

mineral <3333333333333333333333333333333333333333


I'd say Overrated by Engine Down. I guess they could count as emo? I dunno.