Karice

I actually like Out Ta Get Me and Nighttrain from Guns N'Roses Appetite For Destruction than the hit song Paradise City. I thought Paradise City was the best Guns N'Roses song until I heard better songs from them. Paradise City is good but it's definitely not the best Guns N'Roses song.

I enjoy Perfect Crime from Use Your Illusion Part 1 more than the hit song November Rain. How Perfect Crime didn't become a huge hit is beyond me.

SGR

I'd take Coma or Estranged over November Rain

Queen Boo

Some artists make a habit of not releasing their best songs as singles.

Billy Joel has to be the grand champion of this.

__________________
https://www.twitch.tv/drrobuttnik

rubber soul

The Beatles didn't like to release singles off an album. They notably didn't release singles in England off With the Beatles, Beatles For Sale, Rubber Soul, Sgt Pepper, and the White Album (though the US would in their infinite wisdom). As far as Revolver goes, I prefer Here There and Everywhere and For No One over the Yellow Submarine/ Eleanor Rigby single (with all due respect to the latter)

__________________

SGR

I thought that was a typical British/English thing of the time, not a Beatles thing? e.g. The Stones packing in the singles (Ruby Tuesday/Lets Spend the Night Together) for the US release of 'Between the Buttons'

rubber soul

It's possible. I think it depended on the band and how much clout they had. And the Beatles, through George Martin, had a lot of clout with Parlophone, even after their debut album. I do think the Stones had some albums independent of singles as well but I'm more familiar with the Beatles history, obviously.

__________________

Queen Boo

You're right it was common practice in the British music industry not to include previously released singles on albums, the labels were afraid that if someone had already bought the single they may not want to pay for that song again even if it's on an album with a bunch of new songs. This is why Strawberry Fields and Penny Lane were left off Sgt. Pepper.

In Muricah however you're damn right we want the hit singles to be on the album, this is why most early Beatles and Stones albums were altered so much when they were first released in the US, this practice mostly died out by the end of the 60s with some exceptions here and there.

__________________
https://www.twitch.tv/drrobuttnik

rubber soul

Yeah, the American labels destroyed the intent of a lot of British albums in the sixties and it wasn't just the Beatles and Stones. They screwed up bands like the Kinks too. All in the name of making more money.

__________________

DriveYourCarDownToTheSea

How Do You Feel from Jefferson Airplane's Surrealistic Pillow album is IMO the best song on the album (which says a lot) but it wasn't remotely a hit.

Threads like this would be more like a category of, "Albums where the best song wasn't a hit."

__________________
Stop and find a pretty shell for her
Beach Boys vs Beatles comparisons begin here

Plankton

Reminds me of a Sirius channel I listen to:

__________________
See location...