Love or Hate?

Trollheart · 12-06-2016, 06:03 AM

Special note: I have now decided not to listen to any member albums in this thread. I will instead reopen The Showroom, where such reviews can be undertaken in the more in-depth, appreciative way they need to and should be.

Anyone who has a personal album here as their choice please supply me with a new rec, and your own album will then be dealt with in The Showroom. Anyone else who wishes their album(s) reviewed there please post there and I will deal with them.

Thanks.

Trollheart · 12-07-2016, 12:28 PM

OK, bitches! Time to get back to it!

Title: How To Measure a Planet?
Artiste: The Gathering
Genre: Progressive Rock
Familiarity: Zero
Recommended by: The Batlord

Expectations: I don't know. Sometimes Batty gives me albums he knows I'll hate, just so he can enjoy my reactions, but this time I think he might have actually recommended one he thinks I have a decent chance of liking. We'll see. Note: does anyone know why this happened? In the middle of listening to this on Spotify it stops, because my connection dropped. Once I reset the router and got back online, it now refuses to allow me to even access the album, telling me it's not available to me, and I should upgrade! I'm already on Premium! I rebooted Spotify twice, still no luck. Had to go YouTubing in the end. Bastards. What the hell am I paying them for??

1. Frail (You might as well be me): Good start, very laidback, gentle, kind of ethereal. Nice.
2. Great ocean road: A little more powerful but still a great track and certainly pulling me deeper into this album.
3. Rescue me: Yeah, this just gets better. Nothing bad to say about it so far. Kind of reminds me of a heavier Mostly Autumn to some degree, edges of metal peeping in on this track with some harder guitar and snarly keyboard.
4. My electricity: I used not to know what trip-hop was; now I do, and I can hear it in this track, a slower, casual sort of melody, very appealing.
5. Liberty bell: Kinds of almost Indian or something here; wouldn't be surprised to hear a sitar, though I don't think there is one. Very psych though. Got really nice and rocky in the latter parts. Cool.
6. Red is a slow colour: This is also heavy, but slower. Quite dramatic too in its way. Is there an orchestra involved? It would appear not, but at times it sounds like there could be. This is ****ing brilliant! First blue. Probably won't be the last.
7. The big sleep: Very much the trip-hop in evidence here
8. Marooned:This is really nice too. Great vocal here. Sounds like a harp. Is it? Violin or cello definitely though. Quite hypnotic.
9. Travel: This has all been quite laidback so far, and I've enjoyed every minute. Great stuff.
10. South American ghostride: Really atmospheric. Enjoyed that a whole lot.
11. Illuminating: Reminds me of School of Seven Bells a little, and that's no bad thing.
12. Locked away: This has a nice kind of ominous or dramatic aura. Almost puts me in mind of Sabbath at times. That's right: I said Sabbath. As in Black.
13. Probably built in the fifties: I've noticed this album get progressively (hah!) more powerful and intense as it approaches the last few tracks. Interesting. This is one of the heaviest – comparatively – that I've heard on it yet.
14. How to measure a planet?: Ok, this is the monster, just short of half an hour, and also the title track. Let's see if it can maintain my interest for that length of time, or most of it, although given what I've heard so far I don't see that being a problem. Five minutes in and no vocals so far, other than a sort of wailing chant. Guitar here is very U2, and I mean very. Eight minutes in now and, barring taped audio, something like radio chatter, no vocals. Could this be a 36-minute instrumental? Well, no, cos it's 28 minutes, but still, more than halfway through and no sign of anyone singing. Loving it though, long may it continue. Okay, it was all instrumental, other than the bits mentioned. Almost a perfect demonstration of abstract musical expressionism, and I didn't get bored once.

End result: You called it Batty, right on the money. This is an amazing album and there was nothing about it I did not love. Worth checking out their other stuff? (Yeah, like I'm going to get a chance to do that! But you never know...)

So, Love or Hate? What do you think? Gonna have to Blue this mother! A good start to kick back off with a True Love, and it deserves it. One of the best I've heard in a long time.

The Batlord · 12-07-2016, 04:38 PM

If you heard some Sabbathy vibes it's cause The Gathering started life as a gothic doom band a la Paradise Lost. I believe they may even have been the band to popularize female vocals in the genre.

Lucem Ferre · 12-07-2016, 04:53 PM

I can take criticism. Obviously.

But my signature is from a guy named LuckyNumber13 and I can't remember what I did to piss him off that day. But he was really really upset. I thought it was funny and had this sig as the official description of my music for a while.

Ilistentoeverything · 12-08-2016, 10:20 PM

Album name: The Stage
Band: Avenged Sevenfold

The album is on youtube, but it's in a playlist. Just search the name and you should find it. Here's the first song of the album, though.

Trollheart · 12-09-2016, 08:43 PM

Important announcement!

I have now begun a special Metal version of "Love or Hate?" in http://www.musicbanter.com/members-j...l-journal.html, so if you have Metal recs please post them there. Any that have already been accepted can be left here if you wish, or may be moved to the new thread in my journal. However from today I will not be accepting any new recs for Metal albums here. Please post any such in my journal.

Thanks.

The Batlord · 12-09-2016, 09:01 PM

You can move my Demolition Hammer rec to your metal journal. Surprisingly it's the only metal rec I currently have.

Ol’ Qwerty Bastard · 12-09-2016, 09:03 PM

batlord, quick! this our chance to recommend him Ion Dissonance.

Mondo Bungle · 12-09-2016, 09:04 PM

Both mine are metal

The Batlord · 12-09-2016, 09:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Qwertyy

batlord, quick! this our chance to recommend him Ion Dissonance.

I thought about it, but did Deadguy instead. Do it for me. I'd change mine but I really am curious if he can connect with Deadguy. Probably not, but you gotta take the chance.

12-06-2016, 06:03 AM	#3021 (permalink)
Trollheart Born to be mild Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: 404 Not Found Posts: 26,994	Special note: I have now decided not to listen to any member albums in this thread. I will instead reopen The Showroom, where such reviews can be undertaken in the more in-depth, appreciative way they need to and should be. Anyone who has a personal album here as their choice please supply me with a new rec, and your own album will then be dealt with in The Showroom. Anyone else who wishes their album(s) reviewed there please post there and I will deal with them. Thanks. __________________ Trollheart: Signature-free since April 2018

12-07-2016, 12:28 PM	#3022 (permalink)
Trollheart Born to be mild Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: 404 Not Found Posts: 26,994	OK, bitches! Time to get back to it! Title: How To Measure a Planet? Artiste: The Gathering Genre: Progressive Rock Familiarity: Zero Recommended by: The Batlord Expectations: I don't know. Sometimes Batty gives me albums he knows I'll hate, just so he can enjoy my reactions, but this time I think he might have actually recommended one he thinks I have a decent chance of liking. We'll see. Note: does anyone know why this happened? In the middle of listening to this on Spotify it stops, because my connection dropped. Once I reset the router and got back online, it now refuses to allow me to even access the album, telling me it's not available to me, and I should upgrade! I'm already on Premium! I rebooted Spotify twice, still no luck. Had to go YouTubing in the end. Bastards. What the hell am I paying them for?? 1. Frail (You might as well be me): Good start, very laidback, gentle, kind of ethereal. Nice. 2. Great ocean road: A little more powerful but still a great track and certainly pulling me deeper into this album. 3. Rescue me: Yeah, this just gets better. Nothing bad to say about it so far. Kind of reminds me of a heavier Mostly Autumn to some degree, edges of metal peeping in on this track with some harder guitar and snarly keyboard. 4. My electricity: I used not to know what trip-hop was; now I do, and I can hear it in this track, a slower, casual sort of melody, very appealing. 5. Liberty bell: Kinds of almost Indian or something here; wouldn't be surprised to hear a sitar, though I don't think there is one. Very psych though. Got really nice and rocky in the latter parts. Cool. 6. Red is a slow colour: This is also heavy, but slower. Quite dramatic too in its way. Is there an orchestra involved? It would appear not, but at times it sounds like there could be. This is **ing brilliant! First blue. Probably won't be the last. 7. The big sleep: Very much the trip-hop in evidence here 8. Marooned:This is really nice too. Great vocal here. Sounds like a harp. Is it? Violin or cello definitely though. Quite hypnotic. 9. Travel: This has all been quite laidback so far, and I've enjoyed every minute. Great stuff. 10. South American ghostride: Really atmospheric. Enjoyed that a whole lot. 11. Illuminating: Reminds me of School of Seven Bells a little, and that's no bad thing. 12. Locked away: This has a nice kind of ominous or dramatic aura. Almost puts me in mind of Sabbath at times. That's right: I said Sabbath. As in Black. 13. Probably built in the fifties: I've noticed this album get progressively (hah!) more powerful and intense as it approaches the last few tracks. Interesting. This is one of the heaviest – comparatively – that I've heard on it yet. 14. How to measure a planet?:** Ok, this is the monster, just short of half an hour, and also the title track. Let's see if it can maintain my interest for that length of time, or most of it, although given what I've heard so far I don't see that being a problem. Five minutes in and no vocals so far, other than a sort of wailing chant. Guitar here is very U2, and I mean very. Eight minutes in now and, barring taped audio, something like radio chatter, no vocals. Could this be a 36-minute instrumental? Well, no, cos it's 28 minutes, but still, more than halfway through and no sign of anyone singing. Loving it though, long may it continue. Okay, it was all instrumental, other than the bits mentioned. Almost a perfect demonstration of abstract musical expressionism, and I didn't get bored once. End result: You called it Batty, right on the money. This is an amazing album and there was nothing about it I did not love. Worth checking out their other stuff? (Yeah, like I'm going to get a chance to do that! But you never know...) So, Love or Hate? What do you think? Gonna have to Blue this mother! A good start to kick back off with a True Love, and it deserves it. One of the best I've heard in a long time. __________________ Trollheart: Signature-free since April 2018

12-08-2016, 10:20 PM	#3025 (permalink)
Ilistentoeverything Bread scientist Join Date: Nov 2015 Location: Everywhere Posts: 166	Album name: The Stage Band: Avenged Sevenfold The album is on youtube, but it's in a playlist. Just search the name and you should find it. Here's the first song of the album, though. __________________ In war, not everyone is a soldier.

12-09-2016, 08:43 PM	#3026 (permalink)
Trollheart Born to be mild Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: 404 Not Found Posts: 26,994	Important announcement! I have now begun a special Metal version of "Love or Hate?" in http://www.musicbanter.com/members-j...l-journal.html, so if you have Metal recs please post them there. Any that have already been accepted can be left here if you wish, or may be moved to the new thread in my journal. However from today I will not be accepting any new recs for Metal albums here. Please post any such in my journal. Thanks. __________________ Trollheart: Signature-free since April 2018