5 Favorite songs from a favorite band
 

Replacements:

Answering Machine
Can't hardly wait
Left of the dial
Alex Chilton
I'll be you

Kind of a strange list imo besides Alex Chilton. Mine for The Replacements would be:

I Will Dare
Unsatisfied
Alex Chilton
Androgynous
Here Comes a Regular

Anyway now I'll give a shot at my 5 favorite Elliott Smith tracks

Waltz #2
Angeles
A Fond Farewell
Alameda
Tomorrow Tomorrow

Zeppelin

Achilles Last Stand
Ten Years Gone
In the Light
The Song Remains the Same
Since I've Been Loving You

(ask me again tomorrow and the list will change)

Captain Beefheart
Bill's Corpse
Cardboard Cutout Sundown
Making Love to a Vampire With a Monkey on my Knee
Orange Claw Hammer
My Human Gets Me Blues

Not sure why my list is strange although if I made it again it would probably be different. I will Dare should have been on my list! But Answering machine should have been on yours...

As far as Zeppelin:

The Rain Song
Going To California
No Quarter
Achilles Last Stand
Ten Years Gone

Zeppelin

Today it's:

Black Dog
The Rain Song (live - Song Remains The Same)
Since I’ve Been Loving You (live - Song Remains The Same)
Dancing Days
Ten Years Gone
Misty Mountain Hop

Radiohead:
Pyramid Song
Reckoner
Life in a Glass House
Weird Fishes
Idioteque

The Beatles:
A Day in the Life
Strawberry Fields Forever
Tomorrow Never Knows
Helter Skelter
Ticket to Ride

Both of these change constantly.

The Beatles

Strawberry Fields Forever
A Day In The Life
Tomorrow Never Knows
I'll Be Back
Don't Let Me Down

...but they're ever changing.

Well there are very few bad songs in their whole discography so I guess just about any combination is fine, I've just never considered some of those among their most memorable tracks is all!

Not doing Beatles, because that would give away the results of my countdown.

Simon and Garfunkel

• America
• My Little Town
• The Only Living Boy in New York
• Mrs. Robinson
• Kathy's Song

Billy Joel

• Vienna
• Say Goodbye to Hollywood
• Scenes From an Italian Restaurant
• You May Be Right
• Only the Good Die Young

And I'll throw in a band I don't really like, the Stones.

• She's a Rainbow
• (I Can't Get No) Satisfaction
• As Tears Go By
• Jumpin' Jack Flash
• Let's Spend the Night Together