Music Mastermind!

Trollheart · 05-24-2012, 05:06 AM

Yeah, I know it'll probably be moved to the games section, but I want to see how much interest is gained here, through the general section. Hopefully it will be popular, and if that happens I would ask that it be left here, like Album Wars and such, so it doesn't get subsumed among other threads or lost in a backwater sub-forum. If possible.

So...

From the people who brought you "Room 101"...

You all probably know the classic quiz show, if not then let me quickly explain. Contestants face off against each other each week in two rounds, the first being based on a subject they have chosen themselves (and presumably have extensive knowledge of or experience in), their "chosen subject", and the second being general knowledge. At the end, whoever scores highest wins and goes on to the quarter finals and so on.

For the music version, you'll need to a) have a really good knowledge of most branches and genres of music and b) have at least one specialised subject you know inside out. You'll be tested with four minutes of questions on each. Normally it's limited to a two-minute round but as that's oral and this is going to be typed that wouldn't be fair, if for instance one question was very long and took some time to type out: seconds could count. Not to mention typos, computer locks, crashes and so on.

So here are the rules:

1. All rounds, right up to the Grand Final, will be conducted via IM (that can be Yahoo, MSN, SKYPE or whatever. If you qualify you let me know and I'll download the appropriate app if I don't have it, though I use SKYPE myself, and would prefer to use that). Times can be arranged to suit your local timezone, but they must be live, to avoid any possibility of cheating.

2. Each round will last four minutes, first on your chosen subject, then on general music knowledge. This timing will be TO THE SECOND.

3. There will be a ten-second time limit on each question, to avoid cheating by Googling or wiki. If you do not answer the question within that timeframe it will be marked as incorrect. Of course, if you answer quickly you will get a chance to have more questions.

4. If you don't know the answer, you can say PASS and you will be advised at the end of the round what the answer is. A PASS generally counts as a wrong answer, but it can save you time by not dwelling on the answer and quickly moving on.

5. If, at the end of a round, I am in the middle of a question I will finish it (the famous "I've started so I'll finish"), but if you have answered a question in the last second of the round I will not begin another.

6. If there is a tie at the end between players the number of passes will be taken into consideration. If that doesn't break the deadlock then there will be a tie-break.

7. The winner of each round, and the highest runner-up, have the chance to go forward to the next level, until finally we're left with two players who will battle it out for the title of Music Mastermind of 2012.

8. The final decision on any question is mine, and no appeals will be considered. There will be no trick or ambiguous questions.

9. If you wish, and are sure enough to do so, you may interrupt me in the middle of a question, however if you do and are wrong, the score will be SUBTRACTED from your total (don't like smartasses!)

10. There is no actual prize, other than being able to lord your superior musical knowledge over your mates, however with the permission of the mods I will create a special Mastermind avatar which you can use when you win, showing everyone how brainy you are.

11. All contestants must be able to speak, and write, in English. Sorry if this is seen as discrimination, but I only speak English myself.

12. If you progress to the next round, you must choose a new "specialised subject"; the same one cannot be reused. Nor can anyone else choose one that has already been accepted and used.

13. Specialised subjects can be anything, as long as they're music related. An album, a band, a discography, gigs, musical equipment, production, movies, books, genres, eras, hits, flops, deaths... anything that's music related. But they MUST be specialised, so for instance "Heavy metal music" would not be accepted as a specialised subject, though "Nu-metal" would, as would "Heavy metal music of the 80s" or "Motorhead".

I think that's it. Potential entrants should ensure they can make themselves available for all rounds, and the results will be posted here as the quiz progresses.

So, do YOU have what it takes to sit in the Big Chair? Post here if you're interested but do NOT post your intended chosen subject: PM that to me. Note I will more than likely need some time to research subjects I am not familiar with, so as to have the appropriate questions for you.

Trollheart · 05-24-2012, 06:52 PM

Come on, don't be shy! You all know you think you have huge, pulsating ... er, brains ... so prove it. Come an' 'ave a go, if ye're hard enough.

It's the ultimate pi$$ing contest... what music fan could resist?

Don't make me upload a chicken sound...

**Goofle** · 05-24-2012, 06:58 PM

I was supposed to respond earlier but forgot. I love the idea, but I can't see it working on a grand scale. It's just the kind of thing that maybe three of us would commit to at any one point.

I am up for it though.

Paedantic Basterd · 05-24-2012, 11:47 PM

I'd do appallingly bad in "general knowledge". I think most of us would, actually. We're stronger as a whole than divided when it comes to that sort of thing, I think.

Trollheart · 05-25-2012, 03:07 AM

Well, the general knowledge questions would be pretty easy for the most part, stuff everyone should know. With of course the odd harder one thrown in.

Example:

On what Iron Maiden album did Bruce Dickinson make his return?

What was Kylie Minogue's first hit?

What sort of music is traditionally played at Ronnie Scott's?

Who is Declan McManus better known as?

Who had a big hit with "Here I go again"?

What card did Motorhead play on their hit single?

What road was Robbie Williams on, on his album "Sing when you're winning"?

What album cover features a baby swimming?

and so on. Not too hard, eh?

Paedantic Basterd · 05-25-2012, 09:30 AM

See, I can answer exactly one of those confidently. I think there may be flaws in a game where one person decides "general knowledge" based on their historical listening bias. Our tastes are specialized in very different areas of the same spectrum.

**Janszoon** · 05-25-2012, 09:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bam You Have AIDS

See, I can answer exactly one of those confidently. I think there may be flaws in a game where one person decides "general knowledge" based on their historical listening bias. Our tastes are specialized in very different areas of the same spectrum.

I can answer four confidently and one semi-confidently, and they are definitely biased toward my age group or slightly older. So, yeah, I'm not sure I'd describe them as easy, especially not for people significantly younger than me. I like the idea though, Trollheart. I think the questions just need to cover a bigger window of time—both newer and older.

Paedantic Basterd · 05-25-2012, 10:01 AM

Or, perhaps people would excel when playing in teams.

**Goofle** · 05-25-2012, 10:13 AM

Teams would work.

Only 100% got "Ace of Spades" and "Nirvana"to be honest.

**Janszoon** · 05-25-2012, 10:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Goofle11

Teams would work.

Only 100% got "Ace of Spades" and "Nirvana"to be honest.

No Elvis Costello?

05-24-2012, 05:06 AM	#1 (permalink)
Trollheart Born to be mild Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: 404 Not Found Posts: 26,994	Music Mastermind! Yeah, I know it'll probably be moved to the games section, but I want to see how much interest is gained here, through the general section. Hopefully it will be popular, and if that happens I would ask that it be left here, like Album Wars and such, so it doesn't get subsumed among other threads or lost in a backwater sub-forum. If possible. So... From the people who brought you "Room 101"... You all probably know the classic quiz show, if not then let me quickly explain. Contestants face off against each other each week in two rounds, the first being based on a subject they have chosen themselves (and presumably have extensive knowledge of or experience in), their "chosen subject", and the second being general knowledge. At the end, whoever scores highest wins and goes on to the quarter finals and so on. For the music version, you'll need to a) have a really good knowledge of most branches and genres of music and b) have at least one specialised subject you know inside out. You'll be tested with four minutes of questions on each. Normally it's limited to a two-minute round but as that's oral and this is going to be typed that wouldn't be fair, if for instance one question was very long and took some time to type out: seconds could count. Not to mention typos, computer locks, crashes and so on. So here are the rules: 1. All rounds, right up to the Grand Final, will be conducted via IM (that can be Yahoo, MSN, SKYPE or whatever. If you qualify you let me know and I'll download the appropriate app if I don't have it, though I use SKYPE myself, and would prefer to use that). Times can be arranged to suit your local timezone, but they must be live, to avoid any possibility of cheating. 2. Each round will last four minutes, first on your chosen subject, then on general music knowledge. This timing will be TO THE SECOND. 3. There will be a ten-second time limit on each question, to avoid cheating by Googling or wiki. If you do not answer the question within that timeframe it will be marked as incorrect. Of course, if you answer quickly you will get a chance to have more questions. 4. If you don't know the answer, you can say PASS and you will be advised at the end of the round what the answer is. A PASS generally counts as a wrong answer, but it can save you time by not dwelling on the answer and quickly moving on. 5. If, at the end of a round, I am in the middle of a question I will finish it (the famous "I've started so I'll finish"), but if you have answered a question in the last second of the round I will not begin another. 6. If there is a tie at the end between players the number of passes will be taken into consideration. If that doesn't break the deadlock then there will be a tie-break. 7. The winner of each round, and the highest runner-up, have the chance to go forward to the next level, until finally we're left with two players who will battle it out for the title of Music Mastermind of 2012. 8. The final decision on any question is mine, and no appeals will be considered. There will be no trick or ambiguous questions. 9. If you wish, and are sure enough to do so, you may interrupt me in the middle of a question, however if you do and are wrong, the score will be SUBTRACTED from your total (don't like smartasses!) 10. There is no actual prize, other than being able to lord your superior musical knowledge over your mates, however with the permission of the mods I will create a special Mastermind avatar which you can use when you win, showing everyone how brainy you are. 11. All contestants must be able to speak, and write, in English. Sorry if this is seen as discrimination, but I only speak English myself. 12. If you progress to the next round, you must choose a new "specialised subject"; the same one cannot be reused. Nor can anyone else choose one that has already been accepted and used. 13. Specialised subjects can be anything, as long as they're music related. An album, a band, a discography, gigs, musical equipment, production, movies, books, genres, eras, hits, flops, deaths... anything that's music related. But they MUST be specialised, so for instance "Heavy metal music" would not be accepted as a specialised subject, though "Nu-metal" would, as would "Heavy metal music of the 80s" or "Motorhead". I think that's it. Potential entrants should ensure they can make themselves available for all rounds, and the results will be posted here as the quiz progresses. So, do YOU have what it takes to sit in the Big Chair? Post here if you're interested but do NOT post your intended chosen subject: PM that to me. Note I will more than likely need some time to research subjects I am not familiar with, so as to have the appropriate questions for you. __________________ Trollheart: Signature-free since April 2018

05-24-2012, 06:52 PM	#2 (permalink)
Trollheart Born to be mild Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: 404 Not Found Posts: 26,994	Come on, don't be shy! You all know you think you have huge, pulsating ... er, brains ... so prove it. Come an' 'ave a go, if ye're hard enough. It's the ultimate pi$$ing contest... what music fan could resist? Don't make me upload a chicken sound... __________________ Trollheart: Signature-free since April 2018

05-25-2012, 03:07 AM	#5 (permalink)
Trollheart Born to be mild Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: 404 Not Found Posts: 26,994	Well, the general knowledge questions would be pretty easy for the most part, stuff everyone should know. With of course the odd harder one thrown in. Example: On what Iron Maiden album did Bruce Dickinson make his return? What was Kylie Minogue's first hit? What sort of music is traditionally played at Ronnie Scott's? Who is Declan McManus better known as? Who had a big hit with "Here I go again"? What card did Motorhead play on their hit single? What road was Robbie Williams on, on his album "Sing when you're winning"? What album cover features a baby swimming? and so on. Not too hard, eh? __________________ Trollheart: Signature-free since April 2018

05-24-2012, 11:47 PM	#4 (permalink)
Paedantic Basterd Music Addict Join Date: Sep 2010 Posts: 5,184	I'd do appallingly bad in "general knowledge". I think most of us would, actually. We're stronger as a whole than divided when it comes to that sort of thing, I think.

05-25-2012, 09:30 AM	#6 (permalink)
Paedantic Basterd Music Addict Join Date: Sep 2010 Posts: 5,184	See, I can answer exactly one of those confidently. I think there may be flaws in a game where one person decides "general knowledge" based on their historical listening bias. Our tastes are specialized in very different areas of the same spectrum.

05-25-2012, 10:01 AM	#8 (permalink)
Paedantic Basterd Music Addict Join Date: Sep 2010 Posts: 5,184	Or, perhaps people would excel when playing in teams.