Vise versa for me. I happened to see the post within a couple minutes of it being posted, and started the Butthole Surfers song right away. Then I posted, and edited my post several times as I was re-listening to the Bungle song.

One of the weaker songs from LOT and a stronger one from Mr. Bungle. Both the studio and live version of My Ass is On Fire is really awesome. Since I love both bands I thought it was going to be a tough choice but I'll easily go with Mr. Bungle here.

Butthole Surfers - 2
Mr. Bungle - 6

live version?!?!? what live version?!?!?! holy shit mr bungle has a live album??

Umm no, but they were known to perform live, like most bands. ;)

butthole surfers!

Butthole Surfers 3
Mr Bungle 6

Really? "My Ass Is On Fire" is okay but I've always considered it one of the weaker songs on that album.

Battle British Post-Punk:

I just have awful taste in Butthole [edit: this reads poorly without "Surfers"] and Bungle songs, apparently...

I fucking hate this new battle.

Joy Division 0

The Smiths 1

Joy Division: 0

The Smiths: 2

Gotta go with The Smiths here, not that Joy Division isn't great but I just like them a little better...