Music Format Thread

[[MERIT]]

Originally Posted by innerspaceboy

Lossless is lossless. Sound quality is the same as the original source for all lossless compression formats. The only other factors to consider are compression rates which are of lesser and lesser consequence as storage costs plummet, and compatibility. APE is technically the best for compression, but unless you're seriously strapped for space the difference is inconsequential.

Compatability is similarly a non-issue as none of the formats you mentioned utilize DRM, and tools are available to freely convert from one format to the next. However, if given the option between a closed format like ALAC and an open format like FLAC, choose FLAC every time. The only reason to use ALAC is if you're forced to by using a closed application like iTunes, and if you're actually using iTunes I would strongly encourage you to consider exploring better options. There is no reason on this Earth to use iTunes in 2018.

I don't use iTunes anymore, but I used to. I really liked it! I understand not wanting to to update every other day though LOL. There is Foobar, MusicBee, MediaMonkey. Any recommendations?

You seem really knowledgeable. I appreciate your time.

[innerspaceboy]

Originally Posted by [MERIT]

I don't use iTunes anymore, but I used to. I really liked it! I understand not wanting to to update every other day though LOL. There is Foobar, MusicBee, MediaMonkey. Any recommendations?

You seem really knowledgeable. I appreciate your time.

I'm just happy that my experience can be put to some use.

What operating system are you using? If you're in Windows, I've tried all the major applications and some of the minors as well. For large library management, I cannot praise MediaMonkey Gold enough. It is robust, brimming with advanced features, and has a manageable learning curve.

Foobar is a popular choice among audiophiles and is certainly the best open freeware media tool. And the interface is customizable to suit your specific needs. I'd suggest installing each and trying them out for a bit. If you favor MM you can always upgrade to Gold down the line.