This Song Vs That Song Part Eleventy Ten
 

I can't remember what part we are on but the usual drill. Same song title, different songs. Who do you prefer and FFS say why so I have something to read.

Come Together is one of the more overrated Beatles songs, and I've loved Screamadelica since I first heard it, with Come Together being one of the obvious standout tracks along with Shine Like Stars, Higher than the Sun and hell, even I'm Comin' Down.

Oh wow...that Primal Scream song was incredible. I love it. I'm not a huge fan of the Beatles, but of course I've heard that song by them a zillion times. They lose points though cause they stole it from Aerosmith, who does it way better. I voted for Primal Scream. :)

The Beatles version IS the original version lol and not Aerosmith!

:laughing:

Make it a three way! Not the album version but still as spectacular as the aforementioned two.

I was thinking about that track too but knew it would probably lose :(

I knew this. Was just being dumb. Maybe trying to be funny. Probably just dumb though. ><

Either way the Primal Scream song is way cooler.

edit: I like the one lucifer_sam linked too. That might have gotten my vote had it been in the OP...woulda been close.

The Primal Scream song(being the first time i'm hearing it) is quite the adventure, i'm really feeling a sort of epic flight around the globe, taking in just how massive and widespread everything is.

The Beatles song, while itself very good, doesn't quite live up to that level.


point goes to Primal Scream

I'm trying to imagine what Aerosmith would have sounded like if they were around before The Beatles. :D

This is going surprise people here who know my tastes but I'm going have to go with the Beatles on this one. It's one of the better Beatles songs IMO and I couldn't even make it all the way through the Primal Scream track.

I voted for Primal Scream. I love the Beatles, but I don't actually like Come Together all that much and Primal Scream's Come Together is pretty epic.

I love when it come into the chorus of The Beatles' Come Together, the verse and the chorus together kind of bothers me though. It just seems a little disjointed and fused together.

I listened to the Primal Scream track and I'm going to go with The Beatles. Not a bad song just kind of a jam that I didn't find especially moving.

Definitely The Beatles' Come Together. It is one of my favourite Beatles tracks, and I don't think it's overrated. I just really love it and can never help but tap my feet or bounce along when I hear it played. Great song.

Even as a massive Beatles fan words cannot describe how much I hate come together. Its is just extremely annoying and I disllike everything about it.

Primal Scream come together is excellent so that naturally wins.

Primal Scream take it for me. I like the Beatles track, but it's far from a favourite of mine. Along with Maxwell's Silver Hammer it's probably my least-played track on Abbey Road. Paul Weller covered it and improved on it too.

While The Beatles song isn't one of my favorites, it's still good. This was my first time to hear the Primal Scream song, and it doesn't do much for me. Too long, too repetitive, and I find the repeated female vocal a bit cheesy, making the whole song a bit cheesy like We Are the World. Wouldn't care to hear it again, so I'll go with The Beatles.

On another note, I haven't listened to any Primal Scream albums but have probably heard a few of their songs...and expected this to be more rock-based.

As much as a Primal Scream fanboy I am I would have gone for the Spiritualized track had it been included.

Especially the single version where they recorded it with a full orchestra, that version was fucking immense.

Screamadelica is a great album and I love every song on it and the Beatles Come Together is one of my least fav beatle songs. So its Primal Scream for me.

Lol sure you were

0_0

I voted Beatles not because I don't like the Primal Scream song but because the Beatles track is one of my favorite songs ever.