Your opinion of the best singer of all time

Rickenbacker · 10-18-2009, 09:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NumberNineDream

Example: Lennon can't be better than Bob Dylan, Roy Orbison, Little Richard or Chuck Berry ... Cause he learned everything from these guys. They were the inspirers, they should take the credit.

You can't honestly be playing this card, or we would effectively have to credit the first person who ever sang as being the best singer ever, and incidentally better than anyone else who ever sang after him. Nobody is totally original with anything they do, so it's not fair to say that Bob Dylan and Roy Orbison are better than John Lennon simply because he "learned everything from [those] guys." Obviously they weren't totally original either.

A great artist takes influence but also contributes something, and the same principle applies to singing. Personally, I don't think Bob Dylan or John Lennon are great singers in the conventional sense; it was how they utilized their respective voices that mattered. Nevertheless, your point is still flawed.

NumberNineDream · 10-18-2009, 09:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rickenbacker

You can't honestly be playing this card, or we would effectively have to credit the first person who ever sang as being the best singer ever, and incidentally better than anyone else who ever sang after him. Nobody is totally original with anything they do, so it's not fair to say that Bob Dylan and Roy Orbison are better than John Lennon simply because he "learned everything from [those] guys." Obviously they weren't totally original either.

It's in Art ... in general ...
It's the same reason why I don't like many bands. Their songs may be great aesthetically, but that's not what matters. It is the originality of the song, or the band, or here the performance.
That's why I hate Michael Bublé, I don't care that his voice is so charming or whatever. He just sings like Sinatra and we already have a Sinatra.
When someone isn't offering anything original, why go to him, just go to the source.

Rickenbacker · 10-18-2009, 09:13 PM

My point was that, despite my personal beliefs, Lennon can be better than Dylan, Orbison, and those other guys, because he did bring something new to the game. Beyond that it's just preference.

And Buble doesn't sing like Sinatra. He sings like Sinatra-Lite. What a talentless hack he is.

NumberNineDream · 10-18-2009, 09:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rickenbacker

My point was that, despite my personal beliefs, Lennon can be better than Dylan, Orbison, and those other guys, because he did bring something new to the game. Beyond that it's just preference.

And Buble doesn't sing like Sinatra. He sings like Sinatra-Lite. What a talentless hack he is.

The New thing is all that matters.

**And comparing Bulbé to Sinatra sounds so blasphemous. Talentless hack indeed.

Brad Stengel · 10-18-2009, 09:23 PM

Either Lou Reed or Johnny Rotten. Maybe that guy from King Missile.

Brad Stengel · 10-18-2009, 09:24 PM

Nevermind, Mark E. Smith.

Gone Sugaring · 10-18-2009, 09:57 PM

It's between these two;

Sam Cooke

and

Tom Waits.

Macneil1 · 10-19-2009, 11:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NumberNineDream

Another thing I wanted to add.
I love Lennon and I may be his biggest fan, but how can he better than Bob Dylan, if without Dylan there won't be any Lennon.

I disagree with that completely. Lennon started his first band in '57 and I've no doubts he was singing before he'd even heard of Bob Dylan. I doubt Lennon's voice was directly inspired by Dylans.

Brad Nowell is probably my favourite singer. His voice is superb and fit any time of music he and Sublime played. Maynard James Keenan, Otis Redding and John Lee Hooker are other favourites of mine.

loveissucide · 10-19-2009, 12:10 PM

Never realised how cool Elvis Costello's vocals where till 10 minutes ago when I had Angels Wanna Wear My Red Shoes going round my head.

NumberNineDream · 10-19-2009, 03:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Macneil1

I disagree with that completely. Lennon started his first band in '57 and I've no doubts he was singing before he'd even heard of Bob Dylan. I doubt Lennon's voice was directly inspired by Dylans.

Brad Nowell is probably my favourite singer. His voice is superb and fit any time of music he and Sublime played. Maynard James Keenan, Otis Redding and John Lee Hooker are other favourites of mine.

He said so himself. He might be feeling modest the day he said it, but that doesn't sound like him.

10-18-2009, 09:13 PM	#53 (permalink)
Rickenbacker / Join Date: May 2009 Location: The Conn Posts: 1,338	My point was that, despite my personal beliefs, Lennon can be better than Dylan, Orbison, and those other guys, because he did bring something new to the game. Beyond that it's just preference. And Buble doesn't sing like Sinatra. He sings like Sinatra-Lite. What a talentless hack he is. __________________ last.fm rym Talk About the Passion - R.E.M.'s Discography Reviewed

10-18-2009, 09:23 PM	#55 (permalink)
Brad Stengel This Space for Rent Join Date: Aug 2008 Location: Boston, MA Posts: 815	Either Lou Reed or Johnny Rotten. Maybe that guy from King Missile. __________________ These is the musics I own: http://rateyourmusic.com/collection/BradStengel/oo

10-18-2009, 09:24 PM	#56 (permalink)
Brad Stengel This Space for Rent Join Date: Aug 2008 Location: Boston, MA Posts: 815	Nevermind, Mark E. Smith. __________________ These is the musics I own: http://rateyourmusic.com/collection/BradStengel/oo

10-18-2009, 09:57 PM	#57 (permalink)
Gone Sugaring Foam-injected Axl Rose Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: California Posts: 245	It's between these two; Sam Cooke and Tom Waits. __________________ "If I was to vote, I'd say Erik B. For President!"

10-19-2009, 12:10 PM	#59 (permalink)
loveissucide Himself Join Date: Oct 2009 Location: Leuven ,Belgium, via Ireland Posts: 1,325	Never realised how cool Elvis Costello's vocals where till 10 minutes ago when I had Angels Wanna Wear My Red Shoes going round my head. __________________ www.last.fm/user/p-mccusker http://www.mixcloud.com/pmccusker www.valjester.wordpress.com