It would need more interest though as the more people involved in voting and commenting makes it more balanced.

they'll just end up being all the generic "indie" "rock" bands anyway, ZOMG WUTZ TEH BETZTZ RADIOHEADZ ALBUM

When is that going to be done? It seems forgotten about.

Then do something about that.

we could all agree that they're all equally shitty.

How it would work initially is that the 'obvious' artists would be done first.

Say, for example, David Bowie is up everyone would list the 5 tracks and the album, plus a paragraph or two about him, why they like him, his influence etc.

Then, after a week or two the entry will be closed and the top tracks and album listed, along with the most informative, interesting quotes.

It wouldn't be just Indie, lol.

You will have to get the ball rolling and introduce the template then. The mods like a rest now and again :D

I will, just wanting more interest first, or it won't work.

I'll see how the next days go.

sounds like a good idea

I'm thinking that each artist will get a thread for the votes and discussion. Once the results are in I will re-edit the first post with the proper write up and post a link to that thread in the main thread which will have the list.

Or something like that. This can and probably will change.