greatest band of all time compotition..
 

please vote and give a reason...

radiohead or oasis?

HAHAHA are you actually kidding?! Best band ever competition and you put Radiohead against TBS? Im so looking forward to you getting flamed!

its only round one...next it will be Foo fighters vs queen of the stone age...then oasis vs bloc party..ect

But still...Come on...And make that more clear in the title!!

theres no such thing as the best band of all time... especially if the nominations suck.

Hell no it will be a band that will live for ever Alkaline Trio vs. AFI Taking Back Sunday is good but i think that there are better bands out there. To me they are to much pop still.

who the hell are taking back sunday?!

do your parents know you are on the interenet? can you spell compotition correctly?!

Anyways - Radiohead should be in the top 10-20 bands to choose from as best band ever... surely beatles would win any real vote by the people though...

alkaline trio and AFI wont live forever...there a couple of album wonder..

And taking back sunday are not?

beatles are amazing but truly over rated...taking back sunday are an emo band, they're up there with some of the great emo bands like weezer.

i wasn't saying they wern't...i just wanted to know what type of music peopel knew about in this forum.
plus its only round one...so theres going to be ok bands

i'll change the question slightly then...

Shut up. Great emo bands are dag nasty, rites of spring, and falling forward not that shit. And stop spamming.

well sorry emo isn't my seen, because i've never heard of of those bands. but i wouldn't call weezer **** because its would be a fallacy.

I wouldnt call weezer emo by any means. If you don't understand the scene then don't over simplify.

Heck no
 

there is no way if my bands go down then so dont radio head.

weezer are aparintly ledgands of emo...thats actualy a fact.

Maybe you should try being coherant becuase I can't understand you.

Um, no. How old are you?

this thread makes me sick and the beatles we're a go send for their time, a revolutionary band. so listen 1) beatles 2)zeppelin. now shut up.

umm, yes they are...i've gone to there concerts...i've read thousands of reviews and contextual reviews. though, i dont care. my fav band is Oasis...probably the greatest english band of all time. many of times they've been voted the greatest band of alll time and i'm not one to disagree.

the beatles were evolutionary not revolutionary. also, they were origonaly a rock/pop act for little teen girls. zepplin though good, wouldn't be at number 2. you seemed to miss out the greats like: rolling stones, nirvana, pink floyd, the smiths...ect

are you seriously going to even make the claim that oasis are anywhere near the greatest english band of all time?? im astonished.
i mean, i love oasis...really.
i've got a recording of my band covering supersonic to prove it.
but good christ you must be incompitent if you can honestly believe oasis were that good.

zeppelin we're gods, i'd place them above the rolling stones although not by much, the smiths...shut up. and pink floyd although probably my favourite band next to maiden i don't believe shoould be in above zeppelin either. nirvana were **** and stupidly overrated and their music was turd in comparison with zeppelin.

yes certanly...many 100 lists the've topped. nme, seems to think so...even channel 4. Q magazine also agrees.

you just said nirvana were ****! thats rubbish there music, maybe slighly over rated, but poetical genuis they sertainly were. the smiths also an infloence for almost every grea band you hear today. zeppelin are far from gods, but they are amazing.

wasn't that for greatest album? plus if i cared what the media thought i'd be listening to the new greenday album right now courtesy of kerrang magazine, fortunately i'm not.

nirvana's music was wank, i'll stand by that claim till death. heart shaoed box is about the only decent song i've ever heard from that band.
and the smiths again pail in comparison with led zeppelin. now this is ridiculous, frankly i've got some pasta on the go, now if you we're someone worth arguing this with, maybe someone who showed some bleak sign of intelligence i'd stay, but instead i'm gonna go grate someparmizan cheese for myself.

farewell.

haha, greeday are ****ing ****...well there new stuff.

Where`s Dumpys Rusty Nuts?

:laughing: Funniest thing ive ever heard a welshman say

EDIT: For sheer pwnage...Not the Beatles thing!! Before I get lynched

I do agree with the one about weezer

This thread is ridiculous.

i agree with everything this man just said!

you! who put, what i like to call, "the led" second in the greatest band of all time! and yet ont alow me to say oasis are the greatest band of all time! well sorry sir or monkey....but you should shut up...because sorry led zep could never be number 2..because there pertensiuos..."6 good tracks on an album" compaired with the greats!

oh lord, your one of these people who i'd just like to throw stuff at for not shutting up.
also (and im just pointing it out incase ya didn't know)
its spelt 'competition'

yer, theres no need to tell me i know how to spell i just type very fast./ and ditto: i would love to frow things at you.

Uhh... the two bands that should be up there would be The Doors and Led Zeppelin.

true

one, the bands dont suck! two, its was only meant to be round one...but people have to question the new guy.