Ninetales |
08-12-2014 01:10 PM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by LoathsomePete
Panopticon - Roads To The North (2014)
So far this isn't lighting my fire the way Kentucky did, but I'm only on the second song in an hour and eleven minute album so I'll reserve full judgement till the end. I do hope that there's less an attempt to ape the European folk music because one of the main reasons I loved Kentucky so much was it felt like the first true American folk metal album.
|
First thoughts for me on Roads to the North and i think it's on par with, or atleast very close to, Kentucky. Collapse continues to be my favorite release of his but this last one has certainly not been a disappointment. Well maybe except for the excrutiatingly stereotypical album name and cover.
Quote:
Originally Posted by rostasi
I know what you're saying. For me, it's not actually repetition (which I love too - if I like the sound source),
but actually too much personality in the case of Sakamoto. Eno's Music for Airports, for instance, succeeded, for me,
because there's no pretense of "loveliness" - rather a well-chosen system utilizing well-chosen pitch aggregates.
Of course, that doesn't mean that it's not lovely (Eno) - just that it doesn't come off as trying to be -
which is what I get a little from Sakamoto's playing. In my head, I'm thinking how differently I might've
presented the "24-days/24 different keys" idea. I think I just would've liked a bit more of a melding of sonics
rather than a guy playing various harmonics at a rate/level of sameness with a backing of gentle electronics.
Are we supposed to eventually forget that Fennesz was even involved? I don't dislike it. It seems that it could've
been done with more attention to balance and less personality. There's a recording "out there" of a performance
of Fennesz with Roedelius and Autechre that I'd like to hear that I'd like to think has lots of "personality"
but wouldn't try to pretend that it doesn't. Just guessing considering the sources. Anyway, still listening...
|
hmm fair enough. I can certainly see your criticisms, even if I'm my overall attachment to the album won't change. I'm curious, do you like Cendre? I feel like it may have held more interest with you in terms of its cohesion, or at least, having a stronger Fennesz element.
|