Paul McCartney or John Lennon ?? (rock, beatles, Kurt Cobain, Nirvana)

PrettyDemented · 01-04-2006, 03:32 PM

Lennon...definately.

I think he had more of an inpact because well...he died...

~~Sabgoat~~ · 01-04-2006, 03:47 PM

this thread isn't about your favorite beatle its about who do you respect and who do YOU think had the biggest impact with you or whoever else... the question is simple and about only the TWO john & paul.. not george or ringo.. its simple who did better in your opinions.. out of the TWO not four.. grr!

john i know had the biggest impact. before he even died he was loved by so many, he was a musical god in his own right, long before his death. don't make me spam damnit!

PrettyDemented · 01-04-2006, 03:49 PM

I agree that he was a musical god

He influences my guitar playing and writing...

and I absolutely adore the song "Imagine"

but what I was saying was that you don't know what would have happened if Lennon never died...

~~Sabgoat~~ · 01-04-2006, 04:15 PM

know i completely understand what your saying. but here this out. Kurt Cobain kill himself and was in fact famous before he died. the whole band was because it was a amazing band for his voice, the writing everything. but really do you think Nirvana would still be as famous as they are if kurt never kill himself. I personally don't think so, i think personally as great as that band was they would have lost there touch. But i personlly think John lennon before he died was very much famous for everything before he died and would remain a musical god if he never died, maybe his music would have truned to crap, who really knows this for sure, but he was a musical god before he lost his life and he was noticed for it. Nirvana was indeed a great band but i don't think they would be still famous if kurt never killed himself, un like lennon who i think would have remained famous dead or not, and not just because of the songs he wrote or the way he left the beatles or the fact that there's a record out there with naked john and yoko on the cover. I think the way he was so passionet about peace, and love, just living the way he wanted to gained alot of respect in my eyes, plus he made my grand father change his views on war and all that jazz back in the 70's and trust me thats a hard thing to do, concidering my grandfather didn;t even like any type of music other then "christian music".

Urban Hat€monger ? · 01-04-2006, 04:33 PM

3 words

THE FROG CHORUS

MURDER JUNKIE · 01-04-2006, 05:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SabrinaMaher

know i completely understand what your saying. but here this out. Kurt Cobain kill himself and was in fact famous before he died. the whole band was because it was a amazing band for his voice, the writing everything. but really do you think Nirvana would still be as famous as they are if kurt never kill himself. I personally don't think so, i think personally as great as that band was they would have lost there touch. But i personlly think John lennon before he died was very much famous for everything before he died and would remain a musical god if he never died, maybe his music would have truned to crap, who really knows this for sure, but he was a musical god before he lost his life and he was noticed for it. Nirvana was indeed a great band but i don't think they would be still famous if kurt never killed himself, un like lennon who i think would have remained famous dead or not, and not just because of the songs he wrote or the way he left the beatles or the fact that there's a record out there with naked john and yoko on the cover. I think the way he was so passionet about peace, and love, just living the way he wanted to gained alot of respect in my eyes, plus he made my grand father change his views on war and all that jazz back in the 70's and trust me thats a hard thing to do, concidering my grandfather didn;t even like any type of music other then "christian music".

Um............Beatles thread...............just sayin'..............

and NO COMPARISON

sleepy jack · 01-04-2006, 05:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SabrinaMaher

know i completely understand what your saying. but here this out. Kurt Cobain kill himself and was in fact famous before he died. the whole band was because it was a amazing band for his voice, the writing everything. but really do you think Nirvana would still be as famous as they are if kurt never kill himself. I personally don't think so, i think personally as great as that band was they would have lost there touch. But i personlly think John lennon before he died was very much famous for everything before he died and would remain a musical god if he never died, maybe his music would have truned to crap, who really knows this for sure, but he was a musical god before he lost his life and he was noticed for it. Nirvana was indeed a great band but i don't think they would be still famous if kurt never killed himself, un like lennon who i think would have remained famous dead or not, and not just because of the songs he wrote or the way he left the beatles or the fact that there's a record out there with naked john and yoko on the cover. I think the way he was so passionet about peace, and love, just living the way he wanted to gained alot of respect in my eyes, plus he made my grand father change his views on war and all that jazz back in the 70's and trust me thats a hard thing to do, concidering my grandfather didn;t even like any type of music other then "christian music".

This thread is about Lennon Vs. McCarney. Not how what would happen if he lived.

George Harrison.

~~Sabgoat~~ · 01-04-2006, 05:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alexisonfire

This thread is about Lennon Vs. McCarney. Not how what would happen if he lived.

no **** after all i was the one who started it.. i was just giving a point...

stop trying to start ****!

MURDER JUNKIE · 01-04-2006, 05:30 PM

^pretty assertive for a noob

sleepy jack · 01-04-2006, 05:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SabrinaMaher

no **** after all i was the one who started it.. i was just giving a point...

stop trying to start ****!

You'd think the fact you made the thread would mean you wouldn't want spam in it, and i was pointing out you were spamming and the point you making is invalid seeing as lennon is dead.

Wait i have to make my post look more intelligent **** **** **** **** **** ****

01-04-2006, 03:32 PM	#11 (permalink)
PrettyDemented Female Rocker Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: San Francisco Posts: 56	Lennon...definately. I think he had more of an inpact because well...he died... __________________ I ain't a politician, just a bad musician Whatcha gonna do for me? Do you have a taste for sex and blood and hate Or really good LSD? I'd like to start a band with you will sing And you can learn to play the tambourine Here's an invitation...No time for hesitation Come and join my family

01-04-2006, 03:49 PM	#13 (permalink)
PrettyDemented Female Rocker Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: San Francisco Posts: 56	I agree that he was a musical god He influences my guitar playing and writing... and I absolutely adore the song "Imagine" but what I was saying was that you don't know what would have happened if Lennon never died... __________________ I ain't a politician, just a bad musician Whatcha gonna do for me? Do you have a taste for sex and blood and hate Or really good LSD? I'd like to start a band with you will sing And you can learn to play the tambourine Here's an invitation...No time for hesitation Come and join my family

01-04-2006, 04:33 PM	#15 (permalink)
Urban Hat€monger ? The Sexual Intellectual Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Somewhere cooler than you Posts: 18,605	3 words THE FROG CHORUS __________________ Urb's RYM Stuff Most people sell their soul to the devil, but the devil sells his soul to Nick Cave.

01-04-2006, 03:47 PM	#12 (permalink)
~~Sabgoat~~ Account Disabled Join Date: Dec 2005 Posts: 303	this thread isn't about your favorite beatle its about who do you respect and who do YOU think had the biggest impact with you or whoever else... the question is simple and about only the TWO john & paul.. not george or ringo.. its simple who did better in your opinions.. out of the TWO not four.. grr! john i know had the biggest impact. before he even died he was loved by so many, he was a musical god in his own right, long before his death. don't make me spam damnit!

01-04-2006, 04:15 PM	#14 (permalink)
~~Sabgoat~~ Account Disabled Join Date: Dec 2005 Posts: 303	know i completely understand what your saying. but here this out. Kurt Cobain kill himself and was in fact famous before he died. the whole band was because it was a amazing band for his voice, the writing everything. but really do you think Nirvana would still be as famous as they are if kurt never kill himself. I personally don't think so, i think personally as great as that band was they would have lost there touch. But i personlly think John lennon before he died was very much famous for everything before he died and would remain a musical god if he never died, maybe his music would have truned to crap, who really knows this for sure, but he was a musical god before he lost his life and he was noticed for it. Nirvana was indeed a great band but i don't think they would be still famous if kurt never killed himself, un like lennon who i think would have remained famous dead or not, and not just because of the songs he wrote or the way he left the beatles or the fact that there's a record out there with naked john and yoko on the cover. I think the way he was so passionet about peace, and love, just living the way he wanted to gained alot of respect in my eyes, plus he made my grand father change his views on war and all that jazz back in the 70's and trust me thats a hard thing to do, concidering my grandfather didn;t even like any type of music other then "christian music".

01-04-2006, 05:30 PM	#19 (permalink)
MURDER JUNKIE The Wetter The Better!! Join Date: Aug 2005 Location: SH1TTY London Ontario Canada Posts: 2,504	^pretty assertive for a noob