TheBig3

It's over now and it was a soild year for albums. List your top three and then the three that disappointed you the most. List a few reasons and then we'll rip each other apart over eveyone else stupid picks. Yes, the OP is condoning fights, lets not bother with opinion here.

I would like to institue a few rules though:

1. Has to be new material; complilations, live albums, and reissues are out for this particular thread.

2. Three for each. I'd like to ask the mods to delete posts that don't have three for each. I can foresee people only listing bad ones, or listing 105 for their favorites. If someone lists more or less then you guys feel free to delete or add in the albums of your choosing (the mods I mean).

3. Double albums count as one release. Even if they weren't released together.

__________________
I've moved to a new address

sleepy jack

Best:
Bullet For My Valentine "The Poison"
I <3 it i think its good fun metal music with a nice "fake emo" influence lyrically and vocally.
Thrice "Vheissu"
The lyrics are genius its way softer then anything else they've done, its an extremely solid album and flows very nicely.
Coheed and Cambria "Good Apollo I'm Burning Star IV etc.."
The story the album telling is brilliant, and the guitaring is very very good and the songwriting is well put together and it flows nicely.

Worst:
Darkness "One Way Ticket To Hell"
The 80s are over and hearing the same un original music is getting lame and do something new and wear some clothes christ
Audioslave "Out Of Exile"
Grunge is done, and you've managed to release a crappier version of your last album. Amazing.
Weezer "Make Believe"
Yes, it sounds like everything else you released, beverly hills = lame-o hit song.

Yes, i hate the albums that are boring and sound like everything else they've done just my opinion though.

__________________

IamAlejo

Since we are supposed to rip others apart....those 3 albums are basically shiit. Maybe not Bullet for my Valentine, which is half shiit, but the other 2 are basically complete shiit.

__________________

a man, a plan, a canal, panama

sleepy jack

You know what my retort is?
YOUR complete shit.
Actually i think the albums are kind of an aquired taste.
Maybe not BFMV's but the other two are.

__________________

Scarlett O'Hara

It's you're...

__________________

Wild7Dustr

[QUOTE=Alexisonfire]
Worst:
Darkness "One Way Ticket To Hell"
The 80s are over and hearing the same un original music is getting lame and do something new and wear some clothes christ
Audioslave "Out Of Exile"
Grunge is done, and you've managed to release a crappier version of your last album. Amazing.
Weezer "Make Believe"
Yes, it sounds like everything else you released, beverly hills = lame-o hit song. QUOTE]

Alright, 1st of all I've gotta agree with you on the Weezer song being really cheesy and all, but I think that's just there natural style, ya know?Of course the song's a hit, but I wouldn't care whether a song's either a hit or not as long as it was good music!!!Some of the riffs/music seem alright for a basic rockin' tune, but the part that ruins that song is that bi tch in the background saying "gimme, gimme" all too much!!!Some songs get overplayed and you might start getting a little sick of hearing it....
...With this one song, with the girl sayin' "gimme, gimme" so many damn times, it only makes you sick of the song even faster than originally!!! One thing I gotta say is if they're (Weezer) gonna use her to sing that song for every show, every tour, they might as well put in a handpuppet and have the handpuppet set off explosions and, therefore, kill that annoying sound that the girl sings!!!
With the Audioslave one, I agree that their music is definitely getting worse!!!Ya gotta give some credit to their 1st disc for being pretty good, but the 2nd then proved to be way worse!!!Rage was what it was all about and they've quickly lost much of that energy/greatness!!!If they even put out a 3rd album together, well, I'll just leave ya with this...
...It's 3 strikes, now you're out!!!

Urban Hat€monger ?

I posted some of this somewhere else but it won`t hurt to do it again here

Best
Eels - Blinking Lights & Other Revelations

I just love the way Eels albums just come out of nowhere with little hype & little fanfare & continually be of an excellent standard.Although it`s a double album it doesn`t fall into the trap of having half good stuff & half rubbish.You can see that a lot of thought has gone into this record.I`ve no doubt this album will probably get ignored in favour of more albums by 'current indie darlings' but I don`t really care , I know it`s great & that`ll do for me

Super Furry Animals - Lovekraft
Simple reason really , their first 2 albums were 2 of the most wonderful eclectic albums i`d ever heard.And then they spent the last 7 years releasing uninspiring rubbish.This was a return to form of the old SFA & when that band are on top form nobody comes close.

Goldie Lookin Chain - Safe As F*ck

Because in one of the most depressing years I can remember in music for a while and with all the Live 8 crap and bands taking themselves far far too seriously , I just think it`s great that a bunch of welsh rappers can take the piss out of everything.And they`re about a million times funnier than Tenacious D ever were.

Biggest Disapointments

Dandy Warhols - Odditorium & The Warlords Of Mars
Wank wank wank wank wank , how on earth do you release a double album with NO good songs on it at all.Is this really the same band that made all those great singles circa 2000?

QOTSA - Lullabies To Paradise
Too many guest appearences which in my mind gave the album a lack of direction & made it totally unfocused.It`s a really difficult balance when you work like that , they pulled it off for SFTD , but not here sadly.A shame because I was really looking forward too it.

White Stripes - Get Behind Me Satan

As far as I am concerned the White Stripes can do anything & i`ll buy it.The one thing they can`t do is be boring , this album was DULL.I appreciate they`re trying to work from a broader canvas from what they`re usually known for , but if you`ve not got the songs to back it up it falls flat on it`s arse.And thats the biggest shame , none of the songs on this album grabbed me at all. I hope it`s just a blip & we have a back to basics album coming out from them next.

__________________

Black_Jack_Davey

I'm hurt. The songs are there. Blue Orchid. Denial Twist. Take, Take, Take. Red Rain. I'm Lonely (But I Ain't That Lonely Yet). It was a lot different for Jack, he took a step back from electric guitar. But this album rocks. It is something new and exciting for the White Stripes, and just as they managed to kick ass on Elephant, they completely reinvented themselves and still kicked ass on Satan. It is the album they needed to release to be set apart from the 'garage rock' talk. They will entertain you whether it's electric guitar, piano, marimba, mandolin, or acoustic. I think you need to listen to the Stripes first three records (Elephant was well-produced) and realize how huge of a progression they've made, from being a Detroit garage rock duo to rock and roll idols.

__________________
Would you forsake your house and home
Would you forsake your baby
Would you forsake your husband too

shiftael

(In no particular order, both ways)

Best:
Interpol - Antics
Drive by Truuckers - The Dirty South
Modest Mouse - Good News for People who Love Bad News

Worst - (in my case most disappointing, was looking forward to all these releases)
Daft Punk - Human After All
Moby - Hotel
Fear Factory - Transgression

Expletive Deleted

Welcome to last year, sir.