I'm sure I know where it's from, but it's escaping me now. 8/10 because it's a .gif, and not many people use them.

Goofle, my old one was from Lemony Snicket.

Pretty cool, not as good as your last one though. 7/10

4/10 Meh. Pic is boring, and the colors are muted to the point of looking ****ty.

Pet_sounds: I preferred the old one but crocs/alligators are cool and I love the way it works with the title so 8/10

Blaro: cool but the flashing colours give me a headache so have to deduct: 7/10

Batty: always first with a Christmas avatar, and damn funny too! 9.6/10

Incidentally, who wants to see Summer in a Santy hat? ;)

Yeah! It would improve your rating from a 9/10 to a 10/10.

8/10. A step up from your last one.

4/10 It was meh to begin with, and familiarity is jerking off contempt.

10/10. Baddass, Funny, Amazing Artwork.

Here ya go!
:)
Justin, what is it with you and monkeys? 6/10

7/10 Not the best photoshop job for sure.