Just as planned.
Although I suppose the Horned One Between The Trees would kill accompanied by something way more evil than "Holy Diver".
Yours is kinda unassuming, plus I'm no TS fan. But the understated nature of it is pleases me, so let's say 6/10.

And yours is?......^

Is what?

You ninja-ed me.

You again ;) 9/10, i think.
I was wondering, what is it? A deer?

Random musician avatars are so obvious on a music forum that they bore me, and that one's pretty meh, too. 4/10

Chicks from drawings who would be average in real life get a 3/10 at this point. Come up with something better.

Does nobody get that it's not a "hot chick avatar"?

Nope. Nobody gives a **** but you.