Music Banter - Official Mental Health Thread

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)

- Current Events, Philosophy, & Religion (https://www.musicbanter.com/current-events-philosophy-religion/)

- - Official Mental Health Thread (https://www.musicbanter.com/current-events-philosophy-religion/91965-official-mental-health-thread.html)

Quote:

Originally Posted by DwnWthVwls (Post 2064694)

Im not on a high horse. I asked a genuine question and offended our most offensive member. Idk what you want me to say.

Seriously, troll a different thread.

Hey people who provide care, the science isnt out yet but why dont you stop being slackers and do better with tools you dont have.

Hey OH, is that really the case?

“Im offended.”

Quote:

Originally Posted by DwnWthVwls (Post 2064699)

Hey people who provide care, the science isnt out yet but why dont you stop being slackers and do better with tools you dont have.

Hey OH, is that really the case?

“Im offended.”

Straw man a different thread.

Im mot trolling. I asked for a justification of your criticism and also provided a personal example asking how i could possibly be accurately diagnosed given the randomness of occurrence. How do you propose doctors diagnose the call of the void i previously mentioned?

Quote:

Originally Posted by OccultHawk (Post 2064701)

Straw man a different thread.

You realize asking a question isnt a strawman? Im not making an argument. I was curious how you came to your conclusion about current treatment. Comparing the diagnosis and treatment of a mental disorder to a broken arm seems like something that can be reasonably questioned to me. Maybe i could have phrased it better but im still not sure how you get off comparing the two.

If you did know what you were talking about you could have told me “no, they should be doing xyz but instead they abc because blah blah”.

Quote:

Originally Posted by OccultHawk (Post 2064689)

*hippocampus

My post was simply stating that physiological nature of the ailment should be investigated when a patient has symptoms indicative of a mental disorder. And every human experience including every emotion and every thought is only physiology. There’s nothing about that even remotely invites a critique. The only criticism possible is either an irrelevant personal jab at me or an argument that mental health care doesn’t need to be improved.

You said brain scans should be required before the diagnosis of a mental illness and implied that people that diagnose them don't know anything about neurology.

1st is critiqued by the simple fact that brain scans don't always catch mental illness and 2nd is just a false statement since psychiatrists, the ones that prescribe medicine to treat mental illness, are required to work in neurology for at least 6 months. Even psychologists, from what I understand, need to have a certain understanding of neurology in order to get a degree.

It's not personal. Not on my end.

OH is just bitter that his psychiatrist won't return his calls.

Quote:

Originally Posted by OccultHawk (Post 2064696)

Ive kept it civil.

I post that the people who provide care should understand the neurology. And the response I get is what do you even know about the neurology. I never claimed to be qualified to provide care so outside of trolling explain to me the value of that question.

It's one thing to bitch about it, it's another thing to be a bitch about it. You're looking for reasons to be in your feelings about it.

FTR im still curious what those of you that have gone through the process think needs to be improved besides accessibility. I just deal with **** on my own and pop a small dose of xanax on rare occasion. I dont like the idea of meds cause they seem to fix one thing and break 5 others.