Welcome jayshreddz as our newest moderator!

crash_override · 03-28-2012, 01:20 PM

This decision blows.

GuitarBizarre · 03-28-2012, 01:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Unknown Soldier

Just seen this thread as well, it seems to be the old case of a newbie being handed a plum position and the others not liking it.........its human nature I suppose. Basically Jayshreddz has just come in and he doesn't know the community and the community doesn't know him, basically just give the guy some slack and judge him after a reasonable period of time and not before he's even started.

It really isn't that. Before Jay was modded his posting was so bad people were literally sure he was a troll that was going to be banned within a few days. That reaction wasn't bull****, that was because his posts were TERRIBLE and he had already earned a bad reputation.

Then we find out he's a mod all of a sudden? Yeah. Expect a bad reaction.

Dr_Rez · 03-28-2012, 01:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pedestrian

Thank you, Pete.

It's ignorant generalizations of our staff as seen above your post that really make me want to give the users what they seem to want and start doing fuck all, then see if they notice a difference.

I had something fun planned for April, but maybe I won't put in the effort now.

pfffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff ffffffff

You are a kick ass mod. Dont listen to anything or anyone. Especially with organizing the weekly themed threads and many other things. We need more like you in fact.

/ass kissing over

Paedantic Basterd · 03-28-2012, 01:26 PM

Thanks Rezz, though if I remember correctly, I was one of those freshies that was modded when you also applied.

Dr_Rez · 03-28-2012, 01:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pedestrian

Thanks Rezz, though if I remember correctly, I was one of those freshies that was modded when you also applied.

Yea but as I also mentioned not all of them were bad. I think you are the only one or maybe 1/2 that are actually left. Maybe the other is Freebase, but he is a fantastic mod as well. I shall speak of this no more I feel the ban hammer near!

Unknown Soldier · 03-28-2012, 02:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GuitarBizarre

It really isn't that. Before Jay was modded his posting was so bad people were literally sure he was a troll that was going to be banned within a few days. That reaction wasn't bull****, that was because his posts were TERRIBLE and he had already earned a bad reputation.

Then we find out he's a mod all of a sudden? Yeah. Expect a bad reaction.

Certain people when they enter a new forum for the first time and are not used to the way things work and the nuances of the forum etc. They can come-off as bit antagonistic, especially when they start giving out different opinions or vibes and are also not really susbstantiating their opinions either, I wouldn't call this being a troll, I would just call it a newbie trying to find his feet a bit and most either do after a while or just end up leaving or getting banned. A troll is different, this is somebody on a mission to cause problems and usually hijacks threads to do so or starts up threads guranteed to cause a stir. Classic trollls have included Cherry Picker (I think that was the name, the guy that stated every band had ripped off the Beatles and rock music didn't really exist before them) The Virgin, Erasertime and Franco Pepe Kalle, none of these guys were/are insulting but they knew hold to invest time in a thread, that was sure to antagonize a certain amount of members on here.

GuitarBizarre · 03-28-2012, 02:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Unknown Soldier

Certain people when they enter a new forum for the first time and are not used to the way things work and the nuances of the forum etc. They can come-off as bit antagonistic, especially when they start giving out different opinions or vibes and are also not really susbstantiating their opinions either, I wouldn't call this being a troll, I would just call it a newbie trying to find his feet a bit and most either do after a while or just end up leaving or getting banned. A troll is different, this is somebody on a mission to cause problems and usually hijacks threads to do so or starts up threads guranteed to cause a stir. Classic trollls have included Cherry Picker (I think that was the name, the guy that stated every band had ripped off the Beatles and rock music didn't really exist before them) The Virgin, Erasertime and Franco Pepe Kalle, none of these guys were/are insulting but they knew hold to invest time in a thread, that was sure to antagonize a certain amount of members on here.

Please, go and read Jay's post history.

Unknown Soldier · 03-28-2012, 02:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GuitarBizarre

Please, go and read Jay's post history.

Ok you've twisted my arm, I'll do it.

MoonlitSunshine · 03-28-2012, 02:10 PM

For the second time: There is more to the moderation of a forum than being involved in the community and helping its growth. It's great when you have a team which can both "moderate" and help the forum develop, but in my own experience of hiring mods (forum with 6 million posts, 100,000 registered users and 3,000 active users, and a three-tiered team of over 30 moderators, I know what I'm talking about), you can't always get people who have everything.

Satch has said it before, and I know other people have as well - the way mods are recruited on this forum is great, for one aspect of moderation. When it comes to dealing out the letter of the law, it IS harder to be just when you know the people involved. It DOES lead to a group where the "accepted" members of the community receive better treatment than outcasts/newbies. It's generally not intentional, but even the most just of people generate small bias over time.

So Jayshreddz didn't make the best of first impressions. I honestly couldn't care less under the circumstances. he has implied that his job here has nothing to do with what is considered here to be the standard moderating role. There is far, far more to the running of a forum than being well-liked, responsible and contributing. Noone here knows anything about him or his qualifications, so as far as I'm concerned he could be far more qualified for his particular role than any of the volunteer mods here.

Finally, this is presumably a source of income for the owners of the website. Presumably, they want someone they trust relatively involved in the moderating and the development of the site, in order to maximise profit. A random volunteer from the forum isn't going to necessarily have their best interests at heart.

FETCHER. · 03-28-2012, 02:11 PM

In all seriousness I thought it was a joke because I thought he was a troll...

03-28-2012, 02:10 PM	#239 (permalink)
MoonlitSunshine Dat's Der Bunny! Join Date: Jul 2006 Location: Ireland Posts: 1,088	For the second time: There is more to the moderation of a forum than being involved in the community and helping its growth. It's great when you have a team which can both "moderate" and help the forum develop, but in my own experience of hiring mods (forum with 6 million posts, 100,000 registered users and 3,000 active users, and a three-tiered team of over 30 moderators, I know what I'm talking about), you can't always get people who have everything. Satch has said it before, and I know other people have as well - the way mods are recruited on this forum is great, for one aspect of moderation. When it comes to dealing out the letter of the law, it IS harder to be just when you know the people involved. It DOES lead to a group where the "accepted" members of the community receive better treatment than outcasts/newbies. It's generally not intentional, but even the most just of people generate small bias over time. So Jayshreddz didn't make the best of first impressions. I honestly couldn't care less under the circumstances. he has implied that his job here has nothing to do with what is considered here to be the standard moderating role. There is far, far more to the running of a forum than being well-liked, responsible and contributing. Noone here knows anything about him or his qualifications, so as far as I'm concerned he could be far more qualified for his particular role than any of the volunteer mods here. Finally, this is presumably a source of income for the owners of the website. Presumably, they want someone they trust relatively involved in the moderating and the development of the site, in order to maximise profit. A random volunteer from the forum isn't going to necessarily have their best interests at heart. __________________ "I found it eventually, at the bottom of a locker in a disused laboratory, with a sign on the door saying "Beware of the Leopard". Ever thought of going into Advertising?" - Arthur Dent

03-28-2012, 01:26 PM	#234 (permalink)
Paedantic Basterd Music Addict Join Date: Sep 2010 Posts: 5,184	Thanks Rezz, though if I remember correctly, I was one of those freshies that was modded when you also applied.