Urban Hat€monger ?

It's your forum, you decide what goes down here.
This poll is for mod feedback purposes only.

If people feel strongly about it one way or another we may act on it.

We're talking about people who continually post youtube videos with no explanation or any other content to the post.

Should we allow it or not?

Should it be treated as spam?

Tell us.

__________________

Psy-Fi

If there's no explanation or any other content to the post, and that's all they ever do when they post here, Then it seems like a form of spam to me.

Necromancer

I think there should be at least be a daily limit on how many youtube videos should be allowed by any one member.

Say a limit of three ?

To be honest, most people never even play/watch the videos posted anyway. Especially if they are mainstream and popular songs that everybody has already heard before that they are already familiar with. I understand adding a video to help reinforce an ongoing debate and so on.

After all, this is a music discussion forum. And if you don't want to discuss music, then go to the Lounge forums or shout box.

That's my (brief) opinion on the subject anyway.

VEGANGELICA

Posting youtube videos with no explanation or any other content to the post should be allowed.

Some people aren't talkers or can't easily express their feelings about music in words, and so they share with others in the community by sharing the music itself.

I rarely find myself without something to say ... but I don't want moderators to fault those members whose gab gift is less gifty or who choose, for whatever reason, to post just the music without commentary.

__________________

lucifer_sam

What is with this democratic horseshit?

Everything should use moderator's discretion, there's just simply no way you could enforce it black and white.

__________________
first.am

The Batlord

Why the hell should it be treated as spam? Youtube threads and What Are You Currently Listening To threads are just spam threads anyway. I don't get why anyone would care, they're not selling anything or posting random Youtube videos in inappropriate threads. **** it!

__________________

Urban Hat€monger ?

There isn't a rule on this so how can we enforce a rule that doesn't exist?
The point of this thread is to see if members think it's a big enough problem to make a ruling on.

And most of the rules here are there because members wanted them so this democratic horseshit isn't really anything new.

We're not talking about those threads, that's why they're in the games, list, polls & jokes forum & not any of the music forums.
This is about people who continually do it in the music forums.

__________________

skaltezon

^ ^ ^


Demonstrate how that's done, please.


No, those threads are in the music forums:

Music Banter > The Music Forums > General Music
Favourite Music Videos Favourite Music Videos


Music Banter > The Music Forums > General Music
What Are You Listening To Right Now? II

Urban Hat€monger ?

And if you look at that thread you'll see that a large majority of people chose to say why they like it as well as posting the video, which is what we want in the music forum so I'm not sure why you're telling me this.


From the first post in that thread...

If anything by showing those two threads you're just highlighting the problem that some members have expressed.
So thanks for that.

__________________

Freebase Dali

I'd say: It depends.

In one hand, I don't see a problem with people posting youtube music vids only in threads that lend itself to that sort of thing, or if the person is a contributing member. But in the other, if there's a user that does nothing but post youtube vids (I.E. Lovesong) in every thread they post in, adding no meaningful content, then yea... that's spam.