Creative Forum (rock, members, quote, talented, song)

[riseagainstrocks]

This site is called MusicBanter

therefore our threads are about Music. Hell if I had my way, the Lounge wouldn't exist. The songwriting forum is up because it directly relates to music. There are plenty of other forums for art. And if you want to post it here, put it the Lounge or the Games/Spam sub-forum.

[explosions-in-my-pants]

Originally Posted by riseagainstrocks

This site is called MusicBanter

therefore our threads are about Music. Hell if I had my way, the Lounge wouldn't exist. The songwriting forum is up because it directly relates to music. There are plenty of other forums for art. And if you want to post it here, put it the Lounge or the Games/Spam sub-forum.

The way you spoke in this msg, sounds like your the mod with all the say.

i think its a good idea.. I know this is about msuic.. but still music is a artform, so why not bring in a little of other type of art areas... gives us something to do when not many people are posting in the music forums.. plus it can bring new people in.

[sleepy jack]

Originally Posted by riseagainstrocks

This site is called MusicBanter

therefore our threads are about Music. Hell if I had my way, the Lounge wouldn't exist. The songwriting forum is up because it directly relates to music. There are plenty of other forums for art. And if you want to post it here, put it the Lounge or the Games/Spam sub-forum.

Agreed, thats pretty much what I was gonna say..

[right-track]

Originally Posted by riseagainstrocks

This site is called MusicBanter

therefore our threads are about Music. Hell if I had my way, the Lounge wouldn't exist. The songwriting forum is up because it directly relates to music. There are plenty of other forums for art. And if you want to post it here, put it the Lounge or the Games/Spam sub-forum.

Originally Posted by Crowquill

Agreed, thats pretty much what I was gonna say..

I'm gonna disagree.
First and foremost, yes this is a music forum, but the attached non music forums seem to attract new members and help keep the current members posting here on MusicBanter.
The 'Arcade' being the case in point.

I really can't see what harm a 'Creative Forum' can cause. After all, quite a few of the members who post here may have initially been attracted by the 'Songwriting' forum, which I agree is music related, but without it would the likes of hobojesus, DRMO, Crow etc. choose to stay?
I'm sure a 'Creative Forum' would prove popular among those members just mentioned, amongst others.
It sounds like a good idea and at least should be given a try.

[littleknowitall]

Originally Posted by right-track

I'm gonna disagree.
First and foremost, yes this is a music forum, but the attached non music forums seem to attract new members and help keep the current members posting here on MusicBanter.
The 'Arcade' being the case in point.

I really can't see what harm a 'Creative Forum' can cause. After all, quite a few of the members who post here may have initially been attracted by the 'Songwriting' forum, which I agree is music related, but without it would the likes of hobojesus, DRMO, crow etc choose to stay?
I'm sure a 'Creative Forum' would prove popular among those members just mentioned, amongst others.
It sounds like a good idea and at least should be given a try.

thank god a od on our side. there should be a general forum vote, somebody make a poll already.

[sleepy jack]

Originally Posted by right-track

I'm gonna disagree.
First and foremost, yes this is a music forum, but the attached non music forums seem to attract new members and help keep the current members posting here on MusicBanter.
The 'Arcade' being the case in point.

I really can't see what harm a 'Creative Forum' can cause. After all, quite a few of the members who post here may have initially been attracted by the 'Songwriting' forum, which I agree is music related, but without it would the likes of hobojesus, DRMO, Crow etc. choose to stay?
I'm sure a 'Creative Forum' would prove popular among those members just mentioned, amongst others.
It sounds like a good idea and at least should be given a try.

I'm sure you can find a creative arts forum on the net somewhere that you can join. I don't think we should sit here and add every little single forum. It would make this site more of a general forum then a music forum.

[right-track]

Originally Posted by Crowquill

I don't think we should sit here and add every little single forum. It would make this site more of a general forum then a music forum.

Agreed, I don't think there should be too many music unrelated forums added...unless it was a good idea...this one is.
If the people want it...let em' have it.

Personally I don't care either way, but if it improves MB and proves popular...it's all good.