The Beatles Discography: Ranked

Mooneh · 03-21-2013, 12:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Powerstars

I like "Within You, Without You," it's just that I feel it goes on too long. I understand they were trying to experiment with longer songs, but that is not one that should've gone one for terribly long. "A Day In The Life," goes on for just as long, and I cannot get enough of it.

It could of ended around 3:41, I'll say that. The end verse is sort of unnecessary but it's okay. Still a kick ass song.

Powerstars · 03-26-2013, 04:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mooneh

It could of ended around 3:41, I'll say that. The end verse is sort of unnecessary but it's okay. Still a kick ass song.

Agreed.

juanxtwoxthree · 08-09-2013, 02:30 PM

First off, nice job on this project. It definitely spurred me on to give the songs/albums a more thorough listen.

The only thing that really stood out to me was that you called "Something" the best love song of all time. While I LOVE that song to death, I would never call it the best love song of all time. Perhaps it can enter in a discussion regarding the best expression of deep feelings for someone & the feeling of mystery and excitement that comes with not knowing what the future with them holds.

However,

I don't think it is best expressive of what 'love' is. Unfortunately, love's definition has become quite unclear due to the word's overuse & careless treatment.

I think the song that best expresses love -- done so in a beautifully poetic way -- is "Make You Feel My Love" by none other than Dylan himself. It is not as much about the emotions/feelings one may have for someone they love as "Something" is, but it definitely sings love in its purest & most sincere form.

Cheers.

08-09-2013, 02:30 PM	#3 (permalink)
juanxtwoxthree Groupie Join Date: Aug 2013 Posts: 1	"Something is the best love song of all time" First off, nice job on this project. It definitely spurred me on to give the songs/albums a more thorough listen. The only thing that really stood out to me was that you called "Something" the best love song of all time. While I LOVE that song to death, I would never call it the best love song of all time. Perhaps it can enter in a discussion regarding the best expression of deep feelings for someone & the feeling of mystery and excitement that comes with not knowing what the future with them holds. However, I don't think it is best expressive of what 'love' is. Unfortunately, love's definition has become quite unclear due to the word's overuse & careless treatment. I think the song that best expresses love -- done so in a beautifully poetic way -- is "Make You Feel My Love" by none other than Dylan himself. It is not as much about the emotions/feelings one may have for someone they love as "Something" is, but it definitely sings love in its purest & most sincere form. Cheers.