Because they all make bland unoriginal music. Many will disagree, many will agree.

That guy PMed me a million times
Just 'cause I said I didn't like his review
:rolleyes:

IIIIIIII certinaly agreeee

I will sort the PM situ out for you.

Well I think he's stopped now
I hope
I kept telling him over and over again to :rolleyes:

you people are so centred around egotistical beleifs. these sites are forums, they are sociable areas for people to talk about music. You two are so damn arrogant that its unreal. i think those reviews contain character, interest, and great information. i think you need to grow up and get out more!!!

People don't like the band , no need to take it personally.

So is this thread still about biffy Clyro or ?

yeah, well in a abusive sense.

What is your problem? Because I don't like the bands that were mentioned you have a hissy fit. I have not mentioned at any time the actual review and my views pertaining to it. I made a (admittedly) flippant remark but I have already commented on that. You smack of arrogance if you cannot handle any crticism. i have reviewed Pink Floyd on another thread and all comments are appreciated good or bad. Complaining if someone has a different view to you with the retort "damn arrogant" is arrogance itself.

You have PMd fellow members if they have replied to your thread (including myself) which could lead to a ban because you are spamming PM box's. Of course I am not going to do this because debate should be encouraged, however you have to accept different views or at least provide a good counter argument and not call people arrogant and egotistical.

I hope this draws a line underneath it now.

The question is... does this:-


Warrrant this:-

bit harsh?

Regardless of what was said between mark and jackhammer in PM it was said in a public forum where people such as I (a biffy clyro and review fan) have to read it.
Even though everyone is (pretty much) allowed to share their opinion there are some comments that will create a backlash and some that won't, it's having the hindsight to see it coming and the conviction to justify it that will stop people thinking you're a tosser.
Even though nothing negative was said about BC it was an incredibly narrowminded/unfunny comment to add. All it accomplished was to highlight how narrowminded jackhammer is.
I don't know jackhammer from a bar of soap but on first impressions I know that from now on whenever I read a comment made my him I shall think back to the narrowminded comment he made in the BC: puzzle thread, it that too harsh?
Personally I think the review was outstanding and I feel that the only credibility that was lost in this thread was that of jackhammers.
But hey thats just my opinion.

P.s. can I also add another jackhammer quote from another thread
musicbanter.com/indie-alternative/28634-teenage-fanclub-2.html

Take some of your own advice.