Quote:
Originally Posted by anticipation
The Elysian fields have been widely misinterpreted as a the Greek equivilent of Valhalla, which it is in no way like. What I mean when I say everyone goes to the same place is that both the most immoral kings and purist peasants both went to the Underworld, where Elysium is located. Even Achilles, when he died, said that he would rather have lived in obscurity forever than to die young and famous. Greek mythology had no moral values, it had no central text, and it certainly didn't have the gods handing down orders like most Judeo-Christian religions. Most of the ideas concerning the judgement of man comes from Roman interpretation of ancient Greek myths. It's really only in Virgil's Elysium that we see the idea of a pleasant afterlife in Greek mythology.
|
Considering how little is really known about these beliefs, you seem to be making some sketchy assumptions I think. I agree that as far as I know, morality wasn't as central a theme in greek mythology, but that doesn't mean it wasn't at all important.
From Wikipedia's article on Greek Underworld :
Quote:
|
Philosophers such as Plato and the mystic Orphics and Pythagoreans include the concept of the judgement of the dead. Spirits were assigned to one of three realms: Elysium for the blessed, Tartarus for the damned, and Asphodel for the rest. Further, they believed in reincarnation and the transmigration of souls.
|
So after dying, you are judged and that decides where in the Underworld you end up. It doesn't say here that the blessed are necessarily those of strong moral fiber, but there are stories like that of Sisyphus who was an "evil" king who got sent to Tartarus where he famously had to spend eternity rolling a boulder up a hillside. It's a story about an evil man who got punished by Zeus and that implies moral values.